• We're looking for artists. Direct message Dr. Watson for more info!

Game Ranked Hero Killer Mafia

Status
This thread has been locked by the thread creator and is currently not open for replies.
but thats not my issue, I am playing only because fleur asked me to a lot, so if I die day 1 thats perfectly fine with me

if insomnia is tunneling me here as villager, it will be even better when i flip town
the fact is the majority of your content ists of pushing alexis
i understand why u dont like their play, but i havent seen you really bring anything to the table but that. you pointed out thoughts on insom and you gave that one read a couple pages ago but what original ideas have you broughten up
 
Lethal cooled down, which I am happy about for thread health reasons, but I don't like that Alexis is basically their sole focus. Lots of people have said that they're thread spewed town tho, which if so, shows some TMI at works.
This is absolutely false. Alexis is an annoyance but to paint them as my sole focus is disingenuous. I've discussed Miranka and jay at length and just now found you as a town lean.
 
the fact is the majority of your content ists of pushing alexis
i understand why u dont like their play, but i havent seen you really bring anything to the table but that. you pointed out thoughts on insom and you gave that one read a couple pages ago but what original ideas have you broughten up
that is not my content and I find it actually dishonest of you to act like I did not post reads. If I post a majority of nonsense fluff posts but still end up posting actual content then you can analyze them instead of doing some content to fluff % read which does not even make sense.


Likewise: I find it actually gruesome to act like we should reward Alexis for AI posting. No matter what you think his alignment is. I respect the spirit of the game, you should try that.

Also I have given more than one read and I have given original thoughts on a bunch of slots
 
PoE list
Lethal
jay23
Aurelian

Lappland
Fujishiro
Atsumori
Arne Slot
Luka
Cataclysm
PepeBoi

Adjusted because jay23 and Lappland are now incompatible (I expected it to be the last one).
 
Gonna sort you guys in two categories:

Those I feel sorta good about:
2) Fujishiro
3) Atsumori
5) Alexis2282AE
9) PepeBoi
11) Grammaton
12) Lappland
13) BradLand
15) jay23
16) Mlraka

Those I feel sorta bad about:
1) Lethal
4) Cataclysm
6) Arne Slot
7) Sharter Holmes
8) Luka
10) Hayumi
14) Stick
17) Aurelian


Which isn't a good list at all, considering the size of the bad feels.

Stick has had a few takes I enjoy, but is not impactful.

Lethal cooled down, which I am happy about for thread health reasons, but I don't like that Alexis is basically their sole focus. Lots of people have said that they're thread spewed town tho, which if so, shows some TMI at works.

Cataclysm just exist. So. Yeah.

I disliked Arne's posts around the Brad vs the world posts.

I dislike that Sharter comes in just to snipe at Atsumori and having not much else to say.

Luka makes on paper very nice posts, but also plays a lot of peacemaker between players.

I dislike how Hayumi tried to strongarm the lynch.

Aurelian basically exists to make snipes and tilt.

I think the wolf approach in this context would be:
1. Lay low but also be sorta active so you aren't completely forgotten
2. Make some easy inoffensive pushes so you can a) influence thread movement, and b) appear like someone who is solving whilst avoiding flake.
3. Try to be the good guy of the thread. The reasonable one. Make yourself and your input too valuable for town to be lynched in the early game.

Some of these steps apply to people in my good list (like Jay), but I will focus for now on the people who get coal for christmas.

I could maybe see a team of Luka/Hayumi/Sharter

What I have disliked the most is the forced push of the Brad/MIk dichotomy.

Vote Lynch Hayumi
I think Hayumi's Town.
 
which, unless they're like w/v (which most of the time i play peacemaker they strictly arent), is against the wolf wincon. e.g. alexis stuff

i felt arne was pretty towny TBH, perspectives feel believable for someone who doesnt know brad and i liked them just point blank sheeping gramma without agenda (also mind melding with me on cata)

i think cata is pretty wolfy



can u explain these two? im at lappland scum lean atsumori town lean rn but i dont feel confident in either direction
Yeah the reason why I am not hard pushing you is because I don't have the ba-, because you're playing pro town at the moment. But I also have an impression that you appear pro town as wolf, and I know in a game state like this it is pretty easy to play pro town without hurting wolf agenda tbh

That's a fair point on Arne. I thought he was opportunistic.

There was a post earlier from Lappland that I low-key town read, around their reply on why they did not give much takes on Brad. My impression of Lappland's wolf game is that they wanna be That Guy as a wolf. The Gangsta with capital G. Especially in a ranked game, I would expect them to try hard basically. Like, it is super easy to be town read at this point and I think Zarathustra would capitalize on that. I think as town it is more believable that they just... Don't have much to say about things.

Atsumori had a town vibe during my first visit in this thread. I disliked that they've been actively lurking, though it is a good sign that they didn't react much to the snipes their slot received in the meantime.
 
Page 14 Quotes (60-Page Thread)


Vote Lynch Atsumori

Happy to push there. His early posts were cringe af and nothing he did brought him back up again.

Gonna wait on the duel. I obviously scum read Brad more than Fuji tbc, but @Flower does the duel stop at hammer? As in, will 10 votes for Fuji to win mean the duel ends there or will it end when the main phase ends?

I have a slight town lean on Atsumori currently from my ISO. You said their early day 1 was sus, but that's also a bit of a fillery time to be fair. What parts of my reads in my ISO do you specifically disagree with?

They were talking about the duel.

Dang I already forgot the context of this but that's fine I've been forgetting half the players in this game so gonna just do a light ISO of Cataclysm's posts on this page. NAI

Why me, I thought we friends

Seems neither a townie nor scummy reaction. Not really sure how to read Pepe so far in general, would need to ISO to come to a conclusion

What's the push on Alexis this game?

I also don't get it, this is a good question

i promise everyone in this game for the love of god brad is town lol
if you tr fuji that much to the point where youd prefer to go brad over them sure, whatevs. but voting brad because hes the wolfier player is not the play

Goddammit you're so frustrating. I don't trust your hedgy, apathetic a** at all but there's no way in hell you'd fight for Brad this blatantly as scum, right? Right?

We're thinking Fuji is wolf this game?

Idfk, I'll probably ISO Fuji in a later post cause nothing in their posts is screaming scum to me from memory. Like why would you duel on Brad as scum, this kind of bus makes zero sense on day 1

dude gets overtly emotional as town and not as wolf. he would probbaly be a bit miffed as wolf but not like IM NOT GOING TO POST SINCE THEIRS NO POINT, FUCK THIS GAME AND YOURE A MOD TOO?

obviously thats hyperbole but the point stands

You know them better than me but obviously I don't agree

well he dueled said obvious town without even asking for a claim first when the game barely started
not great!

I agree that it's not ideal but it feels more like something an overexcited or dumb townie would do than a mafia play. Also with ALexis's 3rd party theory, would a 3rd party really put themselves in the limelight like this on day 1?

1) Lethal/jay23/Lappland
2) Lethal/jay23/Aurelian
3) Lethal/jay23/Fujishiro

Lethal is my top scum-read right now, and so all top worlds involve him. Scum-reading Jay because I see her as the most compatible person with Lethal, and how she's only pushing people of whom I am town-reading. As for everyone on the latter end of each world; part of the final PoE I have for today.

PoE list
Lethal
jay23
Lappland

Aurelian
Fujishiro
Atsumori
Arne Slot
Luka
Cataclysm
PepeBoi

So if I understand correctly, you basically think that Lethal and jay23 are aligned to the same role?

Unsure how to marry Lethal saying he would ignore Alexis' tunnel to Lethal asking Fang if they should lynch Alexis

Thank god someone said that Fang = Aurelius cause I was confused af reading back.

I do agree though it feels a bit inconsistent and it's one of the reasons why Aurelius is my biggest sus to be mafia

I don't think Aurelian is scum. I would expect him to pressure me more if he was scum. He still could be indie if he remains too silent.

So your meta on Aurelian is that they have a rather limited wolf range? I haven't played with them before but I just haven't seen them do anything pro-town. No reasoning for most of their reads are rather superficial reasoning when they do give it. And the aggression they showed toward me over something that wasn't even correct was pure obfuscation, which is what wolves do

What's the plan if Brad flips town?

I swear to god, there's no way in hell Brad flips town.

But as someone else said, it would make sense to bring more attention to Fuji in this random hypothetical

I only remember Alexis as when he is town, and right now, I don't think he looks super scummy

I agree with this.

It's an improvement over his earlier games I had with him where he just said chills.

Yeah I feel like Alexis is actually making good contributions this game that most people are just ignoring for what seems like meta reasons

both duellists are town and i wasn’t rly planning on voting between them at all but like


why are most of u voting to kill the Jailkeeper lol instead of the role that i assume has alr exhausted its ability


Vote Bradland to win the duel

Tbh while the reasoning is flawed (cause it's natural for Brad as mafia to claim a role that's less likely to get lynched in a vacuum), I'm inclined to TR you for this take and vote cause it would most likely be suicidal for you to defend Brad here as mafia
 
hmmmm ok im gonna slot boq as town (he will win it for the wolves in f3)


as per my understanding of fuji's role, they get to initiate more duels as long as their target flips scum - this is unfortunately not happening so to me the duel right now is vanilla town vs 3 shot jailkeeper town so my vote stays
 
This is absolutely false. Alexis is an annoyance but to paint them as my sole focus is disingenuous. I've discussed Miranka and jay at length and just now found you as a town lean.
Well soz, but I've only seen a handful post of yours that address mik and the post where you town lean me. The majority I've seen since day start and that has stuck with me is the Alexis discussion

On the other hand, I have similar feelings about Lappland yet town read them, so I should probably review those reads
 
Yeah the reason why I am not hard pushing you is because I don't have the ba-, because you're playing pro town at the moment. But I also have an impression that you appear pro town as wolf, and I know in a game state like this it is pretty easy to play pro town without hurting wolf agenda tbh

That's a fair point on Arne. I thought he was opportunistic.

There was a post earlier from Lappland that I low-key town read, around their reply on why they did not give much takes on Brad. My impression of Lappland's wolf game is that they wanna be That Guy as a wolf. The Gangsta with capital G. Especially in a ranked game, I would expect them to try hard basically. Like, it is super easy to be town read at this point and I think Zarathustra would capitalize on that. I think as town it is more believable that they just... Don't have much to say about things.

Atsumori had a town vibe during my first visit in this thread. I disliked that they've been actively lurking, though it is a good sign that they didn't react much to the snipes their slot received in the meantime.
Keep in mind, I do not actually care about rankings here at all lol. I only played a singular game here
 
Status
This thread has been locked by the thread creator and is currently not open for replies.
Back
Top