Who is the gothest of us all?

[Goth Boy]

I've seen none of you at Punk Clubs or even mentioning it, some of y'all choose DnD over VtM, and others confuse Goth with Alt Punk and conflate the two

Not a single one of yall are Goth in either definition of the term.

Goth aint grunge, Goth ain't alternative Rock, Goth is Goth and no one here reaches that

"Sisters of Mercy and Magazine are actually Post Punk not Goth you poseur"

 

[Ruffles]

A real goth would probably argue that the music they listen to isn't evil or satanic, and they'd be right because they aren't cool enough to listen to satanic music.

 

[jane]

show us your favorite satanic music @Ruffles

 

[Ruffles]

I am listening to "Satan Worshipping Doom" by Bongripper right now.
Good album, name is an intentional pisstake, but that's okay because the devil isn't real.

 

[Goth Boy]

A real goth would probably argue that the music they listen to isn't evil or satanic, and they'd be right because they aren't cool enough to listen to satanic music.

Goth Music never had anything to do with Satanic stuff. Peter Murphy and Ian Curtis were religious fairly conservative guys, so was Alice Cooper who while not goth he pretty much inspired the movement.

Led Zeppelin and 70s bands were the guys who were into that Satanic shit

 

[Goth Boy]

Inb4 "The Joy Division isn't Goth you uneducated Clown"

 

[Ruffles]

Goth Music never had anything to do with Satanic stuff. Peter Murphy and Ian Curtis were religious fairly conservative guys, so was Alice Cooper who while not goth he pretty much inspired the movement.

Led Zeppelin and 70s bands were the guys who were into that Satanic shit

Tell that to every mom with a goth teen

 

[Ruffles]

Also, Led Zeppelin?
The only big 70s band that I know talked about the devil was Black Sabbath and they were christian

 

[Goth Boy]

On a related topic , Ozzy and Dio also were both conservative religious guys

And funnily despite Dio being more popular in Europe, he was American, many people assume he's European

 

[Goth Boy]

Also, Led Zeppelin?

Jimmy Page was obsessed with Aleister Crowley

 

[Ruffles]

On a related topic , Ozzy and Dio also were both conservative religious guys

And funnily despite Dio being more popular in Europe, he was American, many people assume he's European

They must be confusing him for the other Dio that isn't a real person.

Jimmy Page was obsessed with Aleister Crowley

Based

 

[Vermiform]

I've seen none of you at Punk Clubs or even mentioning it, some of y'all choose DnD over VtM, and others confuse Goth with Alt Punk and conflate the two

Not a single one of yall are Goth in either definition of the term.

Goth aint grunge, Goth ain't alternative Rock, Goth is Goth and no one here reaches that