• We're looking for artists. Direct message Dr. Watson for more info!

Game Official Ranked The Boys: Mafia - Game Thread (Day 6)

Status
Not open for further replies.
Reader mode
Dont let him breathe!
 
Can I ask why you think this is scummy for Gad please? Like what is your expectation of him as town to contrast this?
 
Wakizashi said:
"Day 1 will run for a maximum of 48 hours"

This is quoted from page 1 so I assume that eventually someone will be lynched
Click to expand...
As I don't think anyone answeres, if it runs for 48 hours with no majority the day ends with no lynch. So we need to hit majority.
 
SCCHAMP said:
You think both RDK and aure are both scum here? The way they interacted with each other earlier in this game makes me feel otherwise
Click to expand...
I might be confirmation biased here, but I really don't like anything that this slot has brought to the table today. Like even this post feels like they're latching onto easy, safe to engage with content that isn't going to be disagreeable but doesn't really do anything either. Probably my preferred lynch of today.
 
Hans Tweetenberg said:
Ratchet stonks plummeting at around page 54, having Pein and Champ as your main directions at that point seems weak and I don't agree with his read on Pein
Click to expand...
Why is it weak? At that point I had town reads on most of the active/"top tier" players. I really don't understand you people to be honest, you people being the site regulars, it's like you think if a highly regarded player doesn't scum read any of their peers then they're weak and ducking them. I don't really understand how you can come to this conclusion unless you wilfully ignore my town reads, and given that my focus is to find town reads, I have no idea why you would think that is a good way to analyse my play.

As of now, Poyser has slipped down, largely because I haven't liked any of his main directions. That means I have a town lean or read on you, Sky. And while I don't expect to be completely on the same page as him, I do expect some overlap, as of this point for example I had no town read of Sky and I liked that I agreed with some town reads from Poyser, hence overlap.

I think Ultra is the most egregious example of the above by the way, in fact I suspect he bases his solves around the idea that "at least one tier 1 player is scum" before he even reads. Whether it's true or not. I'll get a reads list up in a moment but I suspect you're going to be disappointed Tweet because I still think Pein and SCCHAMP are my highest outright scum reads.
 
1. Ultra
2. Flower
3. RDK
4. Poyser
5. Melkor
6. Tempest
7. Lethal
8. Sparkles
9. Sky
10. Hime
11. Evans
12. Ratchet
13. SCChamp
14. Alco
15. Fujishiro
16. Aurelian
17. Gad
18. TPein
19. Tweet
20. Wakizashi

Notes:
I have no read on Lethal. I think he can fit in as scum, but I wouldn't have any real confidence either way. He's in PoE until that changes.

Aurelain I would say is a GTH Town. I thought about colouring him Blue, but I don't really have anything to defend it with and it's not a read I want on my record because I'm really not sure about it.

Hime was someone I was tempted to downgrade to Blue. Really, her scum reads to me feel like she's going at the so-called "top players" without much regard for whether they fit in a team (which is fair, for it's day 1, but still shows a lack of holistic analysis) but I do question what she really hopes to gain long term from it as scum. At some point she's going to have to progress her reads state, and I think other elements such as her willingness to claim are townie enough to put it to the side for now. But, that slot is trending down a little for me.

I haven't really been compelled by Poyser's defence or his reaction to being a wagon. Feels like it's missing some venom, actually, so I wouldn't mind lynching there. Would prefer to give him a Night though, and I think the level of evidence against him isn't all that strong to warrant a day 1 lynch. And his claim, I don't mind it. It's not clearing or anything but I think it's plausible, the problem really is I think as a fake it would be plausible too.

Alco obviously I have no read on. Needs to either post or be replaced.

So preference would be in my scum reads, then Poyser, and then if that's not on the table I'd be fine with taking a blind shot at Alco or Lethal (well, Lethal can at least claim, and Alco can be replaced). Gad might be closer to Blue than Green, haven't minded his posts at all though.
 
Reader mode
Status
Not open for further replies.
Menu
Log in
Register