Game Official Ranked The Boys: Mafia - Game Thread (Day 6)

[Flower]

Oh yeah, speaking of the duel, I prefer we use it if we have a clear suspect. I‘m not a fan of it replacing the lynch. Ratchet exploited that as scum in Members and forced Hime and Sky into a Thunderdome that cost us two day phases. Else I think Hime just shouldn’t use at all.

 

[Flower]

Why are you calling him weak btw. You basically only get by off by sheer entitlement like a 500 pound welfare queen who's been skin glued to the couch. You're not even voting him you're just shitting in him for having the audacity to suspect you. Seriously annoying.

I‘ve done much more than that this game, but you do you.

 

[Sharter Holmes]

@Ultra the reason I’m tring you here that’s different from that game is because I’m ngl I thought high posting = town for you and thought you were incapable at playing as scum because your other mu games showed otherwise.

I’m tring you here because of your aggression that I recognize from the first game we played together especially in the early bits of phases like I said. Correct me if I’m wrong but I don’t remember that aggression to get what you want from the second game we played together.

And your thoughts on why some people mentioned he's being less aggressive this game? That factor into your reads?

 

[Sharter Holmes]

Yea I lied in that game because you were posting a lot so I just towned you and said fuck it mu meta is strong

Muh man, you're scum aren't you?

 

[Sharter Holmes]

holy shit i submitted my paper 30 seconds before midnight
that was way too close ;-;

Like a true student

 

[Sharter Holmes]

Wow who's treating who in bad faith now

How was that bad faith?

 

[Ratchet]

while Ratchet seems a bit more like he's trying to corner him

Why is this your takeaway? I feel like you have to be pretty uncharitable to me to come away with this impression, as opposed to it being what I say it is.

 

[Sharter Holmes]

hello again friends

Hellp CP

 

[Poyser]

I think you can also argue Sky "defending you" by questioning my read is more directed at me and how I got there than it is at positioning around you.

Like here I am a cis white male with a big juicy brain saying "hey let's lynch Poyser" with mostly loosely attached explanation and you think she's scummy for not being sold off the bat?

From your standpoint, I feel like it's interesting that you've so easily reconciled her skepticism on me pushing you if you think I'm chatting pure shit.

What are you on about man
Its not skepticism, she defended me. She asked you to provide an example of me acting the way you say and you said I was playing similarly to a scum game you hosted, rather than dig into that she instead was like no I want a town game where he acted the way you say you would which you didn't provide and she didn't ask further. She also defended me by saying I wouldn't act that way as town because I was better than that, and then accused you have having a straw-poy in your head.

Even if you want to say her defence of me could be genuine, if she thinks you are pushing some bullshit version of me, why would she not be suspicious of you lol?

 

[Flower]

What are you on about man
Its not skepticism, she defended me. She asked you to provide an example of me acting the way you say and you said I was playing similarly to a scum game you hosted, rather than dig into that she instead was like no I want a town game where he acted the way you say you would which you didn't provide and she didn't ask further. She also defended me by saying I wouldn't act that way as town because I was better than that, and then accused you have having a straw-poy in your head.

Even if you want to say her defence of me could be genuine, if she thinks you are pushing some bullshit version of me, why would she not be suspicious of you lol?

Frankly, after Sky accused Ultra and me being scum together in GTA after we argued for a whole day phase and flamed each other for multiple pages I don't think you should apply logic that much.

Just ask yourself what's her motivation to do any of this as scum.

 

[Ultra]

Why is this your takeaway? I feel like you have to be pretty uncharitable to me to come away with this impression, as opposed to it being what I say it is.

Not really. You dissolved his OMGUS defense with FACTS and LOGIC so cornering is a pretty good description regardless of what your respective alignments are

 

[Ratchet]

Not really. You dissolved his OMGUS defense with FACTS and LOGIC so cornering is a pretty good description regardless of what your respective alignments are

"Ratchet is trying to corner him" implies that my motivation is to make him look bad, not solve him. Which would only ever come from me as scum. As Town, I have an obligation to want to be right on his alignment.

 

[Flower]

"Ratchet is trying to corner him" implies that my motivation is to make him look bad, not solve him. Which would only ever come from me as scum. As Town, I have an obligation to want to be right on his alignment.

Eh, not really. You can also corner scum so they have no way out.

 

[Poyser]

Frankly, after Sky accused Ultra and me being scum together in GTA after we argued for a whole day phase and flamed each other for multiple pages I don't think you should apply logic that much.

Just ask yourself what's her motivation to do any of this as scum.

Im not really applying logic to her though? Im saying her defending me seems way out of what she does as town. Logically Id expect her to sus ultra after what she said but thats not why I find her sus, its the effort she put into defending me based on basically giving me the benefit of the doubt (IE I wasnt up someones ass because there hadn't been much of substance that had happened)

I think her motivation for defending me as scum would be pretty obvious lol

 

[Poyser]

Eh, not really. You can also corner scum so they have no way out.

its obvious what ultra was implying though

 

[Flower]

Im not really applying logic to her though? Im saying her defending me seems way out of what she does as town. Logically Id expect her to sus ultra after what she said but thats not why I find her sus, its the effort she put into defending me based on basically giving me the benefit of the doubt (IE I wasnt up someones ass because there hadn't been much of substance that had happened)

I think her motivation for defending me as scum would be pretty obvious lol

I don't think that's her scum MO though from what I remember. She tries shading people and tying them together. Her interaction with Ultra didn't really contain shade though.

Her scum motivation would probably be to tie you to her if she's scum, but that's hard to see.

 

[Lethal]

Seems very tense atm in here. leaves to continue reading

 

[Lethal]

Nobody wants to stop arguing to say hi. Insult received.

 

[Poyser]

I don't think that's her scum MO though from what I remember. She tries shading people and tying them together. Her interaction with Ultra didn't really contain shade though.

Her scum motivation would probably be to tie you to her if she's scum, but that's hard to see.

No, it would be to get on my good side more than likely. Tying us together would be a bonus too though of course. Not sure why you're saying it's hard to see though?

Also what game are you basing her scum MO on lol?

 

[Ultra]

What are you on about man
Its not skepticism, she defended me. She asked you to provide an example of me acting the way you say and you said I was playing similarly to a scum game you hosted, rather than dig into that she instead was like no I want a town game where he acted the way you say you would which you didn't provide and she didn't ask further. She also defended me by saying I wouldn't act that way as town because I was better than that, and then accused you have having a straw-poy in your head.

Even if you want to say her defence of me could be genuine, if she thinks you are pushing some bullshit version of me, why would she not be suspicious of you lol?

She thinks I'm an overconfident blowhard though. Do you remember when she was caught talking trash about THOSE PEOPLE (obviously being me and Ratchet) off-site?

I'm also curious why you've overstepped the part where, if you're town, her questioning should have some validity. Undue defense maybe, but why aren't you asking these questions?

Like what's your reaction here to me saying any of this about you and your meta? All fine and dandy?