• We're looking for artists. Direct message Dr. Watson for more info!

Game Official Ranked Xmas Mafia 2024 - Where Worlds Collide

Oh true which makes checking Alexis a bit odd imo.
Not really. Night 1 with no vanilla claims to work with, checking PoE slots works because it gives you some info on them

The real problem with his claim is that it fits as a Mafia role too - his would be the equivalent of X's role. A bit stronger actually.
 
speaking of hypothetical situations, there's always a chance that arne was yellow and was janitored by purples

saying yellow since i assume they're all gone and none of flipped yellow's had janitor ability
 
Not really. Night 1 with no vanilla claims to work with, checking PoE slots works because it gives you some info on them
I would wait a bit more to check people who claim vanilla or just any role. Night 1 usage isnt great imo.
The real problem with his claim is that it fits as a Mafia role too - his would be the equivalent of X's role. A bit stronger actually.
I guess thats true.
 
speaking of hypothetical situations, there's always a chance that arne was yellow and was janitored by purples

saying yellow since i assume they're all gone and none of flipped yellow's had janitor ability
It's possible yeah. I don't like to assume that though because it can instill a false sense of safety and generally, it's better to assume the worse case over the better one. But it's worth pointing out because we may not be looking for three players aligned, just two.
 
"Boo hoo Ratchet isn't listening to me"
"Boo hoo you wouldn't say Magic had bad usage, you will only criticise me"
"Boo hoo, woe is me" etc...
It's not what he is doing, it's how he is doing it.
Ok lol. Saying that magic checking Alexis night 1 is way worse then me verifying that hes a Bodyguard after he claimed when I scum read him isnt victimizing myself but whatever you say man.
 
Ok lol. Saying that magic checking Alexis night 1 is way worse then me verifying that hes a Bodyguard after he claimed when I scum read him isnt victimizing myself but whatever you say man.
No it's the "you wouldn't have anything to say about that though would you, huh" that came after it. Watson basically summed up the idea in a nicer way so we can go with what she said too if that works better for you.
 
How is he losing it lol.
Because if he is Odd night, he can only use it... on odd nights.

So N1, N3, N5, N7. So if he doesn't use it N1, he just... doesn't use it. And thus only gets his first investigation night 3. There is no value whatsoever in not using it night 1 lol.
 
It’s “use it or lose it”. Using it on night 1 doesn’t reduce his availability to use the shot on future later nights

Because if he is Odd night, he can only use it... on odd nights.

So N1, N3, N5, N7. So if he doesn't use it N1, he just... doesn't use it. And thus only gets his first investigation night 3. There is no value whatsoever in not using it night 1 lol.
Or right hes not limited shots.
 
Or right hes not limited shots.
Right. Also even if he is limited in shots, the chances of him reaching Night 5 are generally slim. So there is value in using it just to make sure he gets a reasonable chance to use his shots. This is even more the case if he is 3 shot instead of 2 shot. And if he's 4 shot... you get the point.

Generally, if someone is restricted to alternating nights, they shouldn't need to be given X shot on the role too. Generally.
 
So looking at deaths with assumption that yellow's are gone and brutus is town vig

n1:
arne - purple janitor kill, random af, maybe there's something to his posts, idk
poyser - yellow kill, makes perfect sense looking at his poe
rdk (protecting watson) - vig kill

n2: i think i figured out what happened
x - vig kill
pq I
prof I => 1 killed by purples, 1 killed by yellow, 1 killed by someone who received A Toy Soldier (1x Vig Shot) that prof crafted N1
evans I

Noone claimed receiving vig 1-shot so probably mafia got it, someone who prof town read, could be flower or someone yellow but i guess wouldn't hurt to check

n3:
sera - vig kill
ratchet - purple kill
no more yellows

basically i guess i'll check arne's scum reads and or whether he hinted at some useful role and prof's town reads
 
Back
Top