• We're looking for artists. Direct message Dr. Watson for more info!

Game Ranked Members Mafia 2 - One Last Mafia Game

Status
Not open for further replies.
I was obviously town
Role confirmed
Anyone still tunneling me after that has to be scum

Episode 7 Shrug GIF by America's Got Talent's Got Talent
Nah your role was nowhere near as self-clearing as you think
 
I redirected him to himself as we were only looking for one hostile killer at the time so I wanted to clear him if he wasn't the shooter or kill him if he was

Couldn't have forseen what actually happened :bosque:
I was pretty sure melkor was the last scum but as I said to Ultra if they were actually a roleblocker we wouldn't learn anything by me redirecting them to themselves as it would just block everything
 
I redirected him to himself as we were only looking for one hostile killer at the time so I wanted to clear him if he wasn't the shooter or kill him if he was

Couldn't have forseen what actually happened :bosque:
He kinda did mention he was gonna ignite but in hindsight if you look at the players he had primed, simply not igniting would have been way smarter
 
A night chat has no positive utility for scum
Its clearly a town role.
Unless you think host added it just to clear scum which is bastardly.
Like making scum the cop...
Ultra learned after that
Town can give wolves towny roles for town cred
It isn't "bastard" to do so. Bastard is when either:
1) Their are unnannounced game changing mechanics
2) The host lies to the player
(generally)
neither of which is giving a party host to a wolf
 
A night chat has no positive utility for scum
Its clearly a town role.
Unless you think host added it just to clear scum which is bastardly.
Like making scum the cop...
Ultra learned after that
Actually does since scum can use the night to control the thread, just like during the day.

It‘s not clearing at all, it works perfectly as a scum claimable.
 
Town can give wolves towny roles for town cred
It isn't "bastard" to do so. Bastard is when either:
1) Their are unnannounced game changing mechanics
2) The host lies to the player
(generally)
neither of which is giving a party host to a wolf

We don't do that bs in ranked games
Literally no reason for scum to allow players to talk more
Anti scum and against win condition
 
A night chat has no positive utility for scum
Its clearly a town role.
Unless you think host added it just to clear scum which is bastardly.
Like making scum the cop...
Ultra learned after that
Yeah a role like that can be given to scum in order to give them something to claim. Talking at night potentially has utility for scum as well, it allows them to see reactions to whatever flip just went down and then have a better idea of whom to kill after they figure out who's onside and who isn't. I agree giving scum the Cop or Vig is bastardly but your role this game doesn't come close to that in terms of power imo.
 
Actually does since scum can use the night to control the thread, just like during the day.

It‘s not clearing at all, it works perfectly as a scum claimable.

Yeah a role like that can be given to scum in order to give them something to claim. Talking at night potentially has utility for scum as well, it allows them to see reactions to whatever flip just went down and then have a better idea of whom to kill after they figure out who's onside and who isn't. I agree giving scum the Cop or Vig is bastardly but your role this game doesn't come close to that in terms of power imo.
Lolvogel too slow to reply.

(Sorry I just like calling you that now lmao.)
 
Nah
Kekko had to die
Even your boy magic had him as scum
Guy was dross this game
In fairness we were in a bit of a weird situation. We were town but couldn't claim our actual roles, but rather conceal who our mason partner was. It was kinda difficult to play an unrestrained town game like that, with the added difficulty of one of us randomly turning into the SK on any given night.
 
In fairness we were in a bit of a weird situation. We were town but couldn't claim our actual roles, but rather conceal who our mason partner was. It was kinda difficult to play an unrestrained town game like that, with the added difficulty of one of us randomly turning into the SK on any given night.

I meant kekko not magic
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top