• We're looking for artists. Direct message Dr. Watson for more info!

Game Official Ranked Xmas Mafia 2024 - Where Worlds Collide

@Ratchet

Do you think Ultra is faking hated as scum to explain why he’ll make it late in the game? I can’t think of any pro-town benefit to revealing it now
 
I don't think Rugrat is scum, his usage makes sense, he followed up afterwards, on play he hasn't really tried to look good at all and I can't see a world where scum shoot Evans.

I should also note that if Ultra is scum, Hated would be an excuse as to why he's still alive later in the game. If we get a couple of mislynches wrong I would suggest lynching Ultra both for the utility of removing the hated townie who let's scum hammer a cycle early, and to cover that possibility off.
 
I didn't think he was scum to be honest anyway. Might have to take a swing at Magic then, I think if he flips town I'm probably lynching Lappland or Alexis or both next. Also I think Aurelian can be scum. Would be comically on the nose otherwise.

Jig feels like he's the kind of player that could easily pick up that sort of traction later, and there was already some rolespec there about how DV is NAI and he could be scum and such etc. He should be pretty clear.

Aurelian has been on Magic's dick all game for no reason fwiw. I thought he was scum earlier but thought some of his posts yesterday looked a bit more genuine and then just sorta turned my brain off reading them.
 
Wait so he should know who got the gun, right?

(Altho, isn't that like, waaay too specific? Role existing solely to check who prof targetted?)

Idk what gramma was cooking lowkey.
But I can say Ultra or Watson never got anything.

*shrugs
 
I don't think Rugrat is scum, his usage makes sense, he followed up afterwards, on play he hasn't really tried to look good at all and I can't see a world where scum shoot Evans.

I should also note that if Ultra is scum, Hated would be an excuse as to why he's still alive later in the game. If we get a couple of mislynches wrong I would suggest lynching Ultra both for the utility of removing the hated townie who let's scum hammer a cycle early, and to cover that possibility off.

I can take your word for it but to be completely honest I have no clue what you're seeing in him. Absolutely none.

Fine with Magic though
 
I do see the logic in his push to be fair and I think Alexis voluntarily coming forth and flower reading him could be a way to dissuade kills off of what was otherwise an extremely viggable slot

Problem is I'm pretty sure Magic was one of the people saying he was townie and the way he claimed was townie while we were all shitposting about killing his ass lol
 
My inclination is that T-Pein's role is a setup trap meant to stole paranoia between Prof's role and his own.

This is quite a bad gamestate at the moment as we don't seem to have any clear consensus. So I'm trying to figure out what the best lynch today is on the basis of that.

I don't think Tweet is scum. Magic if scum with him would have been prepared to bus only to not do it. I can't think of the motivation for scum Magic to try and cover Tweet (town) either. So maybe Magic is just town.

If I take Rugrat and T-Pein away too I'm left with Ultra, Aurelian, Lappland, Alexis, Chuck, Alco.

I don't think lynching Alco tells us all that much. I know Fuji wants him dead. Magic is right that Alexis is a bit of an aberration with his claim. But Guillo raised good points for not lynching him today. Lappland has the cop on him, and I doubt Chuck fakes that on a scum mate. So those two can be put the side too. Leaving me with Ultra, Aurelian and Alco to choose from today.

I don't like Ultra's claim. Hatred feels punitive in this set up but if there are 8 scum and 22 town or pro town I guess numbers are an advantage to town. I don't love Magic's argument on Aurelian being the Virgin Mary and only a Vanilla as that could easily just be a spec trap setup by Gram. But I do wonder why Joseph dies for Jesus while Mary has nothing to do with Jesus. I'm giving myself a headache trying to think this through.
 
Gift of Gold (A tribute for the unborn savior)
Gift of Frankincense (A tribute for the unborn savior

Like, it says "gift". And afaik she unlocked abilities D2 so she was gifted over N1
 
My inclination is that T-Pein's role is a setup trap meant to stole paranoia between Prof's role and his own.

This is quite a bad gamestate at the moment as we don't seem to have any clear consensus. So I'm trying to figure out what the best lynch today is on the basis of that.

I don't think Tweet is scum. Magic if scum with him would have been prepared to bus only to not do it. I can't think of the motivation for scum Magic to try and cover Tweet (town) either. So maybe Magic is just town.

If I take Rugrat and T-Pein away too I'm left with Ultra, Aurelian, Lappland, Alexis, Chuck, Alco.

I don't think lynching Alco tells us all that much. I know Fuji wants him dead. Magic is right that Alexis is a bit of an aberration with his claim. But Guillo raised good points for not lynching him today. Lappland has the cop on him, and I doubt Chuck fakes that on a scum mate. So those two can be put the side too. Leaving me with Ultra, Aurelian and Alco to choose from today.

I don't like Ultra's claim. Hatred feels punitive in this set up but if there are 8 scum and 22 town or pro town I guess numbers are an advantage to town. I don't love Magic's argument on Aurelian being the Virgin Mary and only a Vanilla as that could easily just be a spec trap setup by Gram. But I do wonder why Joseph dies for Jesus while Mary has nothing to do with Jesus. I'm giving myself a headache trying to think this through.

Elaborate on the bolded white boy
 
After sleeping on it, I’m fine with Magic or Aurelian. I still feel the way Aurelian jumped on Brutus yesterday looked very opportunistic.

Magic’s claim at least tracks with there being a fair deal of VT, or at least VT claims.
 
Back
Top