Game Ranked Members Mafia 2 - One Last Mafia Game

[Magic]

Quite easily

I didn't make a single incorrect read this game

'Lmao'

i was in fact town***

 

[Arne Slot]

Think we are being properly gaslit about how well cp played here

Spent half the game pushing junk, Haza, magic and Ekko

you wagoned me d2 and I was the one shouting from the rooftops to lynch lethal. voting me if you thought lethal was scum is indefensibly bad.

 

[Grammaton]

think we can benefit from a criteria/metric for how post game awards r given

like a point system

ex;

• for every correct town read you had and defended day 1, you get a point
• for every correct scum read you had and pursued day 1, you get 2 or 3 points

etc.. players with most points at end of game gain the awards.

kinda puts more work on the host tho but makes rewarding more consistent

This doesnt work in practice and creates incentives for bizarre play

Just needs hosts to get a grip

 

[Arne Slot]

Quite easily

I didn't make a single incorrect read this game

'Lmao'

er, magic was town and your basis for reading ekko town was that he wouldn't be scum with magic

 

[Magic]

Think we are being properly gaslit about how well cp played here

Spent half the game pushing junk, Haza, magic and Ekko

he had junk as town by n2. i legit just posed his list from n2. his tier 1 lynches were the remaining scum+ekko.

he also didnt really push me until he had results on me and he still seemed hesitant to actually trust those results based on what he was saying in his posts.

 

[Grammaton]

i was in fact town***

No, you were indy. I dont care how pro town you thought you were playing, your posts were well wide of the mark which is what got you in trouble

 

[Sky]

Maybe the idea of offering awards for individual brilliance in a team game is fundamentally flawed but hey what do I know

 

[Ratchet]

You're such a manbaby, I'm pretty sure I've given you awards prior and I have no actual hangups about it.

My god some of you act like such wet blankets. What gives you the impression I'm some spiteful malignant guy in over two years of playing with me here.

I was a fake claim so I stand with Craig.

 

[Arne Slot]

he had junk as town by n2. i legit just posed his list from n2. his tier 1 lynches were the remaining scum+ekko.

he also didnt really push me until he had results on me and he still seemed hesitant to actually trust those results based on what he was saying in his posts.

I had junk as town d2 shortly after she showed up and started posting, which is the whole reason I voted her in the first place. never scum read her.

 

[RDK]

HM and MVP are worth the same points now and we still doing this

 

[Ratchet]

Congratulations to @Ratchet

Nvm all is forgiven.

 

[Grammaton]

er, magic was town and your basis for reading ekko town was that he wouldn't be scum with magic

See above

I also read ekko consistently well, youll struggle to find a game where i get him wrong

 

[Grammaton]

Maybe the idea of offering awards for individual brilliance in a team game is fundamentally flawed but hey what do I know

Go back to your hole

 

[Ultra]

ya but crediting fuji with what other players did with the information is kinda silly.

i get how youre doing this awards with what x player did, the results, then how the results were handled but largely just disagree with that lol.

cp was precise based on the stuff i just showed in quotes. he was on hime and luka as early as day 2, lethal on day 1 and no one except fuji gets credit for the fuji shot.

I get your perspective. How I tend to award people is obviously going to be different from your preference since you play like a pussy differently

Not hard to imagine given my approach to the game how my evaluation favors early aggression. My evaluation is that the game was effectively over (or should have been, really) in large part thanks to the early flips and who feels most credibly responsible for them, reads and pushes past that point are granted a bit less credit since the house of cards has fallen over a bit

 

[Arne Slot]

Think we are being properly gaslit about how well cp played here

Spent half the game pushing junk, Haza, magic and Ekko

this is just wildly incorrect

 

[Magic]

No, you were indy. I dont care how pro town you thought you were playing, your posts were well wide of the mark which is what got you in trouble

this is far more true for ekko than myself, which i have literally shown quotes of.

i can bring up all relevant posts from my self about lethal and luka showing this isnt accurate too lol. my opening to the game was saying luka looked scummy for the manner in which he was posting.

then flower was killed and i directly said that can be tied to luka.

lethal i said the same thing you said, on day 1, about his responses being soft as shit and scummy. you even quoted that and said you initially read it wrong and thought i was calling him town.

i wanted to win with town prior to dying so there would be sk. if i actually wanted to cause disruption in the game to give a better set up for a sk win i would have done so much more aggressively.



i was off on cp and poyser, both of whom i eventually came around on, but i wasn't missing much on actual scum.

 

[Arne Slot]

See above

I also read ekko consistently well, youll struggle to find a game where i get him wrong

eh I think if ekko was pushing to lynch you for pushing a player you both supposedly scum read you might have saw things differently

 

[Magic]

Maybe the idea of offering awards for individual brilliance in a team game is fundamentally flawed but hey what do I know

tbf, saying you cant be assed and want the game to end so dont really care then voting due to that reason is also fundamentally flawed behaviour in a team game lol.

 

[Grammaton]

eh I think if ekko was pushing to lynch you for pushing a player you both supposedly scum read you might have saw things differently

He did early on

 

[Sparkles]

I literally read hime wrong and that’s it, very costly i know but hey