• We're looking for artists. Direct message Dr. Watson for more info!

Game Ranked Wildlife Mafia

Reader mode
Poyser said:
if its due to her claim, then i dont get it
if its due to her play, then why not just explain it?
Click to expand...

Its both but the claim solidifies it

If shes scum then shes the rolecop adjacent - wouldnt be able to use her role in any kind of functional way now that shes claimed it for no reason. Hows she gonna justify tracking (copping) anyone town read?

If you wanna argue she wouldnt be aware of that, go nuts but that then opens up questions of team composition
 
Grammaton said:
Its both but the claim solidifies it

If shes scum then shes the rolecop adjacent - wouldnt be able to use her role in any kind of functional way now that shes claimed it for no reason. Hows she gonna justify tracking (copping) anyone town read?

If you wanna argue she wouldnt be aware of that, go nuts but that then opens up questions of team composition
Click to expand...
i find points like this kinda fall down when faced with the question of what else she would claim lol
the counter could be that well they wouldnt tell her to claim so early, which is fair but also could just as easily be something she decided to do herself
 
Aurelian said:
I'm not really sure what to make of her posts tbdean, she comes off a bit self-defeated and frantically posting all over in her typical town-meta.

You and Craig are both town off vibes.
Click to expand...
you havent done ur town tell yet and this time i wont be soft on u
 
Tempest said:
1. Emil
2. Gad
3. Dr. Watson
4. Poyser
5. Aurelian
6. Grammaton
7. Tweet
9. Nibel
10. Ratchet
11. Lethal
12. Ral
13. Sky

in case anyone is wondering where I'm at rn :) d1 reads aren't set in stone etc
Click to expand...
What puts me on the same level as someone who literally hasn't posted
 
Poyser said:
i find points like this kinda fall down when faced with the question of what else she would claim lol
the counter could be that well they wouldnt tell her to claim so early, which is fair but also could just as easily be something she decided to do herself
Click to expand...
hard sell for me tbdean
 
Poyser said:
i find points like this kinda fall down when faced with the question of what else she would claim lol
the counter could be that well they wouldnt tell her to claim so early, which is fair but also could just as easily be something she decided to do herself
Click to expand...

Its not a question of what else she can claim, its when she claims. You never ever want to reveal those roles as scum because youre now totally gimped- if you're saving yourself sure, but that wasnt the siruation
 
I was gonna say she's probably not scum with Poyser since it appeared to be him saying he wouldn't mind a claim which made her claim

But then if we're already assuming schemes abound then this chain of events would likely be part of that
 
Tbf I’ll probably just take the L for now on Watson here. Feel like at least one of the strong players would be agreeing with me if I had something lol
 
Grammaton said:
Few reasons but i mostly follow your reads AND i think youd be too heavily boxed in to be scum

Undecided as it stands, aurelian possibly? Think theres an argument to be made that hes trying to bootleg the previous game
Click to expand...
I'd be interested in that argument

thoughts on poyser?
 
Reader mode
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top