• We're looking for artists. Direct message Dr. Watson for more info!

Game Official Ranked Xmas Mafia 2024 - Where Worlds Collide

the tiltedness is partially because i don't really enjoy playing on here as much as i used to - it's really a chore

but i wanted to play mafia almost immediately, so
 
My last game here I remember Watson doing something similar with the sniping a seeming town read for something in a similar way D1. Ultimately the slot was scum.
you literally also witnessed me sniping at sera on WG as town

to be fair he was being an umempathetic prick, but still
 
you literally also witnessed me sniping at sera on WG as town

to be fair he was being an umempathetic prick, but still
I don’t remember it! I mostly recall you being pretty aimless and just waiting to be lynched a lot. I don’t really remember you carefully selecting and pecking at people the same way.
 
I’m reading back and you don’t look very similar there and here. Also your post to Sera wasn’t sniping at him for a contradiction like this, you basically just called him out for being an ass early and later you started asking people about his town/scum play which is pretty different than pecking at him for a gatcha.
 
I’m not gonna continue to bury you for it. I don’t think that’ll help your play getting sucked into that lol.

But comparison denied.
 
Yeah probably not. Ekko doesn’t tote water for teammates and would rather bury them to prop himself up
I'm not sure if that's entirely accurate, but I don't think he would casually drop a mate in there knowing he's going to be asked about it, unless he's playing the WIFOM game. In which case, I'd expect Watson to have a read on him, not simply Null. It's not a conclusive read of course, but currently I'm not working to the worldview that they fit as scum together.
 
just as a comparison from the HP game. the kooky antics seemed in line with my familiarity with them

i did note i am not familiar with their scum game however so this view is biased to a degree obviously
Feels a bit... vague, given that they were the first and strongest town read you had. And I think Prof's point was valid - if you're reading someone as "solid town" off of meta you base from one game with them, their comment regarding meta being bad doesn't really feel like something I would think you would need to address. I mean, it's not like you think meta is bad, right?

From your general demeanour I can see that you're not really too interested in getting pressed into answers right now, and I think me co timing in this fashion is likely to prompt the wrong answers regardless of your alignment. So the above is me laying out my considerations. What I'm going to do next is let you grow into the game. There will be no grilling from me. I'll revisit this later in the day, when hopefully there is more of a body of work to read you from.
 
you have also not given the contextual elements at play here and my gradual progression toward self-pres.

context: ear infection and zero ability to defend myself in a way that counters the suspicions placed on me. suspicions i found fair, rather than grasping at LHF

i awaken. i find god. this is me in full swing willing to defend myself later on after recovery. suspicions that felt and were less fair after no one bothered to evolve their reasinung in their read of me

it really all depends on the mood and circumstance im in
i dont know what to tell you other than i disagree with your analysis because it's more nuanced than "she snippy she angry she woman"
 
i mean that's fair
there is no why, i just asked
 
This is a little different to what you originally said (and what I was pushing back against). You argued that him jumping into solving and not shitposting with the rest was a sign of him being scum. I don't agree with that. I don't really think Melkor is the type in general to use the thread to chat or shitpost outside of casual comments here and there. It feeling forced is a different matter, and one I can more or less agree with. But the key here is that his reads felt obligations rather than things he genuinely arrived at.
Yeah I don't really have any comment on that. He has a child and a family so I think not being around at night is not all that strange.
this is an interesting vote that i do not think is ""random"". does melkor open up voting a mate here? ive seen him do it in the past iirc.
It's possible, but there isn't really anything to discuss because Evans hasn't given anything he can be read from so far. I agree that it's a strange vote for Melkor to be making naturally though.
 

Well that's kinda the thing, if you're angry about something, my presumption is that there's a valid reason

In the absence of anything readily apparent I'm gonna assume you're seething over being caught as the most likely explanation. What did I even do to you?
 
let's be honest, as much as i adore melkor he just comes across dry as the sahara desert as either alignment
i wouldn't label him as carefree or casual period
 
it's more nuanced than "she snippy she angry she woman"
It’s the context of the sniping. Not you being angry bc you didn’t seem angry at all.

Ie the sniping felt like seeing a weak spot you could take a peck at and taking it just because it was there and available. Its the focusing on taking a little jab at a town read and no interest in anything else was unusual.
 
Anyway Watson I’m gonna give you room to breathe lol. Just making sure it’s clear what I’m personally addressing and seeing and you aren’t going off of it being something else.