I don't see you ever mentioning before you potentially saw him as scum but I hold my same contention on town reading him as I do scum reading Magic and you were strongly suspicious of Magic way earlier, what gives? Magic failed to address or debunk anything Ekko said, his actions and involvement with how often they soft defended each other, more so then any other time I've seen either as town in past games do, why are you so comfortable with not scum reading Magic but tighter with Whicker who has less mess ups or convoluted arguments with other posters?