• We're looking for artists. Direct message Dr. Watson for more info!

Game Ranked OLF Christmas Mafia 2023 (Day 9)

I’m largely fine with it being host discretion, I’d just hope that hosts can see why it’s bad

You take away the right of the accused to defend themselves. I know that’s not a rule enshrined in the game, but it’s a central tenet of a game based on accusation
Defend themselves against what? Joe Biden? Which most people aren't even going to notice anyway? Meh
 
fuji/flower,
Yo, I only do that when I think he‘s Town or want to buddy him as scum. We‘ve had a long term rivalry ever since I mislynched him in his sleep. Don‘t think we wouldn‘t fight each other xD.
 
Lmfao no you don‘t get to do this after WoT. You knew exactly what you were doing.
no flower because in WoT it was in the rules that breaking a global town PR gets u modkilled, and even then, the rules didn't say you CANT get yourself modkilled

here not only the rules didnt say anything, but also the PR was given by an unlimited shot role lol. it seemed like a joke PR role and wud never modkill as a punishment so i took the gamble

it is what it is
 
like i said lots of ppl need to start rolling scum more cuz the variety is getting boring asfk
 
I just don't see how that's realistically going to be enforced tbh, it'd get violated constantly by people not even realizing night has started. We still get multiple people posting during night accidentally as it is. I think complaining about reacts is fairly precious tbh
Yeah that’s what I said also, it would be a bitch to police and I’m not really for disabling reacts entirely
 
it seems very predictable every game 2 t1's r scum, 2 inactives r scum, and 2 midcarders r scum

every game it's the same

i sometimes start to doubt if it's actually properly randed
 
no flower because in WoT it was in the rules that breaking a global town PR gets u modkilled, and even then, the rules didn't say you CANT get yourself modkilled

here not only the rules didnt say anything, but also the PR was given by an unlimited shot role lol. it seemed like a joke PR role and wud never modkill as a punishment so i took the gamble

it is what it is
Denied. You clearly used trying to get yourself modkilled as a defense. Stop trying to talk yourself out of it Jfc.
 
no flower because in WoT it was in the rules that breaking a global town PR gets u modkilled, and even then, the rules didn't say you CANT get yourself modkilled

here not only the rules didnt say anything, but also the PR was given by an unlimited shot role lol. it seemed like a joke PR role and wud never modkill as a punishment so i took the gamble

it is what it is
1) it's fair to think that breaking the pr wont modkill you. it was a long standing tradition on wf but we largely stopped using prs cause hosts are gay.

2) the issue is intentionally breaking the pr thinking it would modkill you but provide you some benefit. that's angle shooting. telling tweet to break his pr saying it will modkill him is angle shooting. this behaviour is out of the context of the game and thus against the spirit of the game. as in, it is not within the realms of proper scumhunting. even if you are town that is not within the realms of the game and the same accusation is still fulfilled.
 
about when you thought of messaging prof to cooperate with your team on night 4. would you do that to others player? probably not.
See this is where you lose me - what is this based on? I would do it with almost anyone if I felt communicating with them would offer me an advantage, the only exceptions are players who blindly town side and would out me because they would rather be town than win. When I trust that the player will put their wincon before the town's, and if co-operation was possible without detracting from my chances of winning, yes I would do it and have done it. I would do it with Ekko, Flower, you, Ultra, anyone. I happen to know Prof, and I know he favours scum siding, hence why I would be willing to out myself to him through a message that can't be caught by town.

You're assuming your own beliefs and then projecting them on me, I've literally always favoured Indies (I dont count Serial as Indie for obvious reasons).
 
no flower because in WoT it was in the rules that breaking a global town PR gets u modkilled, and even then, the rules didn't say you CANT get yourself modkilled

here not only the rules didnt say anything, but also the PR was given by an unlimited shot role lol. it seemed like a joke PR role and wud never modkill as a punishment so i took the gamble

it is what it is
If you can’t see stuff that isn’t necessarily against rules that have been written out could still be completely against the spirit of the game and/or what the host intends then I can’t help you.

If you’re someone that just is happy being an unsporting piece of shit to get an advantage then all the power to you, but it’s not going to fly here
 
Defend themselves against what? Joe Biden? Which most people aren't even going to notice anyway? Meh
Easy, what if we killed Magic because we knew where his suspicions lay before he posted. And then someone said Magic had these reactions so scum must have killed him. It's just extra, and scum and town can benefit wrongly too.
 
I just don't see how that's realistically going to be enforced tbh, it'd get violated constantly by people not even realizing night has started. We still get multiple people posting during night accidentally as it is. I think complaining about reacts is fairly precious tbh
I'd have to add it to the growing list of features for this Mafioso addon I've been trying to work on lol it's doable, but it will take less priority over the major features.
 
1) it's fair to think that breaking the pr wont modkill you. it was a long standing tradition on wf but we largely stopped using prs cause hosts are gay.

2) the issue is intentionally breaking the pr thinking it would modkill you but provide you some benefit. that's angle shooting. telling tweet to break his pr saying it will modkill him is angle shooting. this behaviour is out of the context of the game and thus against the spirit of the game. as in, it is not within the realms of proper scumhunting. even if you are town that is not within the realms of the game and the same accusation is still fulfilled.
it's not angle shooting tho, it's like saying vig tweet

im telling sky give him PR and get him modkilled

isnt that the whole purpose of a PR giver if it was a scum role? to get town to break the PR and die?

flower used such PR roles before so she knows what shes talking about yet being disingenuous

in WG scum has these PR giver roles all the time where if town break it X number of times they blow up and get modkilled. it's very common for scum to give it to a player then shit talk them or get into a long argument with them to try to get them to break the PR. i dont see why that shud make me look townie lol. you guys really thought i don't do this as scum??
 
1) it's fair to think that breaking the pr wont modkill you. it was a long standing tradition on wf but we largely stopped using prs cause hosts are gay.

2) the issue is intentionally breaking the pr thinking it would modkill you but provide you some benefit. that's angle shooting. telling tweet to break his pr saying it will modkill him is angle shooting. this behaviour is out of the context of the game and thus against the spirit of the game. as in, it is not within the realms of proper scumhunting. even if you are town that is not within the realms of the game and the same accusation is still fulfilled.
I‘m not just talking in hindsight either btw because I advocated for that to be modkilled while the day was still going. Perfectly fine with losing if a Town did that in a scenario, too.
 
Yo, I only do that when I think he‘s Town or want to buddy him as scum. We‘ve had a long term rivalry ever since I mislynched him in his sleep. Don‘t think we wouldn‘t fight each other xD.
Very dishonest of you to act like it's a thing as well, you were in the game where Prof went against town and you directly benefitted from it, you know full well that he gets very paranoid of me and doesn't just blindly sheep me, you're only agreeing with it because it benefits your takeaway from this game. Absolute disgrace.
 
just design the game better. don't give PR roles / PR givers. end of discussion rly

it's purely comical to hear this coming from flower, who got me modkilled for breaking a PR in WG. she was host and gave it to a scum role

and its not only once, she does shit like this alot

so if im scum and have such a PR giver role im for sure gonna give it to a townie and try to get them to break it and die

its 10000000% within the rules of the game

yall just salty asfk
 
just design the game better. don't give PR roles / PR givers. end of discussion rly

it's purely comical to hear this coming from flower, who got me modkilled for breaking a PR in WG. she was host and gave it to a scum role

and its not only once, she does shit like this alot

so if im scum and have such a PR role im for sure gonna give it to a townie and try to get them to break it and die

its 10000000% within the rules of the game

yall just salty asfk
Nobody is salty you moron

Sigis also didn’t break any rules that were outlined in the OP, have you seen any complaints about him being modkilled? No because everyone understands why he was. You’re dense as fuck
 
aight i didn't wanna be mean about it but yall deserve it to be rubbed into ur face

just git gud flower

thats what u get for shit talking ratchet and tpein

couldnt let u win now, could i?

feels much better now
 
I‘m not just talking in hindsight either btw because I advocated for that to be modkilled while the day was still going. Perfectly fine with losing if a Town did that in a scenario, too.
im not either:

because if its modkill and u r unlimited shots u can use it as psudo vig and force POE to modkill themselves

if there is no punishment then how do u know gram wasn't just ignoring it

why r ppl against trying to modkill tweet if they wanna yeet him

spirit of the game cuck boy.

im also against solving tweet as if he's town it solves nothing for poe. literally nothing.

also almost positive there was bussing/distancing this game.
this isn't just "oh we lost, now we're complaining"

i brought it up being against the spirit of the game while playing when it was brought up with tweet.
 
Back
Top