• We're looking for artists. Direct message Dr. Watson for more info!

Game Ranked The Legend of Zelda Mafia

I think Gad is probably the arsonist if I had to guess and is just why would he have both of those roles, that's a lot of eggs in one basket for town. My guess is he's probably odd/even arsonist and watcher with watcher being his safe fake.

I don't know why he would actually claim the firefighter bit though since it would probably be easier for him if people didn't know there was an arsonist about
 
Even with that being said since it would be so disastrous for him to die if he were town I think I'd prefer to let him watch someone tonight and see if he can clear himself and force scum to wifom their kill
 
I think Gad is probably the arsonist if I had to guess and is just why would he have both of those roles, that's a lot of eggs in one basket for town. My guess is he's probably odd/even arsonist and watcher with watcher being his safe fake.
i had the same thought
 
i had the same thought
tho i did also think its also entirely possible that hes just plain scum
wouldnt scum like town to get scared of a potential indie in play?

this was after i said there is likely no serial and the split is probs 10-4
could just serve to make us think there is only 3 scum and that we should start indie hunting after we get the third one
 
if this is true then it would lean me harder in the direction that both rugrat and psychic r scum and that they need gad to be the one to pull through
 
I think it's less likely hes scum because I think poyser would have just told him to claim watcher and leave out the FF portion since he would know that him having two roles would stick out like a sore thumb
 
I think it's less likely hes scum because I think poyser would have just told him to claim watcher and leave out the FF portion since he would know that him having two roles would stick out like a sore thumb
Unless of course he had him do it to wifom me and he's still pocketing me beyond the grave init

 
I think it's less likely hes scum because I think poyser would have just told him to claim watcher and leave out the FF portion since he would know that him having two roles would stick out like a sore thumb
Depends. His claim might not have come up in the chat. In my experience, the simplest explanation is the most accurate one.
 
Depends. His claim might not have come up in the chat. In my experience, the simplest explanation is the most accurate one.
Maybe, Poyser is quite meticulous though and a bit of a dictator when it comes to lesser players on his team, he basically played two slots as scum a few months ago. I think either way i'd prefer to let Gad get watcher usage off
 
I did get targeted by scum last night.
Yeah, was looking for an answer from her. Multiquoted some people to reduce suspicions + asked the Motion Detector to claim.

This looks even more suspect.
I never asked the motion detector to claim, just who targeted me. Sorry if I didn’t make that clear.
I think I know who the motion detector is, it’s very obvious by now, but I’m not going to say it lol.
He does seem pretty jacked.
Even with that being said since it would be so disastrous for him to die if he were town I think I'd prefer to let him watch someone tonight and see if he can clear himself and force scum to wifom their kill
He should be on Hime because she’s like the only clear town imho.
I'll give you another chance. Why didn't you protect Gram or Hime?
Good point
if this is true then it would lean me harder in the direction that both rugrat and psychic r scum and that they need gad to be the one to pull through
I have been on Gad since day 1 and he’s in my PoE. I wouldn’t mind lynching him either because nothing he said makes any sense. But if he was firefighter, it would be disastrous to lynch him.
I think it's less likely hes scum because I think poyser would have just told him to claim watcher and leave out the FF portion since he would know that him having two roles would stick out like a sore thumb
Rdk brings up alot of good points here, leaning him more town than scum.
 
Please claim