Search results for query: *

I didn’t knock your individual play, I just said I don’t think it’s specifically credit worthy to have someone in your reads for eight days and not lynch them. I wasn’t and am not targeting you for failing to lynch Magic; just that I don’t think there’s a ton of credit to be yielded there. FYI, your “chance” to lynch Magic was D2-D7 as you weren’t lynched and it was after the execute. In my view if you’re alive; you have a chance to get your lynch.

fair enough. My issue is mainly with the other two for their obnoxious comments

How did Magic have two clears? At most he had one - the Hider (though the hider explicitly only worked on mafia so it wasn’t a false negative). He could be tracked and watched all the same, plus would be rolecopped as serial killer on nights he killed. If people choose to set up spec after being explicitly told it wouldn’t help them AND chose to dismiss play for set up spec after the SK had been outed by the final mafia three phases before the game ended then blame me, then Christ. I’m not knocking those who didn’t lynch Magic, but you’re missing the forest for the trees. I don’t really need to piss on everything. The game was a great success! It was the highest activity game this year and more importantly nearly everyone enjoyed it. I’m not sure what pissing on everything even constitutes; I haven’t knocked anyone’s individual play or criticised the players involved. I disagreed with a single point you made and you’ve insulted me, shitted on my hosting and knocked the setup.

@Big Man You fucked up

I said you and Polar played well in Discord. I’ve given Polar a HM; just have never been of the mind that being “on” someone is particularly impressive when you stay alive for multiple days. I said the same about Hime getting HM in Members Mafia.

Town had two roles which could avoid night kills and a role which could prevent mafia’s kill. That’s more than enough. If you think town need a bodyguard, seraph or watcher; write them in your games.

Okay, next time I host - how about don’t sign up? Not exactly sure why you’ve get this level of hostility with me (or think I do for you), when I gave you a HM over many other good candidates and have been very complimentary about your play.

@The Orca is your issue you didn’t get Hime’s HM?

I explicitly wrote not to set up spec. Crying foul because your set up spec was erroneous is your own fault. At any rate, I’ve been playing here for nine years and hosting for eight - and this game is another that’s mostly been well received . Town had a hider and commuter who couldn’t be tracked (which is how Flower survived a kill) as well as a roleblocker, which could be used to prevent a kill. There was also a tracker to prevent mafia killing with complete impunity. If you can’t imagine games without town having a bodyguard, watcher or a seraph, that’s on you.

How is it delusions to not view a bodyguard as confirmed town?

How was he auto cleared? Mafia steam roll town all the time.

You and Magic were both alive until Day 8. That’s a lot of time to lynch him. Most games are over well before D8

Shit talking your twin? You had multiple chances to lynch Magic as there were still six oppurtunities between the execute and your own lynch

It’s not that impressive to be “on someone” if you didn’t lynch them and you were around until Day 8.

All post your MVP and HM picks, since I wasn’t following too closely

You’re very welcome! Thanks for playing

I ended a night phase earlier than I should have in hindsight, but there’s only so much discussion you can have with six players - two of whom are confirmed

I’ll let you guys decide HM’s since I wasn’t following super intently; thinking between Hime, Ultra, Ratchet and Haza (feel free to suggest others)

this happened last game and they were lynched

Roleblocker is what I’d consider protective. Scum had the jailer; town had the roleblocker. Very parallel. Shouldn’t your criticism be directed at the other players, if you were able to work it out; mafia were able to work it out - but the rest didn’t?