• We're looking for artists. Direct message Dr. Watson for more info!

Game Official Ranked Xmas Mafia 2024 - Where Worlds Collide

Reader mode
2448.jpg
 
Ultra said:
That's not the point

The point is why are you "fine" with voting when you didn't read anything
Click to expand...
I haven't moved my vote off of her since I placed it. Does that not indicate anything to you?

Pqwerty said:
...why are u voting sparkles if u didnt know they were outted by a track??
Click to expand...
Because I scum read her? And Melkor's refusal to swing or sway his vote at her really doesn't help much either.
Ratchet said:
What am I lying about? I haven't said anything about the Sparkles angle. This is a complete non-secuiter.

By his own admission, he was voting on Melkor, and is voting on Sparkles. In fact he seems certain she's scum, despite allegedly not being aware of the mech on her.
Click to expand...
Yes I am not aware of mech on her when I voted her, red-handed catching her visiting two players. I am not disputing that at all.
Ratchet said:
What non-trust is he defending there?
Click to expand...
That was to and about you.
Pqwerty said:
can u explain your sr on sparkles in more depth pls? wanna make sure u aren't cheating and have tmi
Click to expand...
Cheating?
Ratchet said:
Well you can do that, but my evidence for that is below:
That is you, saying that you're not sure about Sparkles. You say you're trying to follow Poyser's legacy, but her name was the only one in those three that you listed that actually appeared in his scum reads, and it's the only one you express uncertainty about too. Mind explaining that? If you were following his legacy, you would be listing the rest of his scum reads here - not Jigsaw and Brutus. You're going to have to explain why you're not listing X, Flower etc instead.
Click to expand...
I didn't' express any real "uncertainty" about voting or being against lynching Sparkles. Don't dissemble with sophistry here, I voted her, am still currently voting her, and am fine with lynching her. I'd be more guilty of expressing doubt about X because I was genuinely unaware of why he was getting piled on so much/

Jigsaw was not town read: good enough for me to have him in my scum reads.
And I've not seen anything that makes Brutus stand out as town.
Pqwerty said:
why is she suspicious, seymour?
Click to expand...
I already explained this:

  • every game I've played with her when she was town she'd fight tooth and nail to stop her lynch until she was hammered
  • here she has expressively given up completely and ghosted from the game; all tell-tale signs of a mafia player giving up
  • if she was town she'd be fighting for her life
  • in addition the entire equity she has with Melkor and his spewing doesn't help her either

Dr_Professor83 said:
You vote her and make sure to drop some convenient off ramp suggestions. Then when you list her elsewhere you drop the “but idk” hedge.

It’s always a “but”
Click to expand...
There is no but or hedging here. You can be obstinate and an ass about this but I've said and still am fine with lynching Watson, Sparkles, Ratchet, etc...The order doesn't make a difference to me.
 
Aurelian said:
As of now this is where I'm at

Town leaning
Poyser
Chuck
Tweet
Magic
Fujishiro
Dr.Prof
Alco
Sparkles
Jigsaw
Lethal

Null:
Craig/Tempest (feels he's more likely town tho)
X
Seraphoenix
Kiku aka GoddessBlade
Lappland
Ratchet
Ultra
Evans
T-Pein
Watson
Rugrat
Pqwerty (no idea with this guy)
Melkor (its Melkor)

Scummy:
Guillo (refusing to elaborate on his reads when questioned)
Brutus (hasn't even posted I think)
RDK (claims indie which means not town pretty clearly cut)
Alexis (has really just fluff posted and voted, nothing to do with actual solving)
Ekko (hasn't done anything townie imo, he's been baiting around a bit and engagement with Magic & the others seems performative to me)
Click to expand...
have your reads changed much since ekko and RDK (your top srs) flipped green and that Sparkles is potentially outted scum?
 
Lets get over this

Alexis is bodyguard, best value he has rn is to bodyguard a person and die for them

if he doesnt bodyguard a person and claims to target his scumread again then what
 
Aurelian said:
I haven't moved my vote off of her since I placed it. Does that not indicate anything to you?


Because I scum read her? And Melkor's refusal to swing or sway his vote at her really doesn't help much either.

Yes I am not aware of mech on her when I voted her, red-handed catching her visiting two players. I am not disputing that at all.

That was to and about you.

Cheating?

I didn't' express any real "uncertainty" about voting or being against lynching Sparkles. Don't dissemble with sophistry here, I voted her, am still currently voting her, and am fine with lynching her. I'd be more guilty of expressing doubt about X because I was genuinely unaware of why he was getting piled on so much/

Jigsaw was not town read: good enough for me to have him in my scum reads.
And I've not seen anything that makes Brutus stand out as town.

I already explained this:

  • every game I've played with her when she was town she'd fight tooth and nail to stop her lynch until she was hammered
  • here she has expressively given up completely and ghosted from the game; all tell-tale signs of a mafia player giving up
  • if she was town she'd be fighting for her life
  • in addition the entire equity she has with Melkor and his spewing doesn't help her either


There is no but or hedging here. You can be obstinate and an ass about this but I've said and still am fine with lynching Watson, Sparkles, Ratchet, etc...The order doesn't make a difference to me.
Click to expand...
That Ratchet typo was supposed to be Rugrat
 
.guillo said:
Im not, im just 17 pages behind.

I think on top of giving us more time to play due to holidays, our posts should had have a max cap. Cause those like me who are actually prioritizing holidays over the game fall behind big time.
Click to expand...
POST CAPS SUCK
 
Reader mode
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top