Game Official Ranked Xmas Mafia 2024 - Where Worlds Collide

[Ultra]

Now where do I vote and why

Be a good birb and help me pressure X into claiming

Blud is being cute

 

[Ultra]

My tunnel on X is sponsored by Dr. Prof

Enjoy a nice bubbly can of Dr. Prof

 

[Chuck]

Can y'all vote X and pressure him to claim thabks

sure, why not

Vote lynch the X

Someone please give me a summary of the main events. I'll start reading tomorrow.

1. Melkor lynched N1, was scum rolecop, claimed motion detection? basically whether someone is visiting someone/visited by someone at night
2. Watson claimed some US church that's hunted, then said she's in fact Jesus and church was her fake claim...? almost got lynched, 15/16 votes, but we switched to Melkor
3. 3 people dead at night, RDK was town matyr bg, Arne was janitored, Poyser was vanilla town
4. Flower PRd Ekko for shets and giggles
5. Alexis claimed bodyguard

i think that's it mech wise

 

[Ultra]

4. Magic - Town/Indie
6. Ekko - null
7. Alexis - null
8. Aurelian - Town lean
9. Watson - Town/Indie (non hostile)
10. Lappland - Town lean
11. Evans - Scum lean
12. Fuji - Town lean
14. Lethal - Town lean
15. Tweet - Town lean
16. Ultra - Town lean
17. Rugrat - null
18. Ratchet - null
19. Tpein - null
20. Alco - GTH Town
21. GoddessBlade - Town lean
22. Chuck - Town lean
23. Pqwerty - Town lean
24. Guillo - null
25. Seraphoenix - Town lean
26. Sparkles - scum lean
27. Jigsaw - null
28. Brutus - null
29. Dr Prof - Town lean
30. X - GTH Town

Can you explain your reads on Magic/Aurelian specifically

 

[Flower]

Can you explain your reads on Magic/Aurelian specifically

I think Magic is either Town with a garbage take or Indie who decided to scum side today to not mess with the scum team by going after me who should be an easy read. Have seen him do it in GTA before I claimed strong PR.

Fang just looks like he doesn’t give AF this game.

 

[Ultra]

I think Magic is either Town with a garbage take or Indie who decided to scum side today to not mess with the scum team by going after me who should be an easy read. Have seen him do it in GTA before I claimed strong PR.

Fang just looks like he doesn’t give AF this game.

That doesn't actually answer my question, why can't he be scum

 

[Hans Tweetenberg]

Baaaaaaah

vote lynch X

 

[Jigsaw]

Very relaxed, carefree comment. May be town.

Melkor comes across as good guying pqwerty a bit too comfortably

I can usually recognize a clumsy town and he is a new player here.

Besides i think i only made one or two comments about him

I am undecided if Melkor defending Pqwerty is an indication of town/scum alignment for Pqwerty, probably more likely to be town. I think Ultra may have been spot on with Melkor good guying a weak, eccentric townie. I still despise Pqwerty's posts and the misinformation they bring but I'll put that to the side for now.

As I said just from how I view things:

Pqwerty as scum is more able to contain himself, he doesn't have these weird outbursts and overreactions. It's because he has tmi. Without that guy feels lost in his own thoughts and doesn't really know what to do. So he overreacts and gets fucked. That's the main way of how I analyze his game. To me that line exists here and him saying he's crying from seeing me kinda sells that. He doesn't have the gall to say that as wolf normally because he doesn't develop that thought to pocket to me

Lappland defending Pqwerty in the same fashion as Melkor and using weak reasoning/evidence (which I have talked about before).

Bonus: Melkor doesnt come off as scummy, he just always gives that vibe off all the time. Remember the game where he was the town vig, got lynched by Ratchet lying and faking his role?

I haven't.

Think Ultra is setting his bar low going st Melkor like this tbdean.

This post has not aged well for Aurelian.

fwiw we have 2 examples of rugrat just putting a vote and dipping as scum. idk if we got any for him doing it as town

last xmas game, gram explicitly noted in our scum chat that this was a scum trait of rugrat, and he pushed it accordingly. turned out rugrat was serial. so even when we had scum TMI, gram found that trait to be scummy.

also think alexis's read of PQ is a bit too sheepy without any thoughts behind it. i dont rly think PQ vibes that scummy. wud like to see alexis do a side by side comparison to show what he thought was scummy about PQ's vibes in comparison to the town games that PQ played recently in WG that alexis was in

as for evans, i think its an interesting choice by melkor and could be worth a look at after melkor's flip if he turns out mafia

I have a hard time reading what this bolded part at the end is specifically insinuating but it seems important, @EkkoLoJinx

Melkor/Lappland/X/Flower/Sparkles
Watson also mafia a possibility

Idk for slots after that. Wouldn’t surprise me if magic i guess or tweet

I think Poyser was killed for this post.

 

[.guillo]

1. Flower - Town/Indie
4. Magic - Town
6. Ekko -
7. Alexis - Town
8. Aurelian - Town
9. Watson - Town
10. Lappland - Town
11. Evans - Scum
12. Fuji - Town
14. Lethal -
15. Tweet - Town
16. Ultra - Town
17. Rugrat - Town
18. Ratchet - Town
19. Tpein
20. Alco
21. GoddessBlade - Town
22. Chuck - Town
23. Pqwerty - Town
24. Guillo - Town
25. Seraphoenix
26. Sparkles - Scum
27. Jigsaw - Town?
28. Brutus - Town
29. Dr Prof - Town
30. X - Town?

Would leave a PoE of Ekko, Evans, Lethal, T-Pein, Alco, Seraphoenix, Sparkles. I'm expecting about 6 more Mafia, so possibly misreading some players. Maybe X, Jigsaw etc. Also might take Ekko out of the PoE. Think my main focus would be on Sparkles/Evans/Lethal/T-Pein.

Tpein and Alco were the first to be on Melkor with you early day 1, what do you think about that?

 

[Ultra]

I think Magic is either Town with a garbage take or Indie who decided to scum side today to not mess with the scum team by going after me who should be an easy read. Have seen him do it in GTA before I claimed strong PR.

Fang just looks like he doesn’t give AF this game.

Like according to you he's doing something explicitly scummy by pushing you, which is why he could be indi, but he's not scum because ???

Doesn't make much sense

 

[Rugrat]

I’ll be voting with @Magic today and leaving it with him the rest of the game.

 

[Flower]

That doesn't actually answer my question, why can't he be scum

He can be, but he also knows how I would react and that I would unleash hell on him. So I don’t find him being scum after already losing a member likely.

I think what Ratchet is right about is that people don’t really know about my play style changes here yet and that I was a bit uncharitable towards Magic in that regard.

 

[Alco]

I guess Watson's most probably not mafia. Very much in play for indy tho.

I'm very fine with pressuring Sparkles. The few posts I saw were no bueno. Especially the ultra self conscious one.
vote Sparkles

 

[Alco]

I think Poyser was killed for this post.

Since there was a janitor, I doubt Poyser was the mafia kill.

 

[GoddessBlade]

Good morning and Merry Christmas, all! Sorry for my long absence, I had a lot of personal Christmas cards to finish drawing. Took up basically my whole day yesterday

After catching up, the main useful information I have gleaned has led me to believe that this Sparkles fella is presumably frozen in scum chat... or also busy. But only I'm allowed to be busy. Other people are banned from busyness.

My chillsometer is telling me that Alexis is town... and my chillsometer is almost never wrong(because I always think Alexis is town and Alexis is usually town)


My dark horse scum candidate is this Lappland fellow. Too many unsavory pushes

 

[GoddessBlade]

I disagree. She said that she thought there was one scum in Ekko/Melkor and that most likely it was Melkor but she never voted there.

I very rarely vote before EoD in majority, particularly D1. It is what it is

 

[Dr_Professor83]

What benefit would scum have with a bodyguard in their ranks?

Protection from serial and vig

Tpein and Alco were the first to be on Melkor with you early day 1, what do you think about that?

This is blatantly not true.

 

[Ultra]

I’ll be voting with @Magic today and leaving it with him the rest of the game.

Why are you washing his dick when he didn't even vote correctly yesterday

If you don't explain the town read I'm gonna assume you're buttering him up

 

[.guillo]

Guillo had this pointed out to him and then switched his vote but didn't care to admit that Watson was less likely to be scum, just that nobody wanted to go there

Feels like an acknowledgement his push wasn't going anywhere but didn't want to outright give Watson cred

I will never admit Watson’s behavior on day 1 is towny. I will never believe that she is town. It does not matter who she has pushed, scum can do it too to distance themselves from their partners. In my opinion, town never lolcats, if they do, they are throwing, i’m gonna assume that an admin in this site is well aware of what throwing is and would not do it, therefore she is not town. She could be a neutral if not Mafia, but i dont care about anything that is not town.

But again, if you wanna keep her so much, i will not waste my vote there.

GoddessBlade on the other hand if look into all votecounts posted yesterday, she could have gone on Melkor, she had the alleged suspicion to be on Melkor, but she chose to be on Watson. She is Mafia.

 

[Ultra]

He can be, but he also knows how I would react and that I would unleash hell on him. So I don’t find him being scum after already losing a member likely.

I think what Ratchet is right about is that people don’t really know about my play style changes here yet and that I was a bit uncharitable towards Magic in that regard.

So he's not scum in your opinion because he wouldn't push a townie? Don't follow.

Also lol at the idea you'd change your play style.