Game Ranked Members Mafia 2 - One Last Mafia Game

[Poyser]

I mean that happens to just about everyone.

Thsnks for supporting my Luka push at the very least

Sad that alone makes me lean more scum for you than town

Sounds like a skill issue on your end
Look at doflas posts about me/mine about him
Basically confirmed

 

[Poyser]

One thing I gotta mention before y'all proceed with whatever

Lethal claimed Gunsmith
CP claimed QT Cop

Fuji daykilled Dofla
Dofla had a role that removes him from the QT for a while

Both roles seem likely to be for real and we're also seeing reasons for why they're in the game. My question is why is this being treated like a CC situation? On paper couldn't those roles coexist in the same town?

Would you say the same if a cop claimed after a hider or something similar? Almost certainly not so this is kind of a weird post

 

[Grammaton]

One thing I gotta mention before y'all proceed with whatever

Lethal claimed Gunsmith
CP claimed QT Cop

Fuji daykilled Dofla
Dofla had a role that removes him from the QT for a while

Both roles seem likely to be for real and we're also seeing reasons for why they're in the game. My question is why is this being treated like a CC situation? On paper couldn't those roles coexist in the same town?

Ive reason to doubt it yes

 

[Sparkles]

Also unless she’s an unlimited roleblocker, I find it pretty hard to believe she just blind blocked Fuji on N1. Assuming she’s limited that’s a ridiculous play

I mean limited roleblocker using their role randonly on N1 isn’t usually the best strategy either but we can’t prove that she did use it so whatever.

Who’s her character?

 

[Sparkles]

Sounds like a skill issue on your end
Look at doflas posts about me/mine about him
Basically confirmed

I haven’t read D1, why you being mean?

 

[Poyser]

I mean limited roleblocker using their role randonly on N1 isn’t usually the best strategy either but we can’t prove that she did use it so whatever.

Who’s her character?

I mean as town, as scum it’s different lol
I’m saying it’s hard to believe she does that as town. It’s a terrible play unless she’s unlimited and doesn’t have to worry about wasting shots

She’s lord Melkor

 

[Sparkles]

Gonna laugh out loud if I look and it feels more like distancing and you calling it basically confirmed ngl

 

[Poyser]

Gonna laugh out loud if I look and it feels more like distancing and you calling it basically confirmed ngl

Well I won’t deprive you of coming to your own conclusion. Have at it

 

[Grammaton]

Also being overlooked is that she only changed her behavior when she was called out, then went too far the other way

 

[Grammaton]

You know, kinda like how people trying to fake emotion do

 

[Poyser]

Also being overlooked is that she only changed her behavior when she was called out, then went too far the other way

Yes, the reaction to me really wasn’t earned

 

[Sparkles]

I think it’s possible we have both Gunsmith/QT Cop given the neighborizer claim/Dofla’s role.

I’m on Luka partially due too this.

 

[Poyser]

Junk really going to bat for lethal huh

 

[RDK]

My biggest hangup with Hime i think is that she didn't seem to speculate on fuji potentially having been vig/serial/scum when day started and she revealed her usage.

There was only 1 kill, so if she truly blocked him I'd expect her to have those sort of thoughts

Fuji hadn't killed dofla yet either so he wasn't confirmed at all (still isn't if you think a serial killer could have a daykill as a claimable)

 

[Poyser]

My biggest hangup with Hime i think is that she didn't seem to speculate on fuji potentially having been vig/serial/scum when day started and she revealed her usage.

There was only 1 kill, so if she truly blocked him I'd expect her to have those sort of thoughts

Fuji hadn't killed dofla yet either so he wasn't confirmed at all (still isn't if you think a serial killer could have a daykill as a claimable)

Especially as flower clearly wasn’t the vig kill lol

 

[Sparkles]

Gram doesn’t interact with me ever, what behaviour is he talking about Poyser?

 

[Hans Tweetenberg]

Would you say the same if a cop claimed after a hider or something similar? Almost certainly not so this is kind of a weird post

Mmm idk I don't think it's quite that cut and dried. The two things those roles check for tend to amount to basically the same thing since scum can all kill and are all in a chat, but with an extra town killing role (kinda assuming there's a vig somewhere) and a scum role that can detach itself from the chat it gets a bit more blurry.

Fwiw I noticed nothing out of Lethal d1 and Gram is also hinting stuff so maybe this isn't the time to be all like wElL aKShuLlY

 

[Poyser]

Gram doesn’t interact with me ever, what behaviour is he talking about Poyser?

Hime was being called out for being a damp squib and then magically started aggressively counter pushing me and calling me nasty names

 

[Sparkles]

Junk really going to bat for lethal huh

Ya’ll do what u want with him. I already said he’s probably our best yeet today as his flip clears up a lot. But i’m iffy on potentially losing a gunsmith on D2.

 

[Poyser]

Ya’ll do what u want with him. I already said he’s probably our best yeet today as his flip clears up a lot. But i’m iffy on potentially losing a gunsmith on D2.

It’s ok, we basically have 2 of the same role and the roleblocker is allegedly town so we’re golden