• We're looking for artists. Direct message Dr. Watson for more info!

Game Ranked Grand Theft Auto Mafia

Status
Not open for further replies.
Reader mode
Ultra said:
So out of spite you're going to...double down and lynch more townies? The scum team thanks you.
Click to expand...
hey ultra if magic is scum is sky aligned or is he tmi'ing her town. trying to figure this out

also magic ofcourse disappears when i show him my position on gad day 1. if hes town this is worst than the amongus game
 
Achromatic said:
Not at all. Let's look at the timeline:

You asked for votes
I gave a vote

If I wanted to trump up charges or cared to make my vote look like anything other than what it was I can obviously do this as scum. However I didn't. Kind of a weird thing to do as scum don't you think? To just blatantly help lynch a town. Almost like I am not scum or something and didn't know the flip in advance.

Also I never shit post. Unless it's like a mash. You not having the understanding why my vote makes me almost always town is suspicios from a good player. The fact that you think it's the opposite is a legitimate skill issue if you are town my man lol. I have no reason to place that vote as scum while I already laid down why I did it as town. To see how you were doing early game.


Turns out you sucked. If you are town I suggest you stop sucking tbh
Click to expand...

Reasoning is kind of WIFOM but I would give a town lean based on tone.
 
Emil said:
hey ultra if magic is scum is sky aligned or is he tmi'ing her town. trying to figure this out

also magic ofcourse disappears when i show him my position on gad day 1. if hes town this is worst than the amongus game
Click to expand...

I can't reconcile her positions and I strongly feel like she kept pairing RDK's name with Gad early today to drive consensus (under the assumption RDK is town and she leaned into the pairing to push him off Gad who is outted)
 
Emil said:
instead of this, whats ur take on me and alco/RDK. why r u so uninvolved from the discussion?
Click to expand...
I think the discussion is pretty stupid and I don't like getting involved in things I deem to be largely emotions at play as opposed to actual solving. No disrespect towards anybody actually in the discussion, I just don't think either side is seeing things with a clear head

Alco is wolfy and going UTR without doing much, RDK is villagery but I wouldnt object to the flip to resolve wagons.
 
Lord Melkor said:
Reasoning is kind of WIFOM but I would give a town lean based on tone.
Click to expand...
melkor just claim pls, u can catchup all u want after that. ultra and i basically got the poe narrowed down to few slots and are just looking at the final links to nail it down. if u r town help us out with that

i have info, pls go ahead and claim. if i claim before you, the chance of ur claim being believed is much much lower
 
Luka said:
I think the discussion is pretty stupid and I don't like getting involved in things I deem to be largely emotions at play as opposed to actual solving. No disrespect towards anybody actually in the discussion, I just don't think either side is seeing things with a clear head

Alco is wolfy and going UTR without doing much, RDK is villagery but I wouldnt object to the flip to resolve wagons.
Click to expand...
then put a vote on alco's new slot and lets get him to claim

RDK ducked the thread and offered basically nothing. his claim better be DAMN good or else can be disposed off
 
I can't recall Gad expressing much of an opinion on me before he random voted me (to the point that even Ultra, who scum reads me, was flabbergasted) so that screams "voting anyone but scum" tbh
 
Ultra said:
@Fujishiro here's what I'm talking about by the way:



















Starting from top to bottom - I ask Achro if he was planning on actually placing a vote that would go anywhere and he postures and says he'd prefer to go with his own leads.

Not long before the execution shebang he lays a case out on Polar Bear and insists on it in spite of input from other players and with EoD looming close

I think it's hard for me to reconcile him being insistent here on PB as anything less than knowing intentionally that he was going to split the wagon, we barely had 5 votes on the existing one and he's championing a 3rd axis, which fits the profile of what happened later with the execute. Make sense?
Click to expand...

Was Gad already a main wagon when he stsrted pushing PB?
 
Ultra said:
:biden

Yes, of course you knew this

So if RDK was your "main read" and you clearly preferred him over Gad, why did you make it clear you could go either way earlier?
Click to expand...
Because it's a matter of balance. RDK being my preference but Gad being closer to consensus because NLing is bad. This has been my consistent position my entire mafia "career"
 
Ultra said:
I can't reconcile her positions and I strongly feel like she kept pairing RDK's name with Gad early today to drive consensus (under the assumption RDK is town and she leaned into the pairing to push him off Gad who is outted)
Click to expand...
town!RDK has all the cards to solve the game here, pretty tilting if he is and hes not doing it
 
@Sky you started entertaining me/Gad being a pair after

A) Admitting you town read my claim

And

B) Giving no reason on Gad, and now admitting you never had one

Do you see the problem here
 
Reader mode
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top