• We're looking for artists. Direct message Dr. Watson for more info!

Game Ranked Hero Killer Mafia

Status
This thread has been locked by the thread creator and is currently not open for replies.
hayumi i just made a recent post on. my only gripe with her was her start which felt weak / like a wolf would do it. otherwise, her posting afterwards was good or at the very least i had no issues with it. which is about good enough for d1

sherlock is just a gut take that i could be wrong on, as i said he's a yolo read, that tier automatically means i don't have a strong reason for thinking it, i just do. just based on experiences and archetypes of people i've dealt with, he seemed to fit that of a villager, even though it's thin

for stick and luka it's more of a pair thing. i think luka is village siding which is enough to have him north side of null and stick is kinda wolfy here which, by the law of reverse reading which i apply for her and some other player, that would make her villagery (so im basically saying she's wolfy to me, but she's a wolfy villager, so it'd make her a villager). also she doesn't seem to be pushing an agenda thus far
For Hayumi: What specifically changed or what did they post that you considered good, contrasting with the start?
For Sherlock: Can you describe the archetype you think he fits? What specific behaviors make you place him in that category?
For Stick: How do you differentiate between Stick being a 'wolfy villager' and Stick actually being a wolf this game? What would she need to do differently for you to think she was a wolf?
 
I see. Guess hell die either ways.

Hi Luka!
hi fuji!!!
You dont want to punish me though.
but what if brad was like, cop or something lol
its pretty reckless to duel someone without at the very least getting their claim and i kinda do think it just comes from a wolf

(i kinda wanna play with you true but its objectively best to punish you IMO, especially since i think brad is near locked)
 
Vote Duel Bradland
soz fuji
tumblr_inline_pkrj51qeMK1sc6mmj_500.gif


But first you have to gather the votes to out duel my faithful minions.​
 
mirake's tone changes up a bit when he's replying to brad eh? possible distancing going on there imho
litearlly zero world where this is the case. if brad is wolf just hard clear everyone he votes, hes alergic to distancing
i also just think brad faking this ate is pretty outside of his wolf range
 
Arne can be mafia for that take, tho i remain unconvinced that miraka is mafia tbh (i will consider it if u flip, brad, but im kinda v reading their effort and engagement)
nah arne can be anything for someone who doesnt know brad its a reasonable take
just find him by if hes town siding or not imho
 
hi fuji!!!
Hello.
but what if brad was like, cop or something lol
its pretty reckless to duel someone without at the very least getting their claim and i kinda do think it just comes from a wolf

(i kinda wanna play with you true but its objectively best to punish you IMO, especially since i think brad is near locked)
The hand of fate landed on them as foretold by my decision to sheep Gram. He is not to blame for my decision btw in the event Brad flips town.
 
For Sherlock: Can you describe the archetype you think he fits? What specific behaviors make you place him in that category?
i just liked his questions is all, they felt pretty sharp and pretty early which i value

for stick - agenda. i don't see one yet. or TMI

for hayumi - i think i might be subjected to a bias because i was onto her very early for weak reasoning (that could be right) and she posted herself out of it and by contrast i dropped my earlier lean. basically i called her a wolf that was lazy and not doing any catchups and turns out she had the reasoning typed out all along, she just didn't post it cuz after i asked, like 1 min later she drops a wall with all the reasons for her reads. so my concerns faded which can't help but make me villa lean her
 
Status
This thread has been locked by the thread creator and is currently not open for replies.
Back
Top