Kairi returning with the full pirate gear and gimmick is the right call, but WHY did you do it in a match that also featured Rhea Ripley? Inevitably Mami was always going to overshadow Kairi here, even if Kairi had beaten Zoey Stark to win the match.
Zoey's injury really didn't help as it forced them to pivot to Kairi eating the L to Rhea. Granted in the circumstances, it's the right call as Kairi (despite Rhea's best efforts here to make her look strong) doesn't have the hype to justify going over Rhea.
I'd say you should put Kairi in the Intercontinental Title Picture but obviously the Lyra vs Becky feud is still ongoing (nice to see Lyra get one of the biggest pops of the night by the way, this feud has done wonders for her) with Bayley set to get involved at some point.
We need to do something with Kairi to help her bounce back from this but I don't know what.