• We're looking for artists. Direct message Dr. Watson for more info!

Game Ranked Grand Theft Auto Mafia

Status
Not open for further replies.
agree with ur read list for most part. just to devil advocate this tho - you also offered an "unsure" read on luka, which is more or less nullish, so them doing it too shudnt be a problem no?
The difference being I didn't present my reads as holding a position - being in "unsure" established that my read was not developed. My issue with their read was that they didn't present it as such, but rather as one that appeared to make a conclusion as to an alignment, while allowing for room to move off of that position which is where I start to find the original position ingenuine.
 
not yet as i just got to where u started posting, shud be town thus far
So there was a post you made regarding Sky where you said me asking her a question could have pressured- this carries the implicit understanding that I would be town there. I guess this sort of justifies that, given your closing comment.
 
the majority of players in a game are town

scum have in game communication that town dont have, letting them be aware and collaborate on things that town dont have.

scum will gang up on weak town like sharks/predators that smell blood/see the injured.

often times things that are look scummy are just people playing bad town. people playing bad town are often just that because scum are more image conscious and are thus more careful in what they do whereas town are emboldened by the fact they are town and thus nothing they could do could ever be scummy because they are town.

throw it in a pot mixed with observations of what "bad town play" looks like for a number of years and you can town read players across multiple sites!
When you put it like that it makes sense :hmm

I kind of wish I took one of your points into account more often, the fact that the outwardly Bad players are not necessarily scum. Would have meant the Cakey one could be less of a D1 policy
 
Don't really get why rdk would pick on me so directly as scum for being loose with town reads. Doesn't add up un my head. But if it does fo3 you guys I won't raise too much of a fuss and see if my reads are OK or if I would be better suited finding someone to buddy with to solve.

He's self aware enough to know taking an aggressive swing out of left field looks good

Most of his play looks a bit stilted
 
This is so wrong lol.
Its really not. That's his mo as town. Force a claim and move on.
i didnt know you respected ultra so much as a player
Respect just doesn't feel like the correct term. I'll get back to what does though.

I will say ultra is 1000 times better in all aspects than that doofy dude on fanverse
Vote lynch RDK

@Flower @Emil @Sky @Polar Bear @The Orca

Let's wagon this guy
We were just getting traction on emil though lol. I am feeling rdk a bit more over Emil now though

Vote rdk
 
so like this. the reason i hesitate with this is he did the exact same thing last game with my slot with ultra. he scum read me then town read me at eod1 then day 2 started and he scum read me without any elaboration.

unless you find the fact he gave elaboration here and it just didnt check out as the difference and why it's scummy in this scenario.
If you need me to respond to this specifically I will, but I think I mostly convered it.

I can accept wonky reads. It's just the starting point. It's how it progressed in totality combined with his defence and subsequent posting that I find to be more informative.

I'm not 100% sure because I feel like as a player, he can often lead to false positives, but I don't have a better lead from an argument perspective.
 
So there was a post you made regarding Sky where you said me asking her a question could have pressured- this carries the implicit understanding that I would be town there. I guess this sort of justifies that, given your closing comment.
well the first time i brought u up u were still NAI cuz u can be a teammate of sky prodding her without arriving at any major conclusion

after u got into more details with the read list + questioning gad's position on luka, im more confident putting u as town, and it fits well with ur initial post to sky

i see some ppl reading her town just for being open with her thoughts, even if they r scummy. i feel like some of her posts dont need to be made. im still combing through all of the players so if i find everyone more townish than her i'll pressure for her claim
 
well the first time i brought u up u were still NAI cuz u can be a teammate of sky prodding her without arriving at any major conclusion

after u got into more details with the read list + questioning gad's position on luka, im more confident putting u as town, and it fits well with ur initial post to sky

i see some ppl reading her town just for being open with her thoughts, even if they r scummy. i feel like some of her posts dont need to be made. im still combing through all of the players so if i find everyone more townish than her i'll pressure for her claim
I don't really subscribe to the reasons given to read her town either currently but I don't feel so strongly about her being scum at this point, so I want to let her play a bit. She's still in the lower half of my reads.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top