Game Vampire The Masquerade: Bloodlines

[Lappland]

Regardless


Reads are
Handsome
Lappland

Villager
Nutmeg
maybe Ali
probably Ratchet
I reckon Melkor
Atsumori
Cata


Scummy
Reloaded
Stargate
hayumi

 

[Nutmeg]

Could swing either way especially with Fuji as the host. He never makes things simple mechanically/role distribution wise

Noted so basically this is thr wild west an evaluate based on how people act got it

 

[Lappland]

Correct, I think he’s likely scum here. The only other alternative would be if there is a ninja in play that blocked Melkor and would be undetectable.

I mean your post reads a bit like a perspective slip to me, but what can you do

regardless

the fact that you treat Melkor as like super 100% town is telling

 

[Hayumi]

I mean your post reads a bit like a perspective slip to me, but what can you do

regardless

the fact that you treat Melkor as like super 100% town is telling

If you read my posts in response to his claim I don’t think that at all. However, there were 2 kills. Melkor is claiming to have tried to kill me.

We are guaranteed to have a third/SK in the game at the very least.

Melkor is likely just telling the truth with how dumb of a choice that was plus unless the SK or real vig abstained and Melkor killed one of Flower/Luka he’s more or less just verified vig.

 

[Hayumi]

And I look at his claim vs Mr. Reloaded, his is more believable. He already claimed it d1

 

[Mr. Reloaded]

this post is bad

Care you explain why?

 

[Mr. Reloaded]

post about Yoho being more likely to be scum due to the 1x tracker thing reeks of TMI to me.

 

[Mr. Reloaded]

Either you're scum or trolling lmao

 

[Lord Melkor]

Atsu

I got "census" results after yesterday

12/3/1

some mech oracle crap but idt it matters too much

Oh, so typical setup.

What do you mean by "mech oracle crap"?

 

[Lord Melkor]

Killing into luka and flower ln feels like wolf siding which makes sense given how the d1 went down

annoying but im obviously a bit biased here

How much have you played mafia before by the way?
You did not have access to census day 1?

 

[Lord Melkor]

So far;

Confirmed:
Luka - Town
Flower - Town
Alexis - Town
Yoho - Scum


Reads:
Sharter - Scum leaning
Nutmeg - Town
Lappland - Null
GoddessBlade - Null
Ratchet - Null

Need to go back through and read more replies.

Why do you think Nutmeq is town? It is significant since it is basically your only town read.

 

[Lord Melkor]

Rolecrusher.

How does your rolecrush work?

 

[Lord Melkor]

So I think Mr Reloaded is mafia, from what I see Hayumi is outed due to mechs hinting at godfather or SK?

that's fine with me I guess, but Mr Reloaded posts are kinda awful, pqwertys too and I think Pqwerty shows a lot of negative energy due to randing wolf again in a lobby he didn't want to rand wolf into. So there is that. The post about Yoho being more likely to be scum due to the 1x tracker thing reeks of TMI to me. It's such an odd thing to focus on and I wouldn't like care about the 1x? Like what makes the 1x more scummy than a 2x here? Almost nothing really, so I think it is a thing a wolf would hark on while bussing

PQwerty was replaced, right? What do you think of the replacement? I thought his initial posts sounded genuine.

 

[Lord Melkor]

By setup spec if Yoho was a roletracker then the watcher is most likely to be town

 

[Ratchet]

By setup spec if Yoho was a roletracker then the watcher is most likely to be town

Fuji has just finished hosting a game where he gave scum a Tracker, a Watcher, and a Ninja. Town had no tracker and no Watcher. "Setup spec" in a Fuji game is completely pointless.

 

[Ratchet]

That said I'd rather flip Hayumi than Reloaded, primarily because Reloaded volunteered the Watcher information. As scum he'd have to be pretty desperate to insert himself into the mechs of this, would kind of be relying on WIFOM getting him out of it which is meh to me.

 

[Ratchet]

I do trust Lappland's read of Pqwerty so the Reloaded angle is probably due further consideration at some point.

 

[Lappland]

I am not sure why 1x tracker is anyway shape or form a specifically scummy claim

 

[Lappland]

Unless you want to claim 1x watcher 1x tracker?

sure be my guest, but then my point stands and you had tmi

 

[Lappland]

PQwerty was replaced, right? What do you think of the replacement? I thought his initial posts sounded genuine.

I think his initial posts are kind of an atrocity and come across as him begrudging having randed wolf

And I can explain why

me and nutmeg just carried pqwerty to the finish line in a 50 player game to win as wolves while he was outed