• We're looking for artists. Direct message Dr. Watson for more info!

Ranked One Piece Thriller Bark Mafia

cause i just read that and i dont understand the initial suspicion in the first place.

why would you even think as scum he would propose what he did/to what benefit to him does it have?
He worded his posts in a way that made it seem like he didnt know who town should be, why wouldnt I become suspicious of that? But after doing some thinking I chalked it up to him either being dumb town or at worst an indie who doesnt know towns flavor.

You dont understand the initial supcision because you dont have flavor knowledge, I do.
 
aurelian looks town to me so far. not a super strong town read, but stronger than the other weak ones for sure!

i think im coming around to gad as town after that multiquote that included great potato/the fuji commentary and then his response to flower about not having strong day 1 reads as he generally doesn't.

with that said, if you dont often have strong day 1 reads, why were you so sure on flower @Gadministraitor
 
no i understand it was relating to theme and since he knows the theme it should be a given, but it seems like it was a given to him and he was making the obvious clear while being ignorant of the fact it would be obvious to others.
 
with that said, if you dont often have strong day 1 reads, why were you so sure on flower @Gadministraitor
A combination of what people said about Melkor's games where he wouldn't just leave the mc of the town flavor out of the game and it being too fucking risky to cc someone who claimed said character. Unless Fuji and Flower are teamed up as scum, highly unlikely as their interactions were in the spotlight too much for me to think that, that makes no sense for flower to be scum. As close to town-lock as it gets for me.
 
no i understand it was relating to theme and since he knows the theme it should be a given, but it seems like it was a given to him and he was making the obvious clear while being ignorant of the fact it would be obvious to others.
Magic, Im way past this shit lmao. I dont really care about going through it again.
 
where is your ugency!

i didn't play for 24 hours and was just now catching up(although now i am fully caught up i think after 2 more pages).


Imma let magic cook but town reading Luka so easily after he was completely wrong on that slot last game was a choice
ya hardly sure on that, but it's the vibe.

also barely read last game until luka was dead(barely being like 100ish posts). i just thought ratchet and flower were scum and kept asking him to be voted so i just said he was town.
 
1. T-Pein™
2. Great Potato

3. Chairman Nibel
4. Gadministraitor
5. Flower
6. Polar Bear
7. Tempest
8. RDK
9. The Orca
10. Fujishiro
11. Aurelian

12. Luka
13. Grammaton
14. yohoho1996
15. HeWhoHasNoEqual
16. Rugrat
18. Hans Tweetenberg
19. Xadlin
20. Dr. Watson

nibel i kind of like too, but i dont really buy what he said about being tired of being indy and happy to be town again. the last few times he was town here he said he was sad he wasn't scum as that's what he really wants and he seems to be putting in a lot of effort right now(he also put in a lot of effort in that game he vigged me on day 1 before trailing off day 2 so it's hardly a slam dunk or the most scummy thing in the world but i dont really buy he would be happy to be town opposed to unhappy he's still not scum).

luka i vibed as town but idk how/why his scum reads on tpein/gram just disappeared after pairing them and look forward to hearing that interaction.

orca i dont think is overly sus thus far but he's also not agitated anyone yet and i think he's done that in every single one of his town games(whereas polar, as pointed out by fuji, hasn't). he seems very calm and straight forward. he does have cp as scum which i think cp has largely just ignored for whatever reason.

great potato/tweet might be generous town reads, but i haven't seen much scummy from them yet either and the case potato made looked like a town case.
 
vote The Orca

Ya ima go here.

Cp interaction stands out as it just looks weird overall and I don't get his conclusion on why Tempest is scum even with him saying he's popping in and out.
 
My point here was that I feel a bit happy to roll townie when you compare to indie. In WoW's game, I was the cult, and I didn't like that.