• We're looking for artists. Direct message Dr. Watson for more info!

Game Official Ranked Xmas Mafia 2024 - Where Worlds Collide

Town have no forms of protection and there is no reason for a scum bodyguard to protect Ultra night 2.
It could be that they had him use that because they were wary of him being tracked or whatever but that would leave Flower open who was under a bit of heat that day. And no other town protective claimed.
 
It could be that they had him use that because they were wary of him being tracked or whatever but that would leave Flower open who was under a bit of heat that day. And no other town protective claimed.
Would track be stopped by bodyguard?
 
The more you make terrible arguments the closer I am to just wanting you lynched. He is not saying that all animal claims are not on their team. He is saying that at least one non-animal will be off the team. The purpose of that role is to circumvent watchers/trackers, because it makes the target show up as the one making the visit. If the role could only affect her team, why create a chat for it? There is no reason for it.

So the actual argument he made, not the one you created, makes sense - with Jigsaw as the only animal claim, he can be considered town off the back of this. Now, I'm frankly more interested in why the only thing of note you've managed to "contribute" today is to argue why someone isn't town, as opposed to, well, weighing into anything else.
Why the fuck are you alive
 
Well yeah. So why would scum protect Ultra? Ultra would have to be scum with him. If Ultra is scum I could re-evaluate Alexis.
… Thats what I said man.
Why are Alexis untouchable? Chuck I get a bit because of the way he interracted with flower felt a bit unintormed but you have Ultra in not the untouchable spot for example. Cant Alexis be scum BG if Ultra is somehow scum?
 
Shes dead Watson

but I think that makes Arne likelier not purple. Can only be yellow or town
I think Arne was town

What I'm saying is you can apply the same logic to Flower herself--
you have a reason to kill him as mafia
--not just Ekko

(I did previously ISO but "Flower has motive to kill him" isn't necessarily a point that has any real substance. He was hardcore sussing her. )
 
Eh might as well say as scum would know too. Shouldn't have said anything yet.

I awoke on day 2 with my dwelling smelling like herbs, thyme and rosemary.

As no one had claimed it or said anything similar since I'm going to assume it was related to cp's role.
How do you have this info though?
 
Also again I'm clear unless I'm exactly the janitored role which good luck trying to argue why they'd let me of all people take that fake when I'm doing fuck all with it lmao
 
I think Arne was town

What I'm saying is you can apply the same logic to Flower herself--

--not just Ekko

(I did previously ISO but "Flower has motive to kill him" isn't necessarily a point that has any real substance. He was hardcore sussing her. )
Alright but Fleur is dead and my interaction with Arne around EoD as you should remember was him and me pushing Ekko and he insisted Ekko was scummy too
 
I think Arne was town

What I'm saying is you can apply the same logic to Flower herself--

--not just Ekko

(I did previously ISO but "Flower has motive to kill him" isn't necessarily a point that has any real substance. He was hardcore sussing her. )
You're conveying this point weirdly because you're not actually asking the question.


"Why did you assume it was ekko that killed arne and thus suspected ekko for it as well as assuming arne had a pr but you(being lapp) never suspected flower for the exact same reasons when it was true for both"
 
@.guillo I gonna be blunt, I am not

I think the Watson shot was bad in context of the Melkor flip imo. The X shot was good, I just wanted to know how you got there

Of course you do; because you think I'm scum. Watson had 11 votes on her at one point, 7 end of day 1. She was still suspected, mate. Who would you have shot instead? You're pissing at the wind here.

I won't forget you patting Flower on the back for PR'ing Ekko, and tag teaming him when he died.

@Brutus hello! who sussed you previously

I was on a lot of PoE lists so mostly everybody but off top of my head, Flower. Will need to read back.

This is multiscum dude Flower flipped purple.



Stubborn. Like his town meta lol.


Alright lol, you should play there again.

Wouldn't an SK still have the majority to win condition though?

And nah, I won't, I don't play mafia much and that place is too active for me. I'm not very good at this game anyways lol. 10-year rook y'know
 
Last edited:
Back
Top