- It's that time of the year again! Just kidding, we were late.
Click here to see the awards and nominate people for the rest of the categories.
- We're looking for artists. Direct message Dr. Watson for more info!
Game Community Mafia
- Thread starter
Dr. Watson - Start date
-
- Tags
- game thread unranked
Sparkles
Exceptional
I mean i wouldn’t fake claim either; can screw towns solve. Most setups it makes sense for town to have a roleblocker and town can see that (well sometimes). And if they can’t, take the elimination; don’t fake claim as town unless you know what you’re doing. But that doesn’t include drawing town roleblocker again.
This is more than a little silly. From Poyser's perspective, he knew he was Town. He likely also carried the expectation that there were 2 Mafia to hunt. Knowing he was Town, and that there was a Vig (again, it's important to remember that the Vig being a Serial Killer was not really on the cards of what could be expected) his reasoning of you being scum made sense - scum would have to have a way to deal with a Vig and a Cop.
From my perspective, I had you as Town. As far as I could see it, Ppyser could have been fake claiming, but it's obviously harder to fake claim Cop before everyone has claimed than it is to claim Roleblocker (my rationale was that even if he were counter claimed, he would feel like he could possibly win that and win the game as a result).
This is all to say, there is nothing unreasonable about the suspicion you drew. Certainly nothing unreasonable enough to go full scorched earth and begin to lie in your claims because of it. The only time I really felt that you were scum was after Poyser didn't hammer - at that stage, I felt like you had to be Mafia due to what I thought the setup was. You should also consider that it was LyLo - people need to cross-examine one another at this stage, and there wasn't all that much in your favour. It also didn't help that from my perspective, Sparkle was confirmed scum, and you supported her a lot even before she voted, which made it difficult to read you correctly (I ultimately decided that there wasn't much of a plan from you and her as a team, whereas I could see it a bit more easily if it were Poyser and her).