Game Ranked Wildlife Mafia

[Grammaton]

btw are we doing the Executioner Paranoia thing and keeping Aurelian under half majority? Because if not I'm voting that way

Id be surprised at an executioner in a small game tbh

 

[Ratchet]

Should add that I think Gad can be scum entirely on his own merits, simply for how he worked up to getting on the wagon. It applies regardless of what Poyser is (the "Poyser is town' scenario is a bit more level one thinking but it can work pretty easily). Some potential blindspots there like with Emil I guess but otherwise happy with the list.

 

[Poyser]

Generally made most sense to me, has been very much the voice of reason on Watson where some people have still been trying to make her look like obvscum when she isn't

This is so dumb lol
First off, nobody has said Watson is obvscum? Even when I was pushing her I didn’t say that so not sure why you’ve framed it that way

The other point is like… do you expect gram to not make sense as scum? Don’t you think he’d be happy to use Watson being town to make someone like me look bad? Is that not a worthwhile trade off?

 

[Sky]

Id be surprised at an executioner in a small game tbh

Thanks

Vote Aurelian

 

[Atsumori]

Let me guess, you're going to interpret everything Watson says through a scum lens for the rest of the game and later pretend this was a legit push all along

Ekko moment

To be honest, I've a hard time to try to forget this. I don't like this entrance.

 

[Ratchet]

@Dr. Watson I don't really agree that I'm reluctant to townread you early in games but I don't mind the thought process, I would say here your early game has been quite informative and I have given my reasons.

 

[Poyser]

Should add that I think Gad can be scum entirely on his own merits, simply for how he worked up to getting on the wagon. It applies regardless of what Poyser is (the "Poyser is town' scenario is a bit more level one thinking but it can work pretty easily). Some potential blindspots there like with Emil I guess but otherwise happy with the list.

I think having is together is pretty bananas. If we’d agree he was going to get on my wagon to look good, I’d have told him how to do it. Certainly wouldn’t be town reading me and then voting me with no explanation lmao

 

[Sky]

To be honest, I've a hard time to try to forget this. I don't like this entrance.

Entrance hunting is one of the lowest forms of scumhunting. Try again

 

[Grammaton]

This is so dumb lol
First off, nobody has said Watson is obvscum? Even when I was pushing her I didn’t say that so not sure why you’ve framed it that way

The other point is like… do you expect gram to not make sense as scum? Don’t you think he’d be happy to use Watson being town to make someone like me look bad? Is that not a worthwhile trade off?

Wouldnt it be better for me to actually just let you look bad by lynching her and then have to deal with the consequences of that?

 

[Ratchet]

I think having is together is pretty bananas. If we’d agree he was going to get on my wagon to look good, I’d have told him how to do it. Certainly wouldn’t be town reading me and then voting me with no explanation lmao

Eh, I can see Gad doing that even if you do tell him how to work up to it. It's not really something that you'd have to worry about anyway I think, if you flip town he's probably my next push (though I would go back and reconsider Gram in that context, just to see if I can see something different that I've missed first time around).

 

[Atsumori]

Thanks

Vote Aurelian

Did you really need that to vote against Aurelian? Your earlier post about Executionner Paranoia looks more like a post to convince people to vote for Aurelian, I don't think you really fear that Executionner thing.

 

[Poyser]

Wouldnt it be better for me to actually just let you look bad by lynching her and then have to deal with the consequences of that?

Sure, but you also have to actually play the game and make yourself look town lol, not like you’re going to just sit back and do nothing or not get involved in the main push one way or the other

 

[Atsumori]

Entrance hunting is one of the lowest forms of scumhunting. Try again

Sorry but your entrance post sounds so bad, that I might just scum read you. I have a the impression that you're just acting so far.

 

[Sky]

Did you really need that to vote against Aurelian? Your earlier post about Executionner Paranoia looks more like a post to convince people to vote for Aurelian, I don't think you really fear that Executionner thing.

You must be forgetting how pretty much every game in 2023 had an Executioner and people were incredibly cagey about bringing the wagon to over half because of it

 

[Grammaton]

Sure, but you also have to actually play the game and make yourself look town lol, not like you’re going to just sit back and do nothing or not get involved in the main push one way or the other

I mean id say ive already done those things, wouldnt you?

 

[Poyser]

I mean id say ive already done those things, wouldnt you?

Huh? Yes… By town reading Watson which is exactly what I was arguing?

 

[Poyser]

Btw why did you ask for my reads twice and then not respond to them

 

[Poyser]

Huh? Yes… By town reading Watson which is exactly what I was arguing?

Like your hypothetical was that it would be easier for you to let me do it without getting involved lol

 

[Atsumori]

You must be forgetting how pretty much every game in 2023 had an Executioner and people were incredibly cagey about bringing the wagon to over half because of it

Well, if people fear the executioner to kill Aurelian, then it means there is not enough people who want to see Aurelian being lynched. Yet, you're not trying to convince people to scumread Aurelian, but you're convincing them to vote to lynch him. This is very different.

 

[Atsumori]

I know where I place my vote now

Vote Lynch Sky