• We're looking for artists. Direct message Dr. Watson for more info!

Game Ranked COVID-19 Mafia Game Thread

Status
Not open for further replies.
Awards
Awards

MVP
- Grammaton

Been thinking about this all day as I think it’s really close between him and Ekko for the MVP slot. Both worked really well together and both took control of direction and came in clutch at different times and drove the mislynches. Really really good performance by both guys. What tips it over the edge for me is the trust that Gram managed to foster in the neighbourhood chat as I feel that ended up being integral to the win and especially managing to keep it alive through the disastrous tracker result and mislynch of fang. He also took the lead in the final phase and saw it home, although I don’t want to put this as a negative for Ekko as I do think it’s equally as important to recognise when you’re not well trusted and shouldn’t be leading conversation.

HM - Ekko

As above

HM - Aurelian

I don’t usually like giving out awards solely for role usage but there were no other stand outs this game from my pov. He didn’t capitalise on the damning info he had as much as I would have liked, but the usage and result itself was absolutely huge and had the potential to blow the game wide open. It’s the only reason scum didn’t score a fairly processional clean sweep in my opinion.

As for the game itself I enjoyed watching it. Despite how comfortably scum ended up winning, it was a little town sided and this was by design as recruits are a bitch to hunt for so I wanted to give them as much of a chance as I could. Also, mafia could have made it easier on themselves by recruiting certain roles of course and it could have worked out different. That said, if I ran this again I’d give mafia 1 more starting number as them failing both their recruits here would have been catastrophic and largely game deciding. I’ve put more of my thoughts on the setup in the dead chat.

Excellent performance by mafia from the start really. I gave town what I thought were 4 pillars they could trust and rely on and they managed to lynch 2 of them. Achieving 5 mislynches is nothing to be sniffed at, especially when losing two of your own.

Some townies were on the right track but were unfortunately unable to either persuade others or stick to their guns. Thought both tweet and soul killer played well and in particularly with tweet, thought he could have bossed this game if he played with more energy and made himself clearly town which he definitely has the ability to do.

Again, thanks for playing guys! Will add people that ask to the respective chats when I get some free time either tonight or in the morning. Others that have the ability to are free to go ahead and add whoever.​
 
How when he even bought your Hider claim?
he agreed that cops should abstain until n2 and was commenting on the number of recruitable players

luka/lethal/tweet never did that. they seemed clueless about non recruitable mechanic
cp claimed vt
gram was culted
flower claimed miller
saber was hinting some neighbor chat with flower

soul/gad were our best guesses for cop due to their comments on the amount of recruitables. we cfd'ed gad hoping we'd blind lynch the cop but turns out hes a non-recruitable doctor. soul was the next in line best guess
 
He seemed like cop who had the same idea of abstaining np1 (now know that wasn't what he did but still lol)
Just thought of it, if I had that role from my pov, I would not use it N1 as well if it was 1 shot, especially if that ability is high risk where I would die if the person I would die if I hide behind scum. But either way, that wrong guess of yours lead to you a correct guess about my role it seems like which is fair play I guess, lucky, but very fair play lol.
 
Pretty hard to decisively outargue Gram to the point where everyone woulda went for him over myself, I still thought it was obvious as all hell I played my tole as towny as possible
 
Awards

MVP
- Grammaton

Been thinking about this all day as I think it’s really close between him and Ekko for the MVP slot. Both worked really well together and both took control of direction and came in clutch at different times and drove the mislynches. Really really good performance by both guys. What tips it over the edge for me is the trust that Gram managed to foster in the neighbourhood chat as I feel that ended up being integral to the win and especially managing to keep it alive through the disastrous tracker result and mislynch of fang. He also took the lead in the final phase and saw it home, although I don’t want to put this as a negative for Ekko as I do think it’s equally as important to recognise when you’re not well trusted and shouldn’t be leading conversation.

HM - Ekko

As above

HM - Aurelian

I don’t usually like giving out awards solely for role usage but there were no other stand outs this game from my pov. He didn’t capitalise on the damning info he had as much as I would have liked, but the usage and result itself was absolutely huge and had the potential to blow the game wide open. It’s the only reason scum didn’t score a fairly processional clean sweep in my opinion.

As for the game itself I enjoyed watching it. Despite how comfortably scum ended up winning, it was a little town sided and this was by design as recruits are a bitch to hunt for so I wanted to give them as much of a chance as I could. Also, mafia could have made it easier on themselves by recruiting certain roles of course and it could have worked out different. That said, if I ran this again I’d give mafia 1 more starting number as them failing both their recruits here would have been catastrophic and largely game deciding. I’ve put more of my thoughts on the setup in the dead chat.

Excellent performance by mafia from the start really. I gave town what I thought were 4 pillars they could trust and rely on and they managed to lynch 2 of them. Achieving 5 mislynches is nothing to be sniffed at, especially when losing two of your own.

Some townies were on the right track but were unfortunately unable to either persuade others or stick to their guns. Thought both tweet and soul killer played well and in particularly with tweet, thought he could have bossed this game if he played with more energy and made himself clearly town which he definitely has the ability to do.

Again, thanks for playing guys! Will add people that ask to the respective chats when I get some free time either tonight or in the morning. Others that have the ability to are free to go ahead and add whoever.​
gg, i think mvp is well deserved. i did work in the early game but couldnt have took it home without gram late game and his work in the neighberhood

ive pushed a grand total of 10 townies this game, surprised im still alive. got gram to thank for that
 
Pretty hard to decisively outargue Gram to the point where everyone woulda went for him over myself, I still thought it was obvious as all hell I played my tole as towny as possible
Your WIFOM defense was the issue. There's no need for this nonsense when you can just say "I'm Town, listen to me dammit!". The reason why I hesitated so much is because I could see you as Town after your reactions. You argued yourself into a hole with WIFOM instead of just being you.
 
Awards

MVP
- Grammaton

Been thinking about this all day as I think it’s really close between him and Ekko for the MVP slot. Both worked really well together and both took control of direction and came in clutch at different times and drove the mislynches. Really really good performance by both guys. What tips it over the edge for me is the trust that Gram managed to foster in the neighbourhood chat as I feel that ended up being integral to the win and especially managing to keep it alive through the disastrous tracker result and mislynch of fang. He also took the lead in the final phase and saw it home, although I don’t want to put this as a negative for Ekko as I do think it’s equally as important to recognise when you’re not well trusted and shouldn’t be leading conversation.

HM - Ekko

As above

HM - Aurelian

I don’t usually like giving out awards solely for role usage but there were no other stand outs this game from my pov. He didn’t capitalise on the damning info he had as much as I would have liked, but the usage and result itself was absolutely huge and had the potential to blow the game wide open. It’s the only reason scum didn’t score a fairly processional clean sweep in my opinion.

As for the game itself I enjoyed watching it. Despite how comfortably scum ended up winning, it was a little town sided and this was by design as recruits are a bitch to hunt for so I wanted to give them as much of a chance as I could. Also, mafia could have made it easier on themselves by recruiting certain roles of course and it could have worked out different. That said, if I ran this again I’d give mafia 1 more starting number as them failing both their recruits here would have been catastrophic and largely game deciding. I’ve put more of my thoughts on the setup in the dead chat.

Excellent performance by mafia from the start really. I gave town what I thought were 4 pillars they could trust and rely on and they managed to lynch 2 of them. Achieving 5 mislynches is nothing to be sniffed at, especially when losing two of your own.

Some townies were on the right track but were unfortunately unable to either persuade others or stick to their guns. Thought both tweet and soul killer played well and in particularly with tweet, thought he could have bossed this game if he played with more energy and made himself clearly town which he definitely has the ability to do.

Again, thanks for playing guys! Will add people that ask to the respective chats when I get some free time either tonight or in the morning. Others that have the ability to are free to go ahead and add whoever.​
Thought I played a pretty good town game tbdean caught hime and my legacy heavily sussed gram/ekko
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top