Game Official Ranked Xmas Mafia 2024 - Where Worlds Collide

[Magic]

From past experience playing with her, when she rolls anything that isn't town or indie, she will complain and get even more emotionally upset/into histronics. So I wouldn't agree with this.

Yea but she never sacrifices herself or quits

 

[Fujishiro]

Atleast the past year or two she told me she hates it.

 

[Dr. Watson]

I don’t see scum Fang going 0 for 5 with scum reads so you’d be inclined to link Flower.

Also is there any reason Guillo has to be town? Odo hates cops and no reason it couldn’t fit on a scum alignment

i have a hard envisioning why guillo as scum would play like this. there's no benefit here imo

 

[Hans Tweetenberg]

You are inheriting your best pal Jeff's qualities. I'm sorry to hear.

I met a very rude German couple weeks ago... you in New Zealand right now?

Jeff and I aren't pals

Also I don't travel

 

[Ratchet]

According to your logic I can only be town based off the fact I suck at hunting for scum, right?

Nope, that's not my logic. I think you can be scum. What do you have to say for your defence?

 

[Magic]

Flower doesnt like being scum.

Yes but she likes playing the game of mafia. You could tell she was mad while getting lynched. It wasn't a ploy.

 

[Rugrat]

i have a hard envisioning why guillo as scum would play like this. there's no benefit here imo

You have a hard time believing that he’d bus Flower after Flower asked to be bussed in a hysterical rage at the game?

 

[Hans Tweetenberg]

Do you people read my posts or just skim through them.

Idk, are you reading my posts? There are a lot less of them than vice versa. I'm pretty open about the fact that I'm reading almost nothing.

 

[Magic]

@Rugrat claim

 

[Rugrat]

Yes but she likes playing the game of mafia. You could tell she was mad while getting lynched. It wasn't a ploy.

Might have been FAKE ANGER

 

[Ratchet]

Maybe we give Fuji his Alco lynch...

 

[Aurelian]

Yea but she never sacrifices herself or quits

That isn't point though. When she isn't a town alignment, she tends to be less comfortable, more reserved, less active, less vocal, this game was the first I think I've seen her play so actively but she still iirc blunder her claim and then further spewed when she hit Ekko with that PR ability.

Probably her team had to go with lynching her to salvage what they could from it.
Whether or not she fought against it in scum chat, I dunno.

 

[Ratchet]

You have a hard time believing that he’d bus Flower after Flower asked to be bussed in a hysterical rage at the game?

Yup, not worth considering.

 

[.guillo]

Youre the fucking cop lol and I only had 1 follower shot so unless Ratchet somehow manages to catch him killing someone how do you propose we get this mech?

Alexis claimed on day 2 when I asked him to claim because I checked him on n1.

I checked him cause he does fuck all. If I was a cop I'd just cop inactives too. Easier to justify just copping inactives.

Tweet has been very inactive, why not him when he was in Ultra's readlist that you pretty much agreed with on day 1, i dont get it.
And dont tell me it's because you play 4D chess like me.

 

[Fujishiro]

@Rugrat claim

How many times are you going to be no sold lol.

 

[Dr. Watson]

I got no readlist, most people who stupidly jumped off watson's wagon to pile on Melkor while the thread was slowing down, were in my town pile! You, Flower, Poyser, Ultra, Ekko are the ones i remember, and although i only have meta from Ekko, I had deduced that you guys are not inexperienced, you should know better. I don't understand why act scummy if you are not scum cause there is no way that at this point of the game, if Watson is scum, all her scum team are gonna out themselves trying to save her last moment UNLESS, a few dumb townies lead them first! And there lies my annoyance! I don't know who are the dumb town and the opportunistic scum there.

The optimal play is to lynch Watson, to find out if it was a scum vs scum wagon, or a scum vs neutral wagon. That'd give us more clarity to develop our reads. Why are we not pursuing it?

It is very obvious Poyser was the factional night kill, they pretty much strongarmed several people into voting out Melkor at EoD.

I'm more interested in their legacy which pretty much aligned with mine.


Vote Watson

Oh.. in that case there is more reason to lynch Watson no? We all agree that Watson is not town, we are just not sure which kind of evil is she.

I was asleep when he was, but i wouldnt have been convinced to switch. I had no reason to scum read Melkor, in fact, i still dont know what got him caught, im pretty sure Watson is not town and only scum would want to prolong their death further.

I still sustain that switching off from an outed evil to another player was irresponsible, we were lucky that the CFD paid off, it is usually never the case.

his earlier play doesn't make sense from a scum POV. going against the grain doesn't benefit him here in any way.

 

[Rugrat]

Yup, not worth considering.

It’s possible

Let’s lynch Ultra

 

[Ratchet]

Vote: Rugrat

 

[Dr. Watson]

no

 

[Ratchet]

Something might be wrong though, the pieces aren't dropping into place