• We're looking for artists. Direct message Dr. Watson for more info!

Game Official Ranked Xmas Mafia 2024 - Where Worlds Collide

Reader mode
Lappland said:
Which all in all seems really contrived and like a massive misplay for NA's. But that's the reality you try to sell as far as I read out of your posts here now
Click to expand...
wanna give thoughts on
my current reads, am still in
middle of day one
 
In fact a simple Occams razor suggests


Any team that kills Arne would most likely not target you the next dayphase. You do not seem like a strong enough player to withstand such pressure from what I gathered, so there is no reason to strongarm a kill in such fashion.
In fact you do not understand the basics of defending yourself at all, you just seemed like you felt caught yesterday
 
the sparkle town read seems bad


I think the magic townread is spicier here in particular, not sure why your Ratchet read is weaker in particular. pretty sure he helped start the melkor wagon yesterday? Kind of a weird situation to have that one as weaker in particular.

Sparkles as townread is bold. My guess for why you are pushing fleur? It's because she targetted you. There is nothing beyond that imo. You don't listen reason for why she's scum, you are listing reasons to OMGUS her here imo. As I noted the NA's you suggest to have happened require too much illogical actions that I think in a vacuum any semi competent wolf team wouldn't engage in.
 
Lappland said:
In fact a simple Occams razor suggests


Any team that kills Arne would most likely not target you the next dayphase. You do not seem like a strong enough player to withstand such pressure from what I gathered, so there is no reason to strongarm a kill in such fashion.
In fact you do not understand the basics of defending yourself at all, you just seemed like you felt caught yesterday
Click to expand...
top ten contender
of posts purely made out of
someone's ass. wanna

go ahead and like
elaborate on every
thing you just said mate

where are you getting
all this from. it certainly
can't be from this thread
 
The sparkles townread stood out to me such that I thought about it twice. How did you arrive there? Sparkles day 1 was uninspiring as I said, there was nothing there that felt like it stood out to me as particulary villagery. In fact at points Sparkles felt like a utr wolf.
 
EkkoLoJinx said:
top ten contender
of posts purely made out of
someone's ass. wanna

go ahead and like
elaborate on every
thing you just said mate

where are you getting
all this from. it certainly
can't be from this thread
Click to expand...
It's pretty simple, your post suggested mafia killed Arne and janitored them for reading them PR. Then said team also targetted you despite you already being under hot water, if Arne dies, who scumread you yesterday. It is contrived
 
EkkoLoJinx said:
do we even know
if cp was town or not
poyser seem more like

a mafia kill
than C P does, it is weird
if serial kills

poyser, while scum kills
C P. it could be flower
who deduced that craig

is a P R so
killed him to janitor it
otherwise weird kill

i am still reading
will provide reads before i
crash to bed later
Click to expand...
 
You said I should fight you, but the difference between us is like a hydrogen bomb and a coughing baby. You are a small fish in a small pond
 
Next time don't make up messed up scenarios and then suggest I made them up instead of you. It's pretty simple to wolf, if you wanna learn the basics of mafia, I can teach you them for a coaching fee
 
Lappland said:
the sparkle town read seems bad


I think the magic townread is spicier here in particular, not sure why your Ratchet read is weaker in particular. pretty sure he helped start the melkor wagon yesterday? Kind of a weird situation to have that one as weaker in particular.

Sparkles as townread is bold. My guess for why you are pushing fleur? It's because she targetted you. There is nothing beyond that imo. You don't listen reason for why she's scum, you are listing reasons to OMGUS her here imo. As I noted the NA's you suggest to have happened require too much illogical actions that I think in a vacuum any semi competent wolf team wouldn't engage in.
Click to expand...
why is the sparkle
read bad? her interactions
with melkor comes off

townie to me, in
addition to her own non
chalant behavior

i don't think magic
comes off aligned with who i
have as sus in this

worldview so i am
reading him more townie while
ratchet is also

townie but up to
where i read, there were early
interactions with

flower that came off
like distancing so i have
some reservations.

if we take this one
scenario where i am
sus of flower, then

my N K A is
is very level one and
not complex logic

that is, flower just
killed C P and P R me
who both suspected

her toward the end
of last day. please explain where
complex logic is
 
EkkoLoJinx said:
vote melkor with us pls. ur annoyance seem a bit misplaced for the strength of "mafia" read on watson. most ppl think shes indie.

all of this applies if u think watson is mafia and melkor is town which i dont think u do. gonna call it a direct defense for melkor, a punishable offense if he turns out mafia and watson indie!

if both watson and melkor r mafia then ur approach is a non enthusiastic damage control
Click to expand...
Where does the melkor scumread come from so late? I call this an opportunsitic bus on a team mate you can't salvage
 
EkkoLoJinx said:
why is the sparkle
read bad? her interactions
with melkor comes off

townie to me, in
addition to her own non
chalant behavior

i don't think magic
comes off aligned with who i
have as sus in this

worldview so i am
reading him more townie while
ratchet is also

townie but up to
where i read, there were early
interactions with

flower that came off
like distancing so i have
some reservations.

if we take this one
scenario where i am
sus of flower, then

my N K A is
is very level one and
not complex logic

that is, flower just
killed C P and P R me
who both suspected

her toward the end
of last day. please explain where
complex logic is
Click to expand...
Alright Arne suspects you

In a pure value evaluation of NA's. Arne dying makes you more suspicious because of that, you have a reason to kill him as mafia. Naturally that leads to you getting pushed. You got an action on you that can potentially kill you though.

That means the value's of the NA's dimnish, they could have been used on another slot to kill them instead. You would already rank down in ranking naturally in any situation Arne dies and is villager.

these NA's leave value on the table. Your read also hinges on Arne being a PR? How do you know that?
 
Lappland said:
i wonder
Click to expand...
yeah he was not in
doing anti spewing mode
which is why we will

solve the game from his
posts after his flip. this was
not a good play by

him. i thought this play
could be townie because it
is detrimental

to mafia, in
that we get a lot of stuff
to solve from melkor's

posts. i thought if he
had teammates that cared about
future positions

they will tell melkor
to probably shut up since
it is bad for them.

And since he did not
shut up, and C P was k
with yeeting melkor

and i suspected
C P a bit toward end
of day, it made the

melkor wagon seem
meh for a little bit but
his cooking was so

bad that i couldn't
not just lynch him for it, even
over watson who

was basically
outed to have a fake claim
and likely not town
 
You say likely not town, but when questioned earlier day 1 you said Watson was mafia by play regardless of any fakeclaim from your pov.
 
Reader mode
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top