• We're looking for artists. Direct message Dr. Watson for more info!

Game Ranked Hero Killer Mafia

Status
This thread has been locked by the thread creator and is currently not open for replies.
Reader mode
Hayumi said:
Miraka and Brad but less on Brad more on Miraka right now.

Luka
Cata
Pepeboi

also want to dive into these slots I think
Click to expand...

Feels like the only reason you're sussing me is cause of my response when I had a vote from me and Brad saying I'm scummy but not saying why. I don't really understand it or your current vote on me

jay23 said:
there's nothing to get stuck to in this thread, so them being stuck seems unnatural, especially when a lot of other things have happened and they still call back to it.

makes you wonder if it's real or fake
Click to expand...

I know right, I just can't believe Brad would solely focus on me if they were town. Doesn't make any sense whatsoever

Also someone made the point they didn't even look at Fuji at all after the duel which suggests TMI at play

Alexis2282AE said:
@jay23 You never responded to this.

Here are the reads I found:

I'm hard scum-reading Lethal right now. Mind telling me why you're reading him as townie?
Click to expand...

Quoting this for context for the next message

jay23 said:
because he's an obvious villager

unless someone comes and tells me he can fake it as a wolf, i would never take the read back. but judging on the fact that his peers village read him and don't act like he could still be in range, it's probably a good sign he's avilla
Click to expand...

Lethal's played a lot it seems, so maybe they can fake it? But I still agree with you that Lethal is at least a town lean here. Others would be able to comment more intelligently on the range thing than me

jay23 said:
i am not that familiar with them tbh. i did play with brad multiple games, but they are mashes and he's not someone that i make a conscious effort to read / he's not in that spot for me where i can just soul read him off a random post or whatever

and miraka i only have 1-2 turbos.

i found brad's posting just now odd but it doesn't mean anything
Click to expand...

Yeah on that note you reminded me to reread those games at some point to see how your play varied as scum vs. town. But if I reread every player's games here I'd be spending all my time on that instead of actually reading what's in the thread which would probably be more useful anyhow

Agree with you that Brad's posting was a bit odd, doesn't seem to me that it would really come from a townie

Hayumi said:
Brad for sort of fence sitting on Miraka and not really pushing despite claiming to have reason to sus them. Now that Miraka is voting him he pulled an OMGUS back and kind of doubled down with his vote but he still hasn’t actually given a well thought out reason why..?

Miraka for their response to early pressure. Kind of seemed to get heated over what looked like nothing tbh, and then in their read list has Brad as a sus but I asked them if they would be down to pressure them with me and they were kind of against it at the time. Also sussed Aurelian who was sussing them back, and it didn’t seem super genuine idk.

They also have Stick as their top scum read and I disagree with that

I did think they could have scum equity early on but with how they’re interacting currently and plus what those familiar with them said, that’s probably not the case lol.


The rest I named are not scum leans just nulls that have just started to ping me for different reasons scrolling back.

Pepe- not really getting any solving energy like in the cross community game. Kind of just going through the motions atp.

Cata- I just need to see way more before giving them any type of TL or SL. Haven’t done anything yet.

Luka- Kind of pinged me asking where I was going with certain posts like trying to hint at a certain narrative I was just nothing posting idk just a vibe
Click to expand...

Feels like you're just making things up here, Brad was clearly trying to set me up for failure by not saying why they were scummy so that it would be harder for me to defend myself. I reckon they thought I'd be an easy d1 mislynch for being new, not realizing they'd awoken and enraged the beast that would tear the mafia apart limb from limb

Speaking of that, it feels like you're pulling most of the read from me out of your a** cause I did vote Brad soon after and you're STILL bringing it up. I changed my mind on Stick a bit (they're still closer to null than town lean for me) but it feels like you're just annoyed at me because I don't agree with your reads and you don't agree with mine

Do agree on Pepe being kinda null so far

I legit forgot Cata was in this game, every time someone mentions them I'm like, 'who's that'?

Luka - still not sure on them, a few of their posts don't make sense to me at all, but I also feel like there's bigger fish to fry today

BradLand said:
Reason 1. He Newcomb Told via talking about what he's doing in a way to get credit.

Reason 2. His reaction was shit because he tried to defend/use reasoning for my scumread on him, when I never actually stated reasons for my scumread on him until literally now.

I didn't bring up the Newcomb Tell portion just because it's been unreliable, but he did the second thing in reaction to my scumread and it kinda made him look worse.

It annoyed me that he decided to go after me when I said I'd pull back but if this is what he does with it, he can die.
Click to expand...

Legit took me a minute to realize what 'Newcomb' meant

From what I can tell you fake-hedged and then set me up so that whatever I'd say you'd just try to pull it apart like a lawyer in Ace Attorney or whatever detective game you fan-fic when you aren't playing Mafia

And how did that turn out for you, scum?

You look the worst of everyone here and I'm gonna put the trophy on my profile wall of nailing the mafia day 1 when you flip scum

Stick said:
hmm ok imma say brad's v tentatively


atsumori had a pretty wolfy pop in earlier that they did nothing with so im happy with my vote there
Click to expand...

Don't agree on Brad obviously

But Atsumori is someone who flew under my radar, probably a good person for me to ISO later in the day

Grammaton said:
Nobody right now

Is there a particular reason youre seemingly interacting with me only?
Click to expand...

Seems a fair question, Gram is still more null than town lean for me but I liked this question

Hayumi said:
See tracking the logic somewhat but I’m also confuzzed by this

Like you’re basically saying you were trying to be nice but now just all bc he’s sussing you back…you want to yeet him? So if he never would have said that you would be looking elsewhere?
Click to expand...

This feels a bit rambly to me (I know, funny that I say that) though the final question is valid

Hayumi said:
Vote Lynch Miraka

Hear me out yall, do we use this dueling opportunity to yeet both birds with one stone? Surely it’s not giving T v T
Click to expand...

No. Idk why you'd think that, it's such a random thing to say especially with what others said. Inclined to sus you a bit for hedging so transparently

Grammaton said:
Nah, id rather just take two shots on plausible scum leads, never a fan of hedging
Click to expand...

OK actually I town read Grammation after this, was gonna call this out as well but Gram said it the best
 
Reader mode
Status
This thread has been locked by the thread creator and is currently not open for replies.
Back
Top