• We're looking for artists. Direct message Dr. Watson for more info!

Game Official Ranked Xmas Mafia 2024 - Where Worlds Collide

I like X, Magic and Craig so far too. Sparkles slight town. As scum I feel she wouldn't have just left the convo with Prof was it was.

Agree of Pqwerty's opening being pretty bad, and haven't liked much else they've done. Melkor is eh so far too.
Also @EkkoLoJinx - to you, I'm only a weak town read, but this was iirc before Melkor was even voted for. If you're going to argue that your suspicion of Melkor early in the game is clearing for you, or at least strong enough to prompt a solid town read, then you ought to be applying that same logic to your reads. And apparently, you're not doing this, so...
 
I can also argue that Melkor‘s play around me is clearing. I also supported Poyser‘s pivot to him when Watson was L-1.

Best you can argue is that I‘m an Indie.
 
Why does that make you Town? You were not a primary pusher of Melkor, you came in after Ultra and I believe me too. One thing that you do apparently have in your favour is that you opted for Melkor over Watson, but I don't think that's entirely clearing.
i only have one
response to this, git gud. yay
fa so la si do
 
Why does that make you Town? You were not a primary pusher of Melkor, you came in after Ultra and I believe me too. One thing that you do apparently have in your favour is that you opted for Melkor over Watson, but I don't think that's entirely clearing.
i pointed out that went for melkor super late after thinking melkor was townier than watson
 
Also @EkkoLoJinx - to you, I'm only a weak town read, but this was iirc before Melkor was even voted for. If you're going to argue that your suspicion of Melkor early in the game is clearing for you, or at least strong enough to prompt a solid town read, then you ought to be applying that same logic to your reads. And apparently, you're not doing this, so...
i brought this up too
 
i have a question

I did not get the melkor case day 1, it was too meta reliant for me to grasp day 1. Is melkor just outed by default id est polarized
 
I can also argue that Melkor‘s play around me is clearing. I also supported Poyser‘s pivot to him when Watson was L-1.

Best you can argue is that I‘m an Indie.

really don't think you need to focus on clearing yourself rn :o like, does anyone vote you atm?
 
i only have one
response to this, git gud. yay
fa so la si do
I mean, I don't really care lol. If you're going to be an asshole, I'll happily join a lynch on you just to get you out of the game. I don't even particularly scum read you, I'm just pointing out that what you're arguing is not very good. You can choose to engage with that or not, but not engaging isn't going to make you look better.
 
i have a question

I did not get the melkor case day 1, it was too meta reliant for me to grasp day 1. Is melkor just outed by default id est polarized

idk, for me he's always scummy af, but many people were convinced he's outed scum already so i'd guess if we lynched watson, he'd ended up vigged anyway

so like, there could be someone trying to bus him seeing it as lost case altho with watson being right there and him being rolecop, i'd think they'd try to get at least 1 result out of him
 
Also @EkkoLoJinx - to you, I'm only a weak town read, but this was iirc before Melkor was even voted for. If you're going to argue that your suspicion of Melkor early in the game is clearing for you, or at least strong enough to prompt a solid town read, then you ought to be applying that same logic to your reads. And apparently, you're not doing this, so...
yeah i am fine with
you being back to strong town
read. it's not all that

problematic for
me. i sused you because i
thought you had some of

equity with fleur
thats about it T B H
fa so la si do
 
why tho? like, both sera and evans were inactive, right? he put evans in scum pile and sera in town leans
It felt more like a I told you so Town read from him which he could have leveraged to make himself look better if Sera flips rather than a Town read on a mate.
 
yeah i am fine with
you being back to strong town
read. it's not all that

problematic for
me. i sused you because i
thought you had some of

equity with fleur
thats about it T B H
fa so la si do
I mean, are you going to expand on this so-called "equity"? It also doesn't really address the issue that I raise - this shouldn't really need to be pointed out to you for you to come to these conclusions.
 
idk, for me he's always scummy af, but many people were convinced he's outed scum already so i'd guess if we lynched watson, he'd ended up vigged anyway

so like, there could be someone trying to bus him seeing it as lost case altho with watson being right there and him being rolecop, i'd think they'd try to get at least 1 result out of him
I'd argue that at one point it's not worth salvaging, the point being Watson actually finding a foothold into the game again which seemed kinda unexpected
 
It felt more like a I told you so Town read from him which he could have leveraged to make himself look better if Sera flips rather than a Town read on a mate.

Well sure, just it's kinda really odd choice to do so, no? Wouldn't you rather pick someone who gets some heat as your "told you so" pick? Like, if idk Sparkles is town, he says that, Sparkles gets lynched, flips town and his "told you so" looks better than doing it to basically inactive dude while he said opposite thing about other opposite dude. Idk.
 
yeah i am fine with
you being back to strong town
read. it's not all that

problematic for
me. i sused you because i
thought you had some of

equity with fleur
thats about it T B H
fa so la si do
can elaborate
on this, basically in
early game you did

ask me about my
town read of flower, i thought
you might have known she

was wolf and prodded
me for a wrong read i had.
meow meow yay!
 
I'd argue that at one point it's not worth salvaging, the point being Watson actually finding a foothold into the game again which seemed kinda unexpected

Well yeah, let me say this much, if i could save my rolecop from lynch and then suddenly, 1 vote off, people started switching right back to him, i'd be mad af. Idk, maybe check for people who were angry atm?
 
Well sure, just it's kinda really odd choice to do so, no? Wouldn't you rather pick someone who gets some heat as your "told you so" pick? Like, if idk Sparkles is town, he says that, Sparkles gets lynched, flips town and his "told you so" looks better than doing it to basically inactive dude while he said opposite thing about other opposite dude. Idk.
Nah. If he picked somebody who gets some heat he‘d just risk getting offed instead of them.
 
Well yeah, let me say this much, if i could save my rolecop from lynch and then suddenly, 1 vote off, people started switching right back to him, i'd be mad af. Idk, maybe check for people who were angry atm?
I don't think they would show in thread, but I would assume the initial people who switched off watson are townier than not. The later people have more bus equity
 
Back
Top