• We're looking for artists. Direct message Dr. Watson for more info!

Game Cross-Community: MafiaCorner & OneLastForum

Reader mode
Antura said:
Mafia is a game of probability and we (i guess) should act on the probable events.

if Waiki overreactim from mafia is not likely, then why use it as a argument.

HOWEVER, i will repeat my opinion that we did not saw the Waiki going meltdown this edition already. Just to take care of that fact.
Click to expand...

You sound town wanna vote Lion

Let's get that boy to spill his beans
 
Hayumi said:
Please give me your reasoning, I’m not super familiar with either one.
Click to expand...
bobek is a good mafia player that can appease to what people wanna see or hear

he's not doing that this game, he's obnoxious and harsh, he does not really creaate any alliances but rather plays his game

i'd say it's towny coming from him

ffor waki it's just a hunch tbh, I like his tone today, also I agree that he can be more dangerous as town in later stages of the game and if he's mafia, I think we will catch him then
 
kshaq said:
he's attacking but shrugging off anything that goes his way, maybe that's more clear
Click to expand...

That's true to be honest, hehe.
I mean such engagements where you'd say I'm robotic and I'd say you're average would just turn into exchange fest where we deny and state otherwise.

Could be convenient for scum, true, but from a town perspective I don't want to spend my energy on it.

I'd rather discuss other reads with others. Getting into engagements is clouding one's judgements.

If you think Waki is town, what would you say about limming Czuek and Njay? Putting away your distrust for me technically.

I've created a read list and you focused only on last line about you.
 
Lionheart said:
I feel ginger is town. I agree with Montis sentiments that gingers doesnt play for his benefit and I feel like he would as scum.

I disagree with Antura claiming that waki overreating means he is town. I do realize that he usually takes more calm and methodical approach to his scumgames, but that doesnt mean he wouldnt try to replicate his town meta. Thats why you need to judge not IF he is overreacting, but HOW natural is he doing it. And I think he is not doing it naturally at all.
Click to expand...
However, getting into discussion with ya cause why not.

Whats the point of Waiki trying to simulate his over-react (and doing it unnatural way) when he isn't in danger, its day0, hes only player who played here (and played it calm)? Lets say for that discussion I believe you. So you, as a inteligent person, really believes in such turn of events, that Waiki, wanting to try to replicate his town-meltdown-meta, would try it as a mafia, in such big game, here on OLF, in such stupid moment, in d0, when he wasn't in danger, and where there are no profits for such stuff?

Please explai, youre super smart, and youre logic it seems super surface level (based just on (un)natural stuff).
 
@monti

You seemed hardcore convinced there was scum in someone subbing out, why did you never vote into the dude subbing out or his slot? You didn't seem to take issue with suspecting him on that basis
 
Hayumi said:
It’s pretty simple. I read Ultra as town, and find myself agreeing with most of his reads early on. I didn’t think your reactions to Ultra’s initial posts about you seemed very townie either.
Click to expand...
Actually Ultra found me towny during our discussion but he was too shy to say that but i found it between the lines
 
There is definitely somethig wrong about Gingerbread, he's not even trying to talk to the ones he wants to vote? Just telling others to vote them. This is super-cummy
 
Ultra said:
You sound town wanna vote Lion

Let's get that boy to spill his beans
Click to expand...
Its complicated.

My whole idea of playing mafia is that we should lynch players (if there are any) from Background in the first day.

and allow even sus active players to survive d0/d1, out of logic, that they're at least playing the game, and giving as a lot of info about themselves. Even if there is sus mafia amongs sus hard pressured people in d1, we can let him (them) live, with time going on, he should just be waker and worse.

in theory, hero-lynch - so lynch going agains active, against (in theory) good player, to looks for mafia in him is not optimal from the village-side
 
I want an alliance with bobek
kid-en-sacrement.gif
 
I had six votes and now how many do I have? Lucho, kshaq? Two? Interesting.

Monti and Ultra kinda shifted it, but I'm worried how sensible Monti sounded when defending me. Poyser said I was theatrically making an extra enemy, so I'll elaborate.

Monti defended me so well and so reasonable, these were very sensible posts. that made me wonder if this could be some TMI leaking. I indeed made many enemies and what I did wouldn't benefit me. But if a lot of people you townread were hitting one target wouldn't there be some doubt and reduction of confidence when defending such slot?
 
Wakizashi said:
Yes, from my perspective, claiming it was mafia theatre seems strange, like reading it in the least probable way.

As for Njay, all I can say is: Are overreactions inherently scummy? Doesn’t the town overreact sometimes?
Click to expand...
Town overreacts more often, but here something was not right. You were drunk and ok, I'll buy it for now because Antura says the same and I don't believe you both are scums together, not possible.
Do you have any takes of OLF guys?
 
gingerbread said:
That's true to be honest, hehe.
I mean such engagements where you'd say I'm robotic and I'd say you're average would just turn into exchange fest where we deny and state otherwise.

Could be convenient for scum, true, but from a town perspective I don't want to spend my energy on it.

I'd rather discuss other reads with others. Getting into engagements is clouding one's judgements.

If you think Waki is town, what would you say about limming Czuek and Njay? Putting away your distrust for me technically.

I've created a read list and you focused only on last line about you.
Click to expand...
I don't trust myself on Czuek

He does towny things but he did last time as well and I still think he put a lot of effort to appear like his towny version when pushed by Monti

For Njay I still don't trust him, I think there's a chance for him being scum, I didn't like his explanations today and I could technically vote him off

But I wanna vote with Antura today and he's not convinced that a scum sits there so idk
 
Reader mode
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top