• We're looking for artists. Direct message Dr. Watson for more info!

Game Warcraft 3: The Full Story

Reader mode
Dr_Professor83 said:
I have been a little paranoid of you but I think PQ looks a lot worse and you won’t be aligned lol.

I’d actually really love a PQ scum flip so that you become extremely sheepable lol
Click to expand...
I don't love this when I don't even strongly scum read Pqwerty. His position I can actually understand even though I think it's pretty bad, the main problem I have is that he's not willing to claim anything but was fine volunteering info, and I get the sense that the scum read is somewhat in retrospect of me asking him to claim, which could indicate that his position isn't genuine. But, I certainly resent the notion that we're already I'm a dichotomy with each other, I'm not that convinced on that at all.
 
Ratchet said:
I don't love this when I don't even strongly scum read Pqwerty. His position I can actually understand even though I think it's pretty bad, the main problem I have is that he's not willing to claim anything but was fine volunteering info, and I get the sense that the scum read is somewhat in retrospect of me asking him to claim, which could indicate that his position isn't genuine. But, I certainly resent the notion that we're already I'm a dichotomy with each other, I'm not that convinced on that at all.
Click to expand...
It’s not about you scum reading him lol. If he’s scum you two obviously won’t be aligned with the neighbor claim and how you’ve played around him lol

Him being town doesn’t make you scum but him being scum makes you very likely town
 
Poyser said:
Why would they give a fake cult immune claim if they’re not cult immune :pogba makes no sense
Click to expand...
... Yeah? It's - a fake claim, and especially a cult immune fake claim being largely unconfirmable by the town except exempting wolves from finding them. That aside, I'm dropping this since I don't think Sparkles is a wolf atm - just confused by your logic.
 
Dr_Professor83 said:
It’s not about you scum reading him lol. If he’s scum you two obviously won’t be aligned with the neighbor claim and how you’ve played around him lol

Him being town doesn’t make you scum but him being scum makes you very likely town
Click to expand...
You think you should be an easy read for me this game Prof?
 
Ultra said:
I was actually asking where your vote on me is. You're implying I'm scum and acting like it's self evident I should be.
Click to expand...
I never said it was a slam dunk case, I said it was shit. I'm waiting to see what else you bring to the table or even what you're going to do with regards to me because it doesn't really seem like you believe any of it so far
 
Ratchet said:
I don't feel obligation, no. I give him points for it because I can reconcile him starting slowly, I haven't told him what notes he needs to hit here before he's done so, so it coming later is largely immaterial. I can't answer why you think I have an obligation because I have no idea where that position even comes from.
Click to expand...
It comes from thinking you seem to have talked about him a lot without ever really forming a solid conclusion, going back and forth, hedging etc. You seem to be fairly intimately familiar with him, so part of me thinks you feel like you have to talk about him as you'd be expected to because otherwise I don't really see the point of it
 
Dr_Professor83 said:
I’m not giving you shit for not voting me. But you’ve not tried to explore any of my thoughts outside of yourself specifically

Which I’d think would be a good way to explore me if you wanted to get a better read of me
Click to expand...
I dont even care about your read of me, just your conviction or in this case, complete lack thereof
 
Poyser said:
Btw I think X is probably town thinking about it. He was a bit of a pussy cat in Xmas from what I remember and he’s started pretty hard here
Click to expand...

Poyser only brought this up after he got some negative reception to his read just fyi

Think he tried testing the waters to see if he could get something going on X and then "remembered" that his behavior is in town range. Poyser's model of X's town play is that he aggressively and badly tunnels people, so I don't buy that he didn't consider this when he pitched the idea he was scum for suspecting Flower.

Not a fan of his angle on Prof either but dunno how familiar Poyser is with his play
 
Vote Count 2 Of Day 1
  • Index
    • astri-lohne-illidan-tyrande-final-final-smaller.jpg


    Day 1, VC2

    Hammer at 13.

    Poyser - 5
    Pqwerty - 3
    Gad - 2
    Goddessblade - 1
    Ratchet - 1
    X - 1
    Mango - 1
    Professor - 1

    Ichigo: Flower > unvote > Poyser
    Flower: Poyser > unvote > Gad > X > Gad > Pqwerty > Pot > Pqwerty
    Mango: Magic > Ichigo > unvote > Sparkles > unvote
    Poyser: Ichigo > unvote > Gad > Professor > Unvote > Pqwerty
    Lord Melkor: Mango > Gad
    X: Flower > Poyser
    Sparkles: Mango > unvote > Ratchet > unvote > Professor
    Gad: Ratchet
    Luka: Poyser
    Gulio: Poyser
    Alexis: X
    Ratchet: Professor > unvote > Gad
    Ekko: Gulio
    Yoho: Professor > Unvote
    Magic: Mango
    Ultra: Poyser
    Goddessblade: Ekko
    RDK: Goddessblade
    Prof: Pqwerty​
     
    Last edited:
  • Index
    • Poyser said:
    It comes from thinking you seem to have talked about him a lot without ever really forming a solid conclusion, going back and forth, hedging etc. You seem to be fairly intimately familiar with him, so part of me thinks you feel like you have to talk about him as you'd be expected to because otherwise I don't really see the point of it
    Click to expand...
    Why do I need to have formed a solid conclusion less than a third of the way through Day 1? Is this a real thought? You don't see why I would want to engage with him from different angles to develop a read?
     
    Reader mode
    You must log in or register to reply here.
    Back
    Top