• We're looking for artists. Direct message Dr. Watson for more info!

Ranked One Piece Thriller Bark Mafia

Reader mode
Grammaton said:
Except he flat out refuses to scrutinise one player
Click to expand...

Rugrat said:
RUGRAT’S READS ACT 1

14/4+1/1

1. T-Pein™
5. Flower
9. The Orca
11. Aurelian
13. Grammaton
14. yohoho1996
16. Rugrat
17. Magic
18. Hans Tweetenberg
20. Dr. Watson

This is my five town core.

FLOWER

Town in my view. There seems to be little self awareness and high activity which is a town tell. I’ve not personally liked how she has gone around saying players are definitely scum, e.g. GAD and Luka - way too bullish. But scum are not usually bullish. I think that wanting a player lynched half way through day in myself is fairly questionable ironically considering what happened with Luka, but realism/pragmatism etc is something I’d associate chiefly with scum.

I think her expectation that people would just accept that her claim of main character was town seemed town. It’s usually town that have the “why are you not seeing what I’m seeing?” blinkers on for obvious reasons - scum generally would be more cautious about this type of thing.

THE ORCA

Slightly controversial one, but I think he is town. His play around the L-1 of Xadlin is what gives me pause. Very very few scum players would hesitate on a wagon like that and draw attention to themselves. In the mind of a scum player, that’s the time when it’s “let’s just quietly leave a vote” - there’s ostensibly the risk of being tied to the player at L-1 and Xadlin was fairly inactive so I’d not see much reason in scum going for the throat there.

AURELIAN

I reviewed Lethal’s posts and noticed a lot of hostilities here between Lethal and Aurelian. It didn’t read like distancing or bussing, and Lethal’s issues stemmed around Fang’s posts on Xad regarding his entrance to the thread. Reconciling a hypothetical Lethal/Fang/Xad axis - I don’t think a scum Lethal is going to play the 4D chess of bussing a teammate who is bussing another player. It would be incredibly counter productive as it puts the obligation on Lethal to push a teammate - a teammate who only pushed their comrade for thread control/equity. In my view, it’s a write off.

MAGIC

My belief is that Magic is town, his thoughts seem to be aligning with mine on some of the players in the thread. I also think a scum Magic is more keen to push me.

Considering the only reason he had NOT to push me if he was scum, would be to get me on his side - I don’t view this juice as worth the squeeze, as it’s resulted in scepticism from others with more thread control. In addition, I shat on his case from last game excessively where he was town and pushing me. For a scum magic, he’d probably work out from this that him pushing a case of any degree of quality may not lead me to suspect him directly. I think managing my slot without regard to his standing in the thread points to him being town, as he’d a be a little more neurotic in terms of his thread perception as scum.
Click to expand...

We can flip this.

Vote lynch Rugrat
 
The Orca said:
Vote Watson

now-shut-up-and-follow-me-bender.gif
Click to expand...

Grammaton said:
Vote rugrat
Click to expand...

T-Pein™ said:
Vote lynch Orca
Click to expand...

T-Pein™ said:
I think Rugrat is taking the piss.
Refusing to give 3 names top of his head.

Vote lynch Rugrat
Click to expand...

T-Pein™ said:
Thoughts on this?

Vote lynch Orca
Click to expand...

Magic said:
vote Watson

Actually fuck it. Rather see this. She did this exact same play last time I was scum with her where she survived every phase with basic activity while accusing and making a case on the most sussed player.
Click to expand...

Magic said:
unvote

Then again in hades despite being just as afk as here she never said it was due to not caring or being apathetic. Not even sure she addressed people calling her out at all that game for the way she was playing.
Click to expand...

Orca: Watson
Grammaton: Rugrat
T-Pein: Orca-Rugrat-Orca
Magic: Watson-Unvote

Wagons:
Watson 1
Rugrat 1
Orca 1

Let me know if there are any mistakes. Majority is 6 to hammer
 
After checking hades and hell's paradise I'm comfortable with Watson as town. She never flinches as scum or self hates in thread. She did in hades qt but wouldn't do it in the thread. Don't think she's faking that or the reaction to flower or her AtE directed at me so I'm comfortable that's enough factors that makes her town.
 
Lord Melkor said:
Orca: Watson
Grammaton: Rugrat
T-Pein: Orca-Rugrat-Orca
Magic: Watson-Unvote

Wagons:
Watson 1
Rugrat 1
Orca 1

Let me know if there are any mistakes. Majority is 6 to hammer
Click to expand...
T-Pein™ said:
We can flip this.

Vote lynch Rugrat
Click to expand...

Lord Melkor said:
Orca: Watson
Grammaton: Rugrat
T-Pein: Orca-Rugrat-Orca-Rugrat
Magic: Watson-Unvote

Wagons:
Watson 1
Rugrat 2
Orca 1

Let me know if there are any mistakes. Majority is 6 to hammer
Click to expand...
 
Reader mode
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top