Hime, this is what I'm referring to
What I mean is, you placed him in the town pile but didn't expand on it prior. The only indicator for *why* you were reading him as town wasn't mentioned. It was just you throwing him in there.
Compared to the previous phase where he was on the chopping block and the only reason given was you felt he was being genuine and it was less likely (for you/iyo) scum would make this play and try to appeal to pathos to pocket.
You didn't really address what made him town beyond that. Why? Why was he in your town reads to begin with?