• We're looking for artists. Direct message Dr. Watson for more info!

Game Official Ranked Xmas Mafia 2024 - Where Worlds Collide

1. I think in a world where Ekko is scum here (which I still think is possible), he'd probably go after Poyser over Craig; way too easy to misframe Craig being killed on Ekko
2. Poyser being killed kind of sucks because he's able to generate a good sense of unity among town and not as uh polarizing as say Ultra or Ekko in comparison
3. Still don't know why the fuck RDK fake claimed indie/survivor if he was town but that's Haza for you

3 kills

1 vig shot?
1 mafia with 2 kills?
2 mafia doing faction kills?
1 mafia and SK on the loose?

Don't know but feels like this isn't a traditional set up


Would be funny if @Alexis2282AE was the hostile indie though, right @Dr_Professor83
 
why cant they both be mafia?

I just explained, it doesn't make much sense for Melkor to show notable hesitation or strong preference if both are busses

Plus I think Ekko's got a bit more going for him, specifically the fact that he entered the game voting Melkor and the fact that he had gotten a bit of traction yesterday, so it's more buyable Melkor would try and swing there
 

Blud what are you on about
 
Would be funny if @Alexis2282AE was the hostile indie though, right @Dr_Professor83
It would be pretty cool.

Also how have you read enough of my posts to know of my Alexis obsession sus

(Also why mention him as hostile indie specifically at all as opposed to just mafia?)
 
I disagree on the notion that fmpov Ekko tried to early sell Watson as lynch in thread. Shortly before me and Arne pushed him. Voting Melkor early does not matter then, if you try to get Watson over instead
 
Who would you consider here?

To be honest, probably Flower. As stated, using a 3-shot PR on n1 and not knowing it's full use before then is either bad townie or a an articulate scum tactic.


If you think I'll be getting points for calling out your list then you are mistaken. I didn't see RDK's claim to be fair, so yeah it's awful in hindsight. If Ekko turns out to be scum, then I'll look back on this more favorably. You should apologize btw, I am town so throwing me as PoE is not cash money.
 
I disagree on the notion that fmpov Ekko tried to early sell Watson as lynch in thread. Shortly before me and Arne pushed him. Voting Melkor early does not matter then, if you try to get Watson over instead

So what Watson was scummy and she's probably a filthy disgusting rotten indi

She has a fake claim my nigga
 
Blud what are you on about
Shut up and go to sleep
It would be pretty cool.

Also how have you read enough of my posts to know of my Alexis obsession sus

(Also why mention him as hostile indie specifically at all as opposed to just mafia?)
I mean you mention him at least or twice in most of your posts, so it kind of stands out since the game started. Also even if there is only 1 mafia, doesn't exclude hostile indies in the game.

Though I'm more interested in knowing why you think if X is scum, that automatically makes Ekko town, or vice-versa.
 
Automatically no, but more likely yes. I don’t really see Melkor & Dest both bussing Ekko together there. Just don’t think that’s the play coming in having a big group bus triangle session
 
I'm not apologizing for anything.

And obviously I'm not going to take your word at face-value that your town because you insist you are just like that. Paranoia is the name of the game here. And I'm less certain Ekko is going to flip scum since he got hit by that PR from Flower, but I'm still not adverse to seeing him flipped either way because the chance and way he plays can often be as much a nuisance to town.
 
I stopped caring about that ngl

Besides the point, Melkor was Ekko's first vote and it sounded plausibly decisive. I don't think it's impossible they bussed each other but I think it's way more likely he's aligned with the person he played lip service to scum reading but opted to neglect when the chips were on the table. Make sense?
 
I'll be here when the game ends waiting for it :rippedcal