• We're looking for artists. Direct message Dr. Watson for more info!

Game Official Ranked Xmas Mafia 2024 - Where Worlds Collide

Jigsaw lets do this

If Pqwerty is a villager, where else do you go. What would Pqwerty!v indicate to you
 
Hmmm. I think these are fair points. I'm not willing to bark up your tree right now. I think the votes on you are more interesting now.

Magic I can see his thought process through his posts and understand his logic. His posts and vote on you doesn't feel bad to me.

Rugrat's only post is just a vote for you. That's lolbad.

Jigsaw's problem with your post that he quoted, I can't really see the issue. But his follow-up quote of another post of yours I see more sense in. I'd say since all eight of his posts are about you, he's in tunnel mode. So then the question is, why the tunnel?

Craig votes you pretty early on for no reason and then goes on to talk about weird stuff. You can throw him on the suss pile.

Sparkles voted last on the wagon and did so without reason. Has done a good job talking about the game, but not about voting Cry.

Interesting to see all these votes happen closely together. Also, there's only five voters on Cry but six votes counted against him.
 
Lets entertain that Pqwerty would be scum

Jigsaw and Sparkles are two people who I think don't actually have good reasoning to have caught him. I do think pqwerty is a villager though, but even in that world these votes look bad.
 

@Magic Scale of 1-10 how confident are you this guy is scum
 
Also the fact that those most familiar with Pqwerty are giving him town reads is giving me cause to revise him being scum so...
 
Good enough for me tbh

Vote: Lord Melkor
 
Rugrat's only post is just a vote for you. That's lolbad
While I do agree in isolation, I don't really see him doing it as scum. Not to the extent that I would hard clear him from it, but I feel like it's well within his mindset as town to see who Magic is scum reading and vote there until he can catch up with the game himself. Especially if he gets decent vibes from Magic thus far. As scum, I think he would have slightly more reseveration about dropping a vote on a wagon and then just dipping off. Something to consider, anyway.