Nevertheless I still consider that taking into account that scums were supposedly aware on that, the Sharter reactions are not good.
1. He didn't know on the possible replacement if not scum.
2. This list is mostly lolcatting, however also made for reactions check.
3. List is on 4 mafia players naming this is full squad.
4. We have 5 mafias on game.
5. On my worldview the first reaction should seek for mentioned Townslip on number of scums (mentioned Level 1)
6. Sharter immidiately go for Level 2 of that - looking if I have excess knowledge on the replacement of RDL-not-realized-slot.
As of that it looks for me that player which wanted to be replaced is indeed a scum and Sharter approached with TMI and bad faith.