• We're looking for artists. Direct message Dr. Watson for more info!

Game Official Ranked Xmas Mafia 2024 - Where Worlds Collide

Reader mode
@Aurelian I spared your life last night btw, your interaction with Ratchet was quite positive and he had you as 4th on his PoE so I don't see why you would kill him when people are scum reading you
 
Magic said:
Should just mass claim then.

I'm The Ghost of Christmas Present,
Odd-night Vanilla Cop.

N1 Alexis
N3 ratchet

N3 usage is bad but I got a feeling ratchet could be scum with flower and coaching her. Then realized he probably wouldn't claim vt as scum anyway and was going to switch to an inactive but didn't get back online in time to do that(thought we had 24 hours but we only had 18).

N1 usage is why I asked Alexis to just claim on day 2. Didn't really expect him to be so forthcoming with it but ya.

Also why I trusted our initial vt claims. Outside of poyser no one else had claimed vt and since my role is a role I figured there's going to be more than 1 vt in town as that makes basic sense.
Click to expand...
Okay since you claimed here is my claim that I hinted at since Melkor claimed and the reason why I was a bit wishy washy around Alexis.

Ghost of Christmas Future
Secrets/X1 Voyeur/X1 Follower.

Night 1 Voyeur Poyser and he was targetted by a kill.
Night 2 Follow Alexis and he bodyguarded someone.

Im not a fan of the voyeur role tbh its kinda useless imo.

So Alexis is indeed who he says he is.
 
Ratchet said:
I need to think on this. Did you really think I would be scum with Flower? I argued with her every single day, and was more reluctant than most to let her slide through the game even when people were telling me she had too many posts to be scum.

I will say that I think your points on her were good, I do have some reservations about the activity one as I think that's a bit flippant, but there wasn't really much call to bus her there either I don't think. So I can work with you here, am disappointed in your night 3 action though if genuine.
Click to expand...
I mean 1) lack of being caught up meant I was thinking of the hip and I felt like your back and forth was to draw activity out of her that she otherwise struggles with 2) again i didn't really like the approach 3) it was a bad gut read

I think the activity thing stands and for reason I gave. Her activity is well short of her town activity.
 
Chuck said:
i mean, x was scum, watson's shot altho bad made sense at the time and sera was basically vt in poe, i'd say choices were good, especially with low activity
Click to expand...

My reasoning for the Sera kill was I'd rather waste my shot than a day lynching PoE, he was not gonna contribute much I figured anyways. Watson shot was bad yeah but she also was really bad d1.

Sorry @RDK
 
Fujishiro said:
Okay since you claimed here is my claim that I hinted at since Melkor claimed and the reason why I was a bit wishy washy around Alexis.

Ghost of Christmas Future
Secrets/X1 Voyeur/X1 Follower.

Night 1 Voyeur Poyser and he was targetted by a kill.
Night 2 Follow Alexis and he bodyguarded someone.

Im not a fan of the voyeur role tbh its kinda useless imo.

So Alexis is indeed who he says he is.
Click to expand...
Oh ya, melkor claim is why I was thinking he could be town because thematically it matched well with mine
 
Ratchet said:
Would depend, I've seen Gram give fake roles before.
Click to expand...
welp, flower basically claimed part of her real role

melkor claimed sth so niche that he would be sure noone else have it

wouldn't be surprised if they had to improvise, also there's janitor
 
Ratchet said:
Scum will have fake claims. I don't think as scum he would need 20 minutes to claim. He would just claim.
Click to expand...
This argument is weak because maybe his claim was something he felt he couldnt really claim and so settled for vanilla.
Ratchet said:
If you have info on him then you're better off just claiming it, otherwise if you want my take, I think he's fine. He as scum is good enough to know whether he should claim Vanilla or not, and of he were being asked to claim he would just do it.
Click to expand...
Cool I guess youre ignoring my reads too then, very nice. Youre never wrong about yours right.
 
Grammaton said:
Rugrat
Click to expand...
Grammaton said:
Ultra
Click to expand...
Grammaton said:
Tweet
Click to expand...
Grammaton said:
Lappland
Click to expand...
Grammaton said:
Aurelian
Click to expand...

Magic - how confident are you in Rugrat bei g town?

I could see Tweet being scum. Craig being Indie that later becomes town might explain why he was a bit more half-assed than usual, and I think if he were another role then Flower could have claimed that one.

I don't think Ultra woukd be scun with Tweet. It does bother me though than on two other nights barely anyone else targeted him. We can mass claim today.

Lappland and Tweet can be scum together. Then it would be one of Rugrat and Aurelian.
 
Fujishiro said:
This argument is weak because maybe his claim was something he felt he couldnt really claim and so settled for vanilla.
Click to expand...
It's not - he is a straight shooter. If his role is not something he can claim straight up he would just claim Vanilla, and he would have thought about what to claim too. I'm not saying he has to be town by the way. But that your argument about him stalling is not good.
Fujishiro said:
Cool I guess youre ignoring my reads too then, very nice. Youre never wrong about yours right.
Click to expand...
What the fuck?
 
Reader mode
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top