• We're looking for artists. Direct message Dr. Watson for more info!

Game Ranked Dune Mafia - town victory

Status
Not open for further replies.
Her rational for claiming right away, even if she's town, is probably still fake and really only serves to establish some continuity in her gay "meta", for example even though it's obviously detrimental
Well that's what I'm saying to you, like that's the issue I had mainly. I agree, it is fake, there's no way she is asking because she doesn't know who to target. But you presented it as something that's scummy for her which it's not. Actually think it's more likely to come from her as town, because she's a selfish player who is not thinking about how to solve, but how to claim her role.

Anyway, Unvote

Your thoughts make more sense if you're trying to hold her to a standard rather than actually suspecting her for it. Will step back for a bit to see where you go next.

Vote: @Aurelian Let's go, time to start playing
 
But go ahead.

The worse thing thst can happen is i die and go to deadchat and i dont know, start a new game?

My question is, when i flip town when i die, will you consider my reads, or will you still call them fake?

Cause i have a track record of catching scum the first 2 hours of a game.
This feels timid Christmas Guillo wouldnt just roll over and accept Poysers push and even comtemplate being lynched, hes self righteous and will let him know loudly that hes wrong. Thats the impression I got from Guillo in the Christmas game.
 
I may have exaggerated the extent to which I am scum reading her
RFFR


I don't know why you thought my point was phoned in then, you're basically admitting that I was correct in reading that your suspicion was not fully genuine.
 
The voting him struck me like OMGUS lol.
Oh yeah, it was OMGUS. And I'd go further and say that, in some of his responses, he is arguing just for the sake of arguing, like when he responded to Poyser saying that he wouldn't think his reads were fake with "why wouldn't my reads be fake as town". But timid is someone averse to getting into arguments, that's the opposite lol. That's someone who is arguing to the point of being ridiculous.
 
This feels timid Christmas Guillo wouldnt just roll over and accept Poysers push and even comtemplate being lynched, hes self righteous and will let him know loudly that hes wrong. Thats the impression I got from Guillo in the Christmas game.
I disagree here. If I had the inclination, I could pull up several posts that he made on Christmas where he was happy to accept being lynched and made a point to say that he didn't care if it happened or not.
 
I disagree here. If I had the inclination, I could pull up several posts that he made on Christmas where he was happy to accept being lynched and made a point to say that he didn't care if it happened or not.
Can you show me.
 
@Fujishiro

I think the last one alone should be enough. Makes it pretty clear that, if he's pressured, he's happy to roll over and take the lynch rather than stand and fight it.
 
RFFR


I don't know why you thought my point was phoned in then, you're basically admitting that I was correct in reading that your suspicion was not fully genuine.

Well I still think it's a little easy to just say Flower is town and vote me and call it a day

I don't expect Flower to actually consider why I'm pressuring her, but you didn't consider my scum angle in going for her as opposed to just writing her off as town
 
Well I still think it's a little easy to just say Flower is town and vote me and call it a day

I don't expect Flower to actually consider why I'm pressuring her, but you didn't consider my scum angle in going for her as opposed to just writing her off as town
I mean it is but, I haven't called it a day. I know what you're saying, and I do agree that generally, it's easier to just town read her and not bother with it. Just don't think that's enough to look past something that rang ingenuine. What I didn't consider, and this is why I unvoted, was that you could be putting the screws to her to make her play better rather than enable objectively scummy play, which you've basically admitted was the case.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top