• We're looking for artists. Direct message Dr. Watson for more info!

Game Official Ranked Xmas Mafia 2024 - Where Worlds Collide

Reader mode
Aurelian said:
I asked why you were alive repeatedly when others like Craig and Poyser were offed. Your paranoia in trying to tie this into something else isn't defensible. And I don't understand how you think a kill was attempted on you earlier in the game, unless your acknowledging my point that you being alive was thanks to protection, in which case your TMI argument still falls flat. My reads haven't exactly been great or accurate either, so no.
Click to expand...
As per Rugrat's claim, scum would have tried to kill me Night 2. It was moved over to Evans. Then in Day 3, not before, you begin to question why I'm not dead. I find that to be suspect. You didn't call Magic out, but when I asked you conceded he was another, so my contention is that your questioning may have been motivated by having a kill fail.
 
Ratchet said:
If that's the case there is no reason why he wouldn't have seen Watson get something unless it simply doesn't interact with those.
Click to expand...
I don't think it does interact with her.

Grammaton said:
Congratulations, you are Caspar, Magi Aligned! One of the Three Wise Men, or Magi, whose journey to Bethlehem is an integral part of the Christmas story. Traditionally depicted as a king from India, you bring the gift of frankincense to honor the newborn Jesus. Guided by the celestial Star of Bethlehem, you set out on a long and arduous journey, driven by your faith and the prophecies foretelling the birth of a savior.

Your wisdom and dedication lead you to traverse great distances, alongside your fellow Magi, Melchior and Balthazar. Frankincense, your gift, symbolizes Jesus' divinity and is a fragrant resin used in religious rituals, reflecting your recognition of his holy nature.

In this game, you have the following roles:

- Gift of Frankincense (A tribute for the unborn savior)

Your only priority for now is to remain alive, the path to victory will become clear over time. You would be wise to avoid revealing your identity for as long as possible. Your goals ostensibly align with Christmas, however the savior MUST be born in order for you to win.
Click to expand...
Evans' role

Like it's the 3 wise men. Frankincense, myrrh and gold. They brought gifts to welcome the saviour.
 
Lethal said:
I don't think it does interact with her.


Evans' role

Like it's the 3 wise men. Frankincense, myrrh and gold. They brought gifts to welcome the saviour.
Click to expand...
So if it doesn't, then my question is, why does his check for gifts at night if Prof gives them in the day?
 
Hans Tweetenberg said:
Myeah Ratchet woulda wanted me to claim as well

I'm Balthazar, like Evans and Sera I started out as Magi aligned but converted to Christmas at the end of n2
Click to expand...
Ok so Tweet claims here.

Caspar, Melchior, and Balthasar are the 3 wise men.

So this says to me at CP was Melchior, since nobody other than Tweet has claimed it. Which means the janitor shot was a failure in that it didn't give any positives to it.
 
Fucking dumb **** Lethal sera was melchior and I just checked my bible for nothing haha. Everything above is moot and still at play.
 
I think I'm comfy with Magic lynch today. His push on Lapp was atrocious, his straw clutching for Alexis was equally bad, and he lost his exchange with Ultra very badly.
 
The only thing that gives me pause is Flower calling him the SK on her way down.

But she never voted him, she voted Rugrat for ? reasons in spite of not suspecting him earlier.

In fact....didn't she bring up the possibility of busdriver/redirect before anybody else? Did she TMI? Is it Flower & Rugrat with magic pulling the strings?
 
4. Magic - Odd-night Vanilla Cop
7. Alexis - Bodyguard
8. Aurelian - Vanilla Townie
9. Watson - Townish indy
10. Lappland - Vanilla Townie
12. Fuji - X1 Voyeur / X1 Follower
14. Lethal - Vanilla Townie
15. Tweet - Indy converted to Christmas N2
16. Ultra - Hated Townie
17. Rugrat - Busdriver
19. Tpein - Gift Checker
20. Alco - Vanilla Townie
22. Chuck - Vanilla Townie
24. Guillo - 2x alignment cop, outed scum in both groups
27. Jigsaw - Double Voter
28. Brutus - Vigilante
??. Ratchet - Resurrected

thats a bingo
 
Ratchet said:
As per Rugrat's claim, scum would have tried to kill me Night 2. It was moved over to Evans. Then in Day 3, not before, you begin to question why I'm not dead. I find that to be suspect. You didn't call Magic out, but when I asked you conceded he was another, so my contention is that your questioning may have been motivated by having a kill fail.
Click to expand...
Your overthinking this and trying to connect dots where there are none. Occham's razor is used to direct a solution to be the least complex one: Craig, Poyser, and RDK all died. Of the remaining "top tiers", that left you, Magic, and Ultra. Citing past games where you were killed early when town as precedent to prior to your actual death, is why I was suspecting you and questioning you being alive still.

Now you can keep spinning this as something else to keep your argument up as nauseum, but it's patently not true.
 
Aurelian said:
Your overthinking this and trying to connect dots where there are none. Occham's razor is used to direct a solution to be the least complex one: Craig, Poyser, and RDK all died. Of the remaining "top tiers", that left you, Magic, and Ultra. Citing past games where you were killed early when town as precedent to prior to your actual death, is why I was suspecting you and questioning you being alive still.

Now you can keep spinning this as something else to keep your argument up as nauseum, but it's patently not true.
Click to expand...
So your whole suspicion is because he's still alive?????????????????????????????????
 
Aurelian said:
Your overthinking this and trying to connect dots where there are none. Occham's razor is used to direct a solution to be the least complex one: Craig, Poyser, and RDK all died. Of the remaining "top tiers", that left you, Magic, and Ultra. Citing past games where you were killed early when town as precedent to prior to your actual death, is why I was suspecting you and questioning you being alive still.

Now you can keep spinning this as something else to keep your argument up as nauseum, but it's patently not true.
Click to expand...
So why was it only suspect for me, and not for Ultra and Magic? You said Ultra having Alexis protect him explained why Ultra wasn't dead, but you had no such argument for Magic.
 
Reader mode
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top