• We're looking for artists. Direct message Dr. Watson for more info!

Game Official Ranked Xmas Mafia 2024 - Where Worlds Collide

@Chuck you brought up the multi-scum theory. You know more than we do.

Claim
Nah, i'm just that smart that i'll say "Hey, it could be multiball btw" in 30 people game while multiple people die N1.

Idk what has happened and i can claim but if this is the reason then nah o:
 
Nah, i'm just that smart that i'll say "Hey, it could be multiball btw" in 30 people game while multiple people die N1.

Idk what has happened and i can claim but if this is the reason then nah o:
Chuck the reasons I clear you here do not apply if you are not scum with melkor, so claim
 
So... You knew Kilku was mafia for entire past day yet you put Kiku and me as equally scummy anyway? And you didn't check me?
 
Chuck the reasons I clear you here do not apply if you are not scum with melkor, so claim
Eh whatever, you're ruining my gameplan of trying to get myself killed at night tho.

The Bethlehem Inkeeper

Vanilla Townie

So like, no abilities whatsoever, by flavour is that dude who let Mary&Joseph spend a night in stable
 
Not to mention, even if Flower is mafia and not some indie here, you'd have to assume i'm bussing the shet out of my teammates (Melkor&Sparkles or Flower). Anyone from NF/WG would know i'd rather play dumb than do that.
 
That doesn't answer my question.
Obviously we're going in circles; your asking me why I town read them or lean town on them, and I'm asking you why you are doing opposite.
Also doesn't answer my question.
Uhhhh.
That's up to you to argue. You're the one who needs to read me.
Yeah I know: I thought I made it crystal clear that its difficult to read you from my POV because you are a frustratingly elusive person to peg down to an alignment. So I'll repeat again, why shouldn't I have you as non-town? Nothing you've done has been outside your wheelhouse or past actions when you were non-town indie or especially mafia. So there is precedent in having caution and paranoia around your slot.
Which is?
Wasn't Alexis instructed to protect him?
Ask them?
That's not really a rebuttal. Is it not basic mafia 101 to kill players who are strongly able to prevent their own lynching? Why do they leave you around to linger?
Flower, if Indie, would have no TMI on my slot. So her decision to kill me or not to kill me, has no bearing whatsoever on my alignment.
What does TMI have to do with anything? Her hesitance around committing to kill you when she knows it would still benefit her team if she is mafia not indie, wouldn't make sense from a logical standpoint. She got rid of Ekko, why would she hesitate around getting rid of you?
Okay:

Town to me is:

Alexis
Fujishiro
Guillo
Lapp
Lethal
Magic
Tweet
Ultra

Outed as scum/not-town:

  • Flower
  • GoddessBlade/Kiku

Have no problem flipping to narrow things down the PoE:

  • Alco
  • Brutus
  • Chuck
  • Jigsaw
  • You
  • Rugrat
  • Seraphoenix
  • T-Pein

T-Pein wouldn't bus his teammates no matter what, so that's a point in his favor.
Chuck has been wish washy the ENTIRE game and dodged committing to any invested reads.
Brutus and Jigsaw both have done nothing not to flip them solely to shrink the scum pool.
Rugrat voted me last phase
And Sera is a complete red herring, same with Alco other than Poyser vouching for him iirc

Flower or Kiku goes today
Vig shoots the other one
We focus on the rest but I feel reliably convinced this is a multi-faction set up and we have plenty of remaining mafia players and hostiles to deal with
 
OMGUS. If you believe that you're spewed, then feel free to outline why.
That's not omgus, I just thought about who pushed on Ekko alongside me or who pushed Evans. Or who still lists me as potential scum despite me pushing on X for a decent while and pushing Goddessblade yesterday.

Well Goddessblade tried to push me yesterday then instantly flipped her read on me because of a singular post. She in fact did call me scum and then instantly townlock me and fucked off.

I also said we should go for her today as well for that at EoD yesterday.

Flower targetted Ekko with her PR and I wouldn't do it personally. I think she did it to pocket me, and it worked.
 
Hmm, Evans claim confirms Watson is town, right?