You don't have a rebuttal though. At least not one with any actual substance to it.Well my rebuttal is that the premise of your defence is incorrect.
It's all just bad faith and posturing with nothing else; no reason why anyone should reas Nibel is town when his activity and play is 1:1 to past games he was scum.
Also preflipping him when your implying my slot is determined by Nibel's own seems rather specific.