Game Ranked Grand Theft Auto Mafia

[Flower]

Is this often the case here? Godfathers claiming BP I mean.

I gave the GF a BP Fake just a game ago lol. Usually there‘s no duplicate roles here and it‘s hard for scum to fake claim unless they have good claimables. Like for example if a scum is a Roletracker (Role Cop + Tracker) they can fake claim Tracker, but if they have stuff like only a Ninja or a Strongman they p much have to fake Vanilla.

 

[Ultra]

Is this often the case here? Godfathers claiming BP I mean.

Godfather's being bulletproof is

In our ranked games however the default option to claim VT for mafia always exists. The answer to this question really depends on the player - someone who is experienced knows claiming BP is usually scrutinized so if they're scum they might not claim it at all. But other players might just want something they can claim besides literally nothing, etc.

 

[Achromatic]

Although the only thing keeping polar bear alive is everyone else's inaction. If we dream big enough anyone can die.

 

[Achromatic]

I gave the GF a BP Fake just a game ago lol. Usually there‘s no duplicate roles here and it‘s hard for scum to fake claim unless they have good claimables. Like for example if a scum is a Roletracker (Role Cop + Tracker) they can fake claim Tracker, but if they have stuff like only a Ninja or a Strongman they p much have to fake Vanilla.

I see. Feels like a bit of bias on your part to assume it must be a BP claim tbh. Not familiar with the host but it'd be an odd choice for the host to give the same fake twice in a row.

 

[Ratchet]

I mean sure, but I don't really see that enough from what he's said. Just looks like someone caught to me.

Like I said I expect I won't get my primary lynch so will probably be voting elsewhere. Maybe Tempest

Also I think Gad going the OMGUS route with me but entirely ignoring RDK doesn't really line up with what you're saying his method as town is, there would be no reason for him to discriminate there unless he thinks RDK's reasoning was good which he obviously doesn't given he contested it.

 

[Luka]

For what reason is Fuji town

I posted a bit earlier, I don't think they take the approach they did as scum.

 

[Achromatic]

I see. Feels like a bit of bias on your part to assume it must be a BP claim tbh. Not familiar with the host but it'd be an odd choice for the host to give the same fake twice in a row.

GF claim, rather.

 

[Luka]

I heavily disagree with this post, especially since you acknowledged what it would do

No. It is NAI. I do it as both alignments.

 

[Ratchet]

Also I think Gad going the OMGUS route with me but entirely ignoring RDK doesn't really line up with what you're saying his method as town is, there would be no reason for him to discriminate there unless he thinks RDK's reasoning was good which he obviously doesn't given he contested it.

The only answer I have to this really is he wasn't interested in RDK's posts which I find lends itself more likely from how he treats scum mates given he has deflected from suspicion from elsewhere.

 

[Luka]

All of Luka's posts on the first 4ish pages rub me the wrong way lol. They come across as statpadding. I thought that post about Ultra' fellow townies' comment was a joke, but turns out it wasn't :hogansun

Then this one:

What's the answer you're expecting here?

Why would I be expecting a specific answer? I was just curious to see if Watson has any self meta pertinent to the post.

 

[Flower]

I see. Feels like a bit of bias on your part to assume it must be a BP claim tbh. Not familiar with the host but it'd be an odd choice for the host to give the same fake twice in a row.

Well, BP roles are usually associated with scum or SKs and the host is under the belief setups should be more Town favoured as Town rarely wins here. So it would be weird if he put a BP Townie into this game when all it does is give scum a free mislynch.

Probably not good science, but yeah.

 

[Flower]

Actually let me check Rugrat‘s previous setup.

 

[Sky]

Fuji is probably town, I don't think that his approach as scum would be to openly skate the thread, basically not play, and come off with a read w/o any explanation whatsoever while at the same time ignoring prevalent slots in the thread that are more widely town read.

I also don't think a scum mindset would kind of blatantly troll at this point, with his first read being Ekko is towned.

I see

 

[Achromatic]

Well, BP roles are usually associated with scum or SKs and the host is under the belief setups should be more Town favoured as Town rarely wins here. So it would be weird if he put a BP Townie into this game when all it does is give scum a free mislynch.

Probably not good science, but yeah.

Sounds like a trap meant to punish town for assuming things, but that's my own hosting experience.

At some point if a role is too polarized hosts in a community will take corrective action.

 

[Ultra]

The only answer I have to this really is he wasn't interested in RDK's posts which I find lends itself more likely from how he treats scum mates given he has deflected from suspicion from elsewhere.

I didn't even notice RDK was shading him until you pointed it out.

For his lack of follow up after you did sure.

 

[Flower]

I see

Can you post Rugrat‘s old setup here please? He linked the game on Discord and I can‘t access the Wrestling Forum cuz no account.

 

[The Orca]

 

[Achromatic]

I also question why someone who is familiar with this meta would come back hours after being asked for a claim and drop the shittiest claim of all time.

If this was under pressure, in the moment, I could see that more.

 

[Flower]

I don‘t think Gad thinks much about fake claims as scum. He also completely botched his fake as the Serial Killer and didn’t even say what Magic told him to claim.

 

[Fujishiro]

Fuji Town, too.

Fake news.