• We're looking for artists. Direct message Dr. Watson for more info!

Game Role Madness Supernatural Mafia

Reader mode
Sparkles said:
i feel like PQ's fake flailing is pretty incriminating especially considering how you mentioned last night he did that often as scum, being very indecisive, his indecisiveness feels very fake rn.
Click to expand...
I’ve never seen him as scum so Idk what you mean on that one.

I’ve seen him as town. As town I find he’s very worried about being wrong and second guessing everything.

Here he’s doing the opposite of second guessing and being all over the place as a means of brute forcing a worldview
 
Dr_Professor83 said:
“My role is insurance against vig”

“Why are you trusting the vig claim?”

“Scum have to have ninja or some way to deal with watcher”

“You must not have a way to deal with the watcher”
Click to expand...
stop trying to twist my words here. i believe the vig claim too i think so the point i was trying to make there is why do u think scum is so weak to be watcher-dodging when u also think town has 3 protectives, 2 invests, and a vig. it would be a weak scum v a strong town in this scenario. and if u think scum is throwing by deliberately watcher-dodging when u think they actually have stronger roles then idk what scum's goal here is cuz it loses every time.

like those bottom 2 are just me trying to consider what world we're in.

We either have a weak town and a weak mafia or a strong town and a strong mafia.

if we have a weak town then there's probably a liar among the protectives and the investigatives cuz there's no way mafia would be watcher dodging if they weren't weak.

if we have a strong town and a strong mafia team then u have to explain why watson is dead and why they faked being weak instead of just powering through whatever investigative/protective town has. cuz not killing towncore when towncore is pretty big is losing for mafia. Strong town also means it's less likely there's a liar among the protect/invest claims
 
Sparkles said:
who's the better yeet for gamestate Professor? Ali or PQ?

Which are you most sure on and why?
Click to expand...
I’m pretty sure of both, for me it’s PQ though. For one my role is involved so I’m most sure of my own cards and also he’s actively engaging me personally in a way I feel is bad faith.

But also, if PQ were to flip town I think it has a lot worse/more ramifications that need to immediately be known and we need to reset lol. (Bc in that world something is amiss between Dest/Reloaded)
 
Pqwerty said:
stop trying to twist my words here. i believe the vig claim too i think so the point i was trying to make there is why do u think scum is so weak to be watcher-dodging when u also think town has 3 protectives, 2 invests, and a vig. it would be a weak scum v a strong town in this scenario. and if u think scum is throwing by deliberately watcher-dodging when u think they actually have stronger roles then idk what scum's goal here is cuz it loses every time.

like those bottom 2 are just me trying to consider what world we're in.

We either have a weak town and a weak mafia or a strong town and a strong mafia.

if we have a weak town then there's probably a liar among the protectives and the investigatives cuz there's no way mafia would be watcher dodging if they weren't weak.

if we have a strong town and a strong mafia team then u have to explain why watson is dead and why they faked being weak instead of just powering through whatever investigative/protective town has. cuz not killing towncore when towncore is pretty big is losing for mafia. Strong town also means it's less likely there's a liar among the protect/invest claims
Click to expand...
But I keep telling you I don’t think scum are watcher dodging out of weakness. So your premise is immediately out. I think it was more likely out of strategy. I have no doubt scum is well equip to counter towns roles when they need to bc I make games with Fuji and know how he thinks.

Meanwhile you’re saying all of this while also arguing that scum not having a way to deal with any of this is why I’d avoid the cop lol.

You’re talking out of both sides
 
i mean theirs also the play today of trying to cause paranoia amongst the towncore which is exactly what you're doing atm PQ.

But i mean you/mafia probably didn't envision my cop claim hardlocking me in the way it did so mafia probably regret not killing me last night.

Vote PQ

I agree with the need to reassess if he flips town so this is probably the only move we can make for the hamestate today.
 
If you think scum should be strong enough that the Watson kill should be unexplainable from my PoV, then you need to also consider scum is strong enough that your arguments shouldn’t be relying on scum being weak lol
 
Like there's no way in my mind that Professor didn't catch on to me potentially being the cop and his lack of claiming before i did and me being alive reinforces the fact he's probably not scum.
 
Vote Count 1 Of Day 2
  • Index
    • 68747470733a2f2f73332e616d617a6f6e6177732e636f6d2f776174747061642d6d656469612d736572766963652f53746f7279496d6167652f5f4c642d6672726144714f6f76513d3d2d3934343830373632322e31363266623739323130353965393564313033363832393534392e676966


    Vote Count 1 Of Day 2

    Pqwerty: 4
    Ali: 3
    Sigis: 1
    Fuji: 1
    Prof: 1


    Alexis: Pqwerty > Ali > Pqwerty
    X: Pqwerty > Ali > Pqwerty
    Sparkles: Luka > Pqwerty > Ali > Pqwerty
    Fuji: Fujishiro
    Luka: Sigis > Ali
    Pot: Pqwerty
    Sigi: Pqwerty >Unvote
    Reloaded: Ali
    Pqwerty: Prof

    With 10 players it takes 6 votes for majority​
     
    Last edited:
  • Index
    • the professor seems smart enough to put 2 and 2 together there if he's scum, reinforced by the fact despite the tracker claim i still wanted him dead just not sure if i said as much before alexis claimed watcher.
     
    Sparkles said:
    whatever happens here i think if PQ flips town the vig needs to shoot out of ali/x/luka.

    if he's scum then leave x out of that shoot pool.
    Click to expand...
    If he’s town I think there’s for sure scum between Reloaded/Dest (but I don’t think that’s happening). (Claimed vig obv won’t shoot him self lol)

    If he’s scum then after Ali I’m personally not super sure how I order Pot/Luka/Sigi rn.

    Probably Sigi last in that PoE bc they were PQs main scum read yesterday and it carried into today.
     
    Dr_Professor83 said:
    But I keep telling you I don’t think scum are watcher dodging out of weakness. So your premise is immediately out. I think it was more likely out of strategy. I have no doubt scum is well equip to counter towns roles when they need to bc I make games with Fuji and know how he thinks.

    Meanwhile you’re saying all of this while also arguing that scum not having a way to deal with any of this is why I’d avoid the cop lol.

    You’re talking out of both sides
    Click to expand...
    bruh maybe im completely wrong abt u

    i'm horrible at this game so i wouldn't be surprised if i'm just tunneling a townie again for the millionth time
     
    Reader mode
    You must log in or register to reply here.
    Back
    Top