• We're looking for artists. Direct message Dr. Watson for more info!

Game Ranked Hero Killer Mafia

Reader mode
Living Players:
1) @Lethal
2) @hime (sub for Fujishiro)
3) @Atsumori
5) @Alexis2282AE
8) @Luka (sub for Spongebobek)
9) @PepeBoi
11) @GoddessBlade (sub for Grammaton)
12) @Lappland
14) @Stick
15) @jay23
16) @Mlraka
17) @Aurelian

So if I townlean Aurelian and consider Alexis and Lethal just v/v then we have:
2) @hime (sub for Fujishiro)
3) @Atsumori
8) @Luka (sub for Spongebobek)
11) @GoddessBlade (sub for Grammaton)
12) @Lappland
14) @Stick
15) @jay23
16) @Mlraka

so here we have like 50% chance to lynch maf if we have 4 of them left. Also Hime is playing well since the beggining (and she's a girl) and I would never kill a girl. So It's like 7 players left. Did GoddessBlade type anything yet since subbing?
 
PepeBoi said:
Living Players:
1) @Lethal
2) @hime (sub for Fujishiro)
3) @Atsumori
5) @Alexis2282AE
8) @Luka (sub for Spongebobek)
9) @PepeBoi
11) @GoddessBlade (sub for Grammaton)
12) @Lappland
14) @Stick
15) @jay23
16) @Mlraka
17) @Aurelian

So if I townlean Aurelian and consider Alexis and Lethal just v/v then we have:
2) @hime (sub for Fujishiro)
3) @Atsumori
8) @Luka (sub for Spongebobek)
11) @GoddessBlade (sub for Grammaton)
12) @Lappland
14) @Stick
15) @jay23
16) @Mlraka

so here we have like 50% chance to lynch maf if we have 4 of them left. Also Hime is playing well since the beggining (and she's a girl) and I would never kill a girl. So It's like 7 players left. Did GoddessBlade type anything yet since subbing?
Click to expand...

The problem with this analysis is

I'm pretty sure there's at least one mafia in Aurelian and Lethal
 
i iso'd luka and it's pretty bleak. he doesn't have as much content as i would've liked. @Luka what do you think you're villagery off of since you said you were?

Luka said:
hi fuji!!!

but what if brad was like, cop or something lol
its pretty reckless to duel someone without at the very least getting their claim and i kinda do think it just comes from a wolf

(i kinda wanna play with you true but its objectively best to punish you IMO, especially since i think brad is near locked)
Click to expand...

i thought this post kinda had an upside down view which was weird. this clearly should be a good sign, not a bad one. if he doesn't get a claim and he challenges a cop, it's obvious he's gonna die. it's a risk to throw yourself in like that too

Luka said:
mlraka's gonna be null for me for the rest of the gmae since i refuse to read their posts
ill just sheep someone good on them and move on
Click to expand...

feels a bit odd considering he was posting a ton, but meh, let's say it's NAI since i didn't read most of his walls either

Luka said:
dude gets overtly emotional as town and not as wolf. he would probbaly be a bit miffed as wolf but not like IM NOT GOING TO POST SINCE THEIRS NO POINT, FUCK THIS GAME AND YOURE A MOD TOO?

obviously thats hyperbole but the point stands
Click to expand...

i don't have that much trouble with this post, but just his entire stance on brad felt way too confident than I'd like him to be, but i'll give benefit of doubt since prob all MUers but me took brad at lvl 0 villa claiming and weren't careful at all about it

Luka said:
mlk doesnt feel like a villager they responded to most things ive said with bad faith imo

understand i havent read and wont read any of their qoute walls
Click to expand...

kinda odd that he doesn't push him more when he has this read or he says he'll ignore mlk

Luka said:
lappland / aurelian / goddessblade / cataclysm prob is at least 2/4
add atsumori / pepeboi if youre feeling cute but i dont rly feel it
Click to expand...

doesn't look too accurate

Luka said:
cata was wolfy as hell itt but rdk feels towny is what im getting at i guess
i may or may not have recenxy bias since i was p convinced on ctaa but /shrug

@Arne Slot can i have ur thoughts on rdks posting
Click to expand...

and the one problem i have with this is that i had the opposite take, that rdk was overdoing it. and i thought cata was fine xD


he has a few weird interactions with hayumi, they almost seem too awkward to be a wolf. i think this is the time he needs to put in some thoughts because i don't know what to do with luka other than having him some form of PoE
 
PepeBoi said:
so here we have like 50% chance to lynch maf if we have 4 of them left. Also Hime is playing well since the beggining (and she's a girl) and I would never kill a girl. So It's like 7 players left. Did GoddessBlade type anything yet since subbing?
Click to expand...
we never killed brad, he reincarnated in pepeboi...
====

they did, they said we're talking too much and that's about it iirc
 
i sorta like her village reading lapp for some reason though. it screams UNAWARE to me, in a good way. lol
 
PepeBoi said:
Living Players:
1) @Lethal
2) @hime (sub for Fujishiro)
3) @Atsumori
5) @Alexis2282AE
8) @Luka (sub for Spongebobek)
9) @PepeBoi
11) @GoddessBlade (sub for Grammaton)
12) @Lappland
14) @Stick
15) @jay23
16) @Mlraka
17) @Aurelian

So if I townlean Aurelian and consider Alexis and Lethal just v/v then we have:
2) @hime (sub for Fujishiro)
3) @Atsumori
8) @Luka (sub for Spongebobek)
11) @GoddessBlade (sub for Grammaton)
12) @Lappland
14) @Stick
15) @jay23
16) @Mlraka

so here we have like 50% chance to lynch maf if we have 4 of them left. Also Hime is playing well since the beggining (and she's a girl) and I would never kill a girl. So It's like 7 players left. Did GoddessBlade type anything yet since subbing?
Click to expand...
I'm also a girl :zerouwu:
 
I will be back tomorrow, it's quite telling that the peanut gallery who contributed nothing comes out to vote me out of nowhere
 
Like I could go on a rant now, but like
It would take me 40 minutes to explain what I think about playing like that
 
Actually there is something I wanna talk about


it is something called integrity. It is not often that I have like the chance to talk about this, but regardless. Mafia as a game is like very important to me, I love it a lot. More so than I imagine anyone else. I still often think back on games I played in 2015 for example and what I did there and why. How my play changed across these years.

So at one point I realised something, many people do not realise this sadly. Winning and losing only matters in certain contexts. The stakes of the game and the level of play, what actually happened in it. For example I lost a game recently, I was the n2 kill from the wolf team. I actually sorted them all correctly and even lynched 2 back to back. Too bad the rest of town was actually afk and only posted 5 times. So the game was lost in f3 after my death. So I asked myself? Does this loss matter? Well not really, the village did not play at all. How could I win this game, if the villagers don't show up to play it. Likewise I have seen afk wolf teams win games. Does it really count if the winning wolf team has 3 posts among them? You can't reasonably find them. Some people might realise that like not posting at all, might reward them victories, but do these victories really count? No, not at all.

They are as worthless as the play displayed. So where am I going with this? Well it matters a lot to me how I win and why. I could probably find 200 ways to cheat the game in spirit, but win which are completely legal. But these wins would be as meaningful as if I had just disappeared for 3 dayphases.

And here I see a bunch of people, well a wolf team, capitalizing on a bunch of headless villagers who can't really tell their head from their tail. So what to do? Should I take it up the chin? Accept that you guys simply do not care about the game enough to give it the effort it deserves? Maybe, it would definetely keep my sanity more in check. I am prone to aggression after all.

But a part in me wants to see you guys fail. It is precisely because you do not wanna spare the effort, that I try to give. You fall for the easiest libel, you endore openly cheating players like Alexis as town, you do not question narratives. And all in all, I would love to say certain things, but once I do people will cry foul and how much I insulted them. But nonetheless, people should be challenged on their view points more often and if I have to do it, then I hate sugar coating it. Too many times we engage in stupid hugboxes in this game and I don't like it. If we can't face valid criticism then, we are not made for a game that is about criticizing thought processes, manipulating people and the likes.
I also feel like people demand this surgical and often robotic play without fervor and spirit. I am personally not a fan of it, I think it takes the thrill out of the game, the entire enjoyment. And for what? So that we do not engage in 4 hour long shout matches? I mean I get why people dislike it, but anger is a common reaction to being challenged, to being called a liar and the likes.

So where I am at, mafia is slowly killing itself as game
 
Reader mode
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top