• We're looking for artists. Direct message Dr. Watson for more info!

Game Official Ranked The Boys: Mafia - Game Thread (Day 6)

Status
Not open for further replies.
Reader mode
hime said:
attitude and confidence in her argument with ultra despite being all over the place
ive only played one game with her but she isnt really a player i would classify as being on the same caliber as ultra (who i think to be one of the best on this site)
personally find it harder to see someone charge in as scum and argue with a stronger player voluntarily if they dont have a collected argument prepared beforehand

also her conceding in the claim argument with me felt largely townie
as scum, its harder to concede bc ur afraid of how others will perceive it and whether they will find u scummy for it
its far easier to just double down on it or simply disagree with my reasoning
it's not like she was proven wrong or anything during our back and forth, she couldve fairly easily not given in
Click to expand...
Fair I do want to point out that even tho a scum may have a better argument for pushing someone, this isn’t always the case and the way I saw it was more opportunistic rather than in a towny light. I do understand your point tho and ty for the feedback
 
Lord Melkor said:
Are there any other condtions?
What does this offer than the lynch does not?
Click to expand...
Obviously it offers for Hime an option to control the lynch. Let's say she is not pleased with 2 people between town decides a lynch and she has a candidate she wants to see lynched then she can simply replace lynch as organized by town with lynch as organized by herself.
 
Flower said:
Also to reply to this, it feels disingenious.

First of all, you have to consider my threat is aimed at Ultra and Poyser, both players who have seen me as either alignment and from either pov and are known to read me well historically. If such players misread you it's such huge skill issue on their part you p much have to assume an ulterior motive.

Second of all, Sky's vote was most certainly not a sheep vote. She brought up her own unique reasons for voting you, she agreed with the push, but didn't "just sheep" at all.

This post feels like you're trying to appease certain players rather than genuine thoughts.
Click to expand...
Agree it feels like an attempt to appease, obviously me but also the point about Poyser echoes what Ultra was saying
 
Sky said:
Unvote
Vote Evans

Anyway I feel good about this. When you say you're "glad to be back" and then limit your activity to briefly getting at 2 players, both of whom I reckon you consider low-hanging fruit... Nah
Click to expand...
Like, you can clearly see Sky has her own reasons for voting you @Evans .

She thought about what kind of player you are and what you would do here.

So ya, that’s not sheeping at all.
 
Tempest said:
You're not interested in what I meant by saying you were approaching slots in bad faith? Or do you not contest it?
Click to expand...

I disagree with it as it's not true. My opinion of your gameplay and what I believe your motivations are will dictate my response, right?

I think you genuinely believe I was acting in bad faith and you're wrong but I don't think you're doing it scummily. I care more about Flower & Poysers behaviour
 
Sky said:
How do you feel about my assessment that Sparkles only does this as scum if one of Ultra/Poy is her mate
Click to expand...
I'll get home in like 3 hours, gonna read up then and see if your reasoning makes sense to me. Personally I haven't thought it through at all mostly because lolsparkles
 
Sky said:
How do you feel about my assessment that Sparkles only does this as scum if one of Ultra/Poy is her mate
Click to expand...

I don't think she sides so blatantly with him as scum/scum but I understand your angle here especially before Poyser actually responded. Like she wanted to paint the interaction as "oh look here they go again" when all I did was vote him pretty mundanely
 
Ultra said:
We need to utilize 47 hours, 59 minutes and 59 seconds before we reach majority to discuss.
Click to expand...
We should pause the game for 3 months and then resume to make sure everyone, and yes, even Gad, reads every letter in every post before we continue with D2 tbh.
 
Pattern recognition

He plays similarly to a lot of scums I have seen in the past. He shares their characteristics.
 
Reader mode
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top