• We're looking for artists. Direct message Dr. Watson for more info!

Game Ranked OLF Christmas Mafia 2023 (Day 9)

If I can successfully pick the player who won’t go first between Magic & Cal today, I should be in A++ position for my star requirement. So I’d appreciate help in knowing who is likely to go first.
 
Agree to disagree

Think this may just be borderline OMGUS from you

So here:
I need you to look at this and consider an alternative for why Magic is town and what gives you reasons to townread him from your POV

You can then proceed giving a case on why he's scum and I'll listen
I wanted Magic lynched ahead of Ral lol, so if there’s OMGUS - it’s him.

I never even said magic was definitely scum this phase. I said you were way too soon on giving him a town read when all he’d done literally nothing of consequence in the game other than claim a shit role. No I’m not OMGUS’ing you, I said you were town.
 
If I can successfully pick the player who won’t go first between Magic & Cal today, I should be in A++ position for my star requirement. So I’d appreciate help in knowing who is likely to go first.
No idea

We have an entire day, though

Can send your stars during the dayphase? Then wait until the 6 hour mark in the phase
 
What do you think happened N3?
one possibility is rugrat failed a kill on a bulletrpoof target / bodyguard protected target / commuter and then thought he was blocked so is claiming no result

there r other possibilities so we cant be 100% certain but nothing so far from flipped scum explains the 2 blocks n3 which leads me to think hes lying about it
 
I wanted Magic lynched ahead of Ral lol, so if there’s OMGUS - it’s him.

I never even said magic was definitely scum this phase. I said you were way too soon on giving him a town read when all he’d done literally nothing of consequence in the game other than claim a shit role. No I’m not OMGUS’ing you, I said you were town.
I didn't say you were OMGUSing /me/ to clarify

Where do you feel I was giving him an abrupt townread? What phase?

Can you please build both cases from your POV, I want to see where you're coming from on Magic specifically, not just why I was comfortablw reading him as town immediately
 
No idea

We have an entire day, though

Can send your stars during the dayphase? Then wait until the 6 hour mark in the phase
Yes! And I have the whole cycle to decide!

I would like everyone to be thinking about it though!

It will both help town to have everyone take a stance on that issue as a receipt for when the time comes and it will help yours truly.
 
This was earlier - Magic wasn't the only one to consider the possibility Ral was town. There were a couple of others - I think Evans? I'll dig through more posts soon

The mechanical frame is what put a dent in things, there was still room for a scenario of a town flip from Ral which is what was discussed. The limelight, however, was T-pein/Ral equity that overshadowed consideration for Ral being town, not that it wasn't considered
Right, so Magic is town because he said a player was possibly town and then lynched him anyway??
 
why is the card delivered start of night btw. if that was the case mafia can rly use it to tell sk who to shoot
 
This was earlier - Magic wasn't the only one to consider the possibility Ral was town. There were a couple of others - I think Evans? I'll dig through more posts soon

The mechanical frame is what put a dent in things, there was still room for a scenario of a town flip from Ral which is what was discussed. The limelight, however, was T-pein/Ral equity that overshadowed consideration for Ral being town, not that it wasn't considered
actually for anyone that read day 5 where tpein was lynched, which im sure was most of you, someone should have maybe clued into the fact that tpein wasn't even aware who the masons were. as in he thought it was X with someone besides ral. if it was a teammate he would have been aware. would have been a very helpful point at the time!
 
I always have to ask this question when I'm potentially being mislynched. When I flip Town. where does your solve go from there? What happens to your view of the game
 
Yes! And I have the whole cycle to decide!

I would like everyone to be thinking about it though!

It will both help town to have everyone take a stance on that issue as a receipt for when the time comes and it will help yours truly.
Hence why I'm letting discussion play out

It's impossible to predict because for me I want a cohesive solve

Without ISOing and delegating others to do some of the heavy lifting I can't give a confident prediction

Tag others to give their solves with only the player names
Like

(Their) PoE:
(Their) lynch preference:
(this way I can go back and just grab the solves to compartmentalize)

Need to streamline and simplify this, it's exhausting digging up the quotes with excess information
 
Back
Top