• We're looking for artists. Direct message Dr. Watson for more info!

Game Ranked Grand Theft Auto Mafia

Status
Not open for further replies.
Reader mode
Gaddamnit said:
Luka is going forward and making cases for nonexistent scenarios, and given how his last game was him admitedly doing what his team wanted, this might just be him being directionless scum jumping the boat.
Click to expand...
Alternatively, he could easily be directionless town given how early game it is

But then I didn't play the last game did I
 
Sky said:
I like this bold Flower, I think she's town, even though I do think the logical leap from "Magic's case is wrong" -> "Magic is scum" is incorrect, he could just be blinded by his own ego like I suspect
Click to expand...
Inb4 you‘re trying to pocket me now.
 
Gaddamnit said:
Okay. Hold up. Gonna disassociate from the game a lil to get giddy about this.

Food pics. Recipes. Story. What?

I'm interested
Click to expand...
Nothing that big. I was working at a restaurant and we were understaffed. So I helped in the kitchen all while also being a bartender. It was not fun at all .
 
Town:
Watson (aka 19th Amendment)
Flower
Ultra
Polar Bear
hime
Orca

Unsure:
Magic
Luka

Scum:
Gad
Sky

More or less in order. For Watson I don't think she fakes a post restriction as scum, it would be more... not effort, but it goes against her ethos of not doing things as scum that will hurt her down the line. It could be a real post restriction independent of alignment, but Rugrat doesn't feel like the type of host that would include that for a scum player. Flower's reaction is entirely in line with "I have rolled a good role so I expect everyone to treat me like I'm town confirmed". I don't think she leans into this to fake it, she'd have to be ready to claim it to make this sort of play, and I suspect she probably would have by now. Ultra mostly on gut, I liked his posts around Luka because it felt like he was genuinely analysing his play, having just been scum with him this wasn't the same thing. One of those reads that I'm going to struggle to quantify clearly because it's based on my personal experience, that being just last game.

Polar Bear mainly because I liked his Orca read, and that's why I've sheeped it and put Orca in there too. Not really clearing but it's a good baseline to start with. @The Orca What do you think of Polar?

hime because I liked her reads post and also agree with most of it. A fancy way of saying "gut vibes".

Magic I'm unsure of because I've liked most of his content, but I find it wanting too. I liked his argument around Luka, but he hasn't started by looking for town reads which is the baseline I'm working from (not to say that he only does this as town, jus that I find it weird for him not to start like this), and I also feel he's leaning a bit too much into logic regarding Flower because it's an easy way to look better. Just not really getting "town" from him so far, but in terms of his positions I find them mostly agreeable. Luka because I don't have a good way to read him, I think his defence to Magic was pretty bad but I've seen him defend similarly on WorstGen as town, also think he'd a tad less performative than he usually is as scum. The fact he went to discredit Magic first I liked but I don't like how he came to a town read of Magic.

Gad because he's offering nothingburger statements around reads #254 in particular. As for Sky, #259 is how I expect her to talk around a scum buddy and #270 is the same sort of thing as Gad. If I accept that Magic/Flower/Ultra are all town, I ask "how would scum play around this". And my answer is "how Gad and Sky did". Also worth noting that both have offered "NAI" reads of Luka, not sure what that means for him yet because I think Sky at a minimum would scum read him. Which is partly why Luka isn't in scum reads.

Ekko I don't know about, I want to say "probably doesn't play like this as scum" but meh.
 
I have p much the same thoughts as Ratchet except Sky (who is a solid Null read for me rn), he can be Town.
 
I am perhaps the only person who is a permascum read if and only if I'm town
 
People are still yet to inform me what GTA character would have the PR Watson is claiming btw, we've seen faked PRs as either alignment (even though it makes negative sense as town) recently
 
Sky said:
People are still yet to inform me what GTA character would have the PR Watson is claiming btw, we've seen faked PRs as either alignment (even though it makes negative sense as town) recently
Click to expand...
No idea, but GTA lore and characters are very forgettable in general IMO.
 
Flower said:
Eh, you were widely Town read in the Poison game as Town. And scum read as scum in the Mash.
Click to expand...
Different site, different circumstances. I get the feeling that I'm always expected to be bad on OLF except if I have teammates
 
I don‘t think Rugrat gives scum a fake PR since those are usually seen as Town and he‘s under the belief games should be more Town favoured. Just like Watson is unlikely to do stuff like faking PRs or Miller claims since she doesn’t want to burn trust.

Tldr don‘t worry about that.
 
Reader mode
Status
Not open for further replies.
Menu
Log in
Register