• We're looking for artists. Direct message Dr. Watson for more info!

VS Battle The Tarnished (Elden Ring) in God of War-verse

Papa Nier

Papa Nier

Papa Wolf
V.I.P. Member
Shut up and take my money!
Strongest Swordsman in the World
To celebrate being GOTY at the game awards, the Tarnished takes on everyone in God of War, even the ones who have died. Kratos also has every single piece of equipment from all the games including the Power of Hope. Who wins?

Scenario 1) Early game Tarnished fights from weakest to strongest one by one.

Scenario 2) Early game Tarnished fights them all at once.

Scenario 3) Mid-game Tarnished fights from weakest to strongest one by one.

Scenario 4) Mid-game Tarnished fights them all at once.

Scenario 5) End game Tarnished fights from weakest to strongest one by one.

Scenario 6) End game Tarnished fights them all at once.

 
anything past mid-game/Radahn fight should clear given the realms are apparently only continent or earth sized and the tarnished can survive and react to Collapsing Stars by that point


not really sure what earlier versions scale to given feats for guys like Godrick and Rykard and kind of unclear, could scale them to the Fallingstar Beasts surviving reentry I guess? @Atem might have a better idea
 
Rot Goddess Malenia>>>>>>>Radahn=base Malenia

though Morgott did beat Radahn once it didn't do permanent damage to him like Malenia's Rot did and Radahn did continue to be known as the strongest in spite of that, so they're probably just in a similar ballpark.
 
Darth Nihilus said:
Radahn still holding those stars in place while rotting away is fucking impressive
Click to expand...
he's the MVP of the game, everyone just loves him and says he's a great guy :wow

also goes out of his way to protect his horse in the fight, even while senile
 
OtherGalaxy said:
Rot Goddess Malenia>>>>>>>Radahn=base Malenia

though Morgott did beat Radahn once it didn't do permanent damage to him like Malenia's Rot did and Radahn did continue to be known as the strongest in spite of that, so they're probably just in a similar ballpark.
Click to expand...
Who says he is strongest exactly? and if so would Morgott beating him mean the title refers more to physical strength but does not correlate to overall power or skill in combat?
 
NostalgiaFan said:
Who says he is strongest exactly? and if so would Morgott beating him mean the title refers more to physical strength but does not correlate to overall power or skill in combat?
Click to expand...
various sources call him that i know Jerren is one of them, you could argue he’s biased but the guy should be aware of Malenia’s strength too since he’s a part of Radahn’s army.


The starscourge heirloom also calls him the mightiest hero of the demigods.

Also it’s speculated that due to Radahn’s significantly smaller size during his Morgott L he may have just gotten stronger later on. There’s not a ton to go off fir it. Morgott would still be star level though because Radahn conquered the stars “in his youth”
 
Depends on which interpretation you go with regarding the lore for GOW. Muspelheim for example is supposed to be the source of all stars, and the realms were crafted out of Ymir's body. Ymir who was killed and defeated by Odin. Which directly scales to him as a result.

Then there's Thor hitting the World Serpent so hard he fractured the World Tree as a side-effect, and sent him into the past. Which actually happens in Ragnarok.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top